Muslims are being punished for not migrating to Pakistan: Azam Khan rakes up partition pitch

[SIPRA]

But in 1947 your leaders agreed to the land that was carved out for your nation.

And Muslims were supposed to migrate. And millions did migrate.

Then you stopped taking them in further.

From where have you gathered this ridiculous idea that partition of India in 1947 was made on the basis of wholesale transfer of population on religious basis and Pakistan was meant to accommodate all the Muslims of India. Kindly refer me that document, which proclaimed, what you are saying.

 

[padamchen]

From where have you gathered this ridiculous idea that partition of India in 1947 was made on the basis of wholesale transfer of population on religious basis and Pakistan was meant to accommodate all the Muslims of India. Kindly refer me that document, which proclaimed, what you are saying.

Refer to the words of Jinnah. You don't need to look elsewhere.

Cheers, Doc

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

That's what you say today.

But in 1947 your leaders agreed to the land that was carved out for your nation.

And Muslims were supposed to migrate. And millions did migrate.

Then you stopped taking them in further.

So the wholescale migration stopped.

Hindus today (a very dominant percent I can confidently tell you as an Indian) feel miffed about that.

Cheers, Doc

NOT OUR PROBLEM. You guys can exterminate them all for all I care, miffed or not.

 

[SIPRA]

Refer to the words of Jinnah. You don't need to look elsewhere.

Cheers, Doc

Don't divert. Refer me those provisions of the legal documents, which resulted into independence as well as partition of India, which support a mass transfer of population, as you are claiming.

 

[American Pakistani]

Refer to the words of Jinnah. You don't need to look elsewhere.

Cheers, Doc

Jinnah also said entire Muslim regions, including IOK, Hyderabad Deccan, Kolkata, Junagadh/Manvadar, Gurdaspur, Ferozpur, etc.

Yep.

But, thanks to chutiya politicians two parts of Pakistan could not divorce peacefully...

Should've been done peacefully in 50's. Later on we got greedy politicians both in Pakistan and in Bangladesh.

I'll not go into present day details as I have no intention of derailing this thread.

 

[padamchen]

Jinnah also said entire Muslim regions, including IOK, Hyderabad Deccan, Kolkata, Junagadh/Manvadar, Gurdaspur, Ferozpur, etc.

Agree. But the moth-eaten India idea was never going to float.

The basic premise remained though a homeland fir the Muslims if the subcontinent.

This "race" angle is modern Pakistani invention.

As is the Indus angle.

Cheers, Doc

 

[Rafi]

Allah ka karam hai my ancestors heeded to Quaid's call and made that arduous journey in 1947.


Sher ki aek din ki zindagi geedhar ke hazar saal ki zindagi se behtar hai

We are proud to have you as a brother and citizen, live long, and prosper.

 

[padamchen]

Don't divert. Refer me those provisions of the legal documents, which resulted into independence as well as partition of India, which support a mass transfer of population, as you are claiming.

I'm not diverting but directing you to the words of the father of your nation from the time your nation was birthed.

What more holds credence over that?

Cheers, Doc

 

[American Pakistani]

Agree. But the moth-eaten India idea was never going to float.

The basic premise remained though a homeland fir the Muslims if the subcontinent.

This "race" angle is modern Pakistani invention.

As is the Indus angle.

Cheers, Doc

Both of which are true angles.

 

[padamchen]

Both of which are true angles.

They are revisionist narratives of a populace still looking for an identity unique and separate from Hindus.

Cheers, Doc

 

[Type59]

If your ethically same as your neighbours, why are you considered foreign, only difference is religion?

Seems like RSS have realised all the different ethnic groups in India have little in common, hence relying on religious nationalism.

 

[padamchen]

If your ethically same as your neighbours, why are you considered foreign, only difference is religion?

Seems like RSS have realised all the different ethnic groups in India have little in common, hence relying on religious nationalism.

Very perceptive.

They are reading from your playbook.

Cheers, Doc

 

[SIPRA]

I'm not diverting but directing you to the words of the father of your nation from the time your nation was birthed.

What more holds credence over that?

Cheers, Doc

Obviously, your claims are totally unfounded. Pakistan didn't came into existence, by conquest, but by a legal process, which was fundamentally executed by the British, albeit with the consent of Indian National Congress and All India Muslim League. There was absolutely no provision of any involuntary transfer of population, on religious basis, in any document, whatsoever, which governed the partition of India and creation of Pakistan. You are totally concocting and fabricating this claim, which has no basis.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Agree. But the moth-eaten India idea was never going to float.

The basic premise remained though a homeland fir the Muslims if the subcontinent.

This "race" angle is modern Pakistani invention.

As is the Indus angle.

Cheers, Doc

Can you prove that modern day Pakistanis and indians are racially the same? Can you prove that the great Indus Valley Civilisation is NOT situated in modern day Pakistan?

 

[Thorough Pro]

That's what I said, what is happening to them right now is the start of naked aggression against them, either they can continue to cower and learn from the history and rise up against hindu tyranny. the sooner they do it, the stronger they do it the lesser will be sacrifices and misery. The bitter fact is hindus will butcher them one by one, it has already started with the lynchings, the sooner they realize and stand up, the sooner will they get freedom. Its going to be bloody, but either you bleed while fighting or while being lynched is their choice. Once they stand up, then the wolrd will take notice and some might come to help in one way or the other.

This is not only for Muslims of India, this is true for all minorities and casts.

Muslims of India have to resurrect themselves but it is easy said than done. Kashmiris did not stand in one one day!
Muslims of India did best they could under the circumstances. Pakistan supposed to be a tower of light and support but after 71, they gave up. Now it is total Hindu tyranny. It is not that you take few AK's and go to mountains. It is world's largest tyrannical power. This is what Qaid-e-Azam (Allah Mercy Upon Him) and Iqbal foresaw. They gave us Pakistan. Millions gave their lives. Thousands of Muslims mothers and daughters gave their honor. Thousand were kidnapped and still lived in the houses of Sikhs.

Long live Houses of Sharif's! Long Live Houses of Bhutto's-Zardari's. This is what we brought in this Islamic Republic of Pakistan.