Mumbai Attacks

[robincrusoe]

Of course Pakistan should verify whether this is credible or not.

But if it is found to be the truth?

If it is found to be truth, the culprits will be punished and will be jailed where they will be provided with cell phones, TV and other luxuries so that they can function from the jail just like Omar Saeed Sheikh (the killer of Daniel Pearl). Omar Saeed Sheik's case has been postponed at least 100 times (I'm not kidding) by the court.

Just google to find the information that I'm talking about.

 

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

If it is found to be truth, the culprits will be punished and will be jailed where they will be provided with cell phones, TV and other luxuries so that they can function from the jail just like Omar Saeed Sheikh (the killer of Daniel Pearl). Omar Saeed Sheik's case has been postponed at least 100 times (I'm not kidding) by the court.

Just google to find the information that I'm talking about.

That sort of thing happens with almost every powerful individual with resources and money at their disposal who goes through the court system.

It isn't restricted to people like Omar Saeed.

The institutions and systems will evolve and mature with time, just as they will in India, where the legal and law enforcement institutions are also plagued with rampant corruption and inefficiencies.

 

[Vinod2070]

^^ I don't think that would be the only expectation from Pakistan (assuming that Pakistan does only these things).

It is not only the perpetrators of this massacre that need to be punished but further tragedies of this nature need to be stopped as well.

There is news of Nadim Taj being the main planner of this attack. Some ex-SOF guy planning and training the attacks etc. The net has to be cast wide to cover all perpetrators and not just against whom India has been able to present evidence.

That is if Pakistan is really serious about the whole thing.

 

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

There is news of Nadim Taj being the main planner of this attack. Some ex-SOF guy planning and training the attacks etc. The net has to be cast wide to cover all perpetrators and not just against whom India has been able to present evidence.

There is only baseless speculation here, as such there is no basis or need for casting a 'wider net'.

The GoP can only work within her constitution - putting the alleged perpetrators through a trial will be the most it can do in terms of the Mumbai attacks.

As for preventing future attacks, it is not humanly possible from a developing country as large as Pakistan, with developing and inefficient institutions. Taking action against banned groups such as JuD and LeT is what Pakistan can do to some extent, and it has, as evidenced by statements from the JuD and LeT's own leadership that their operations have been severely restricted.

Even Israel, with is mammoth operation, control and blockade of significantly smaller territory has said that it will not be able to stop attacks on Israel completely.

 

[ajpirzada]

please yaar don't rely on us we must sing old song because we love old songs.we just say india is free what she wana say and do we don't care.

and already india blame us and say too much abut us on world forums now why we take action??

calm down brother. if we think we are not involved then lets study the evidence and prove wat we say. and if ppl from pak are found involved then they should be taken to court coz killing of civillians can never be justified. will be gud for both pakistan and india. and after we have dont wat we possibly can, if india complains we will have a reason to show them the middle fingure.

 

[Communist]

They do. That is what we are waiting for.

Yes Pakistan is a sovereign country, it has the right to examine the evidences whatever india provides as also it has the right to punish (if there is anyone in Pakistan involved in the terror acts in india, which indian leaders claim) the accused persons according to the Pakistani law. Though it is offtopic, but at the same time it is very relevant to discuss that just after the mumbai incident, indian leaders and media houses started accusing Pakistan in an insulting way. Many derogatory headlines and comments were published in indian english and vernacular news papers and the indian govt went to the extent giving Pakistan two demarches, demanding a number of accused persons, which is insulting for any sovereign country and thereby breaking up the normal relation once again. India could have provided the evidences without doing such a big drama. Such a melodramatic country india is that it always seeks extra attention and sympathy from the world while trying to pose itself as a big brother of south Asia.

Just after the Mumbai incident what indian leaders did was like this >>

 

[ajpirzada]

Why wont you co-orprate with us..??? Can't you give peaceful dialogue a chance??? Well i agree.. that india shouldnt have accussed and asked pakistan to do something for which evidence is handed over NOW..!!!! But the denial also came swiftly from pakistan and i believe a coverup was also orchastrated by the ISI or the army..?? So if you think whatever comming from india is wrong, and whatever from pakistan is wrong.. when and how is this all going to end.. its only through these people to people contact like these wee can know more about each other..!!! Here too if your closing doors.. then God Bless this part of the world..!!!!

i agree with u that we need to work together. but for that the first thing we need is to build trust coz otherwise u wont believe in wat we say and same will go for us.

 

[Neo]

Of course Pakistan should verify whether this is credible or not.

But if it is found to be the truth?

Here's your answer:

Pakistan will act if evidence is credible: Gilani ​

Monday, 05 Jan, 2009

​

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan said on Monday it was reviewing a dossier India handed over regarding the deadly Mumbai attacks in November, which triggered fresh tensions between the two rival countries, AFP reported.

Meanwhile, Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani said the government remained committed to punishing Pakistani nationals accused of taking part in the Mumbai attacks if ‘credible’ evidence is given against them.

In Islamabad, a foreign ministry spokesman confirmed that Pakistan’s High Commissioner to India had received the file in New Delhi on Monday and had sent it to authorities back home.
‘The material has been received in Pakistan now and is being examined by concerned authorities,’ the spokesman said.

‘It is our duty, my duty to examine the dossier carefully, understand it and be truthful to myself, to my country and the neighbourhood,’ Pakistani Foreign Minister Shah Mehmood Qureshi told Reuters.

Gilani made the comments during talks with Richard Boucher, the US assistant secretary of state for South and Central Asia, who arrived in Islamabad early Monday in a bid to defuse simmering tensions between Pakistan and India.
Gilani spoke of ‘Pakistan’s persistent efforts to defuse current tensions with India, and the government’s commitment to take action against any Pakistani national in case credible evidence is provided,’ his office said.
Pakistan has repeatedly said that its own investigation of the attacks could move forward once India shared evidence with Islamabad.

The US ambassador to India, David C. Mulford, told reporters in New Delhi that his country had helped India gather evidence and that the US ‘will pursue this matter to its conclusion.’

Prime Minister’s Adviser on Interior Rehman Malik said, however, ‘we will not take pressure from anyone.’
‘We are a sovereign state, and we will act according to our law,’ Malik said. ‘Nobody can put pressure on us.’

 

[Silverfalcon]

My leaders are greedy

Yours are idiots and inhumane.

 

[shrivatsa]

My leaders are greedy

Yours are idiots and inhumane.

They are not idiots ,they may be corrupt but when it is the question of the nation they do what is best for us.

 

[Silverfalcon]

They are not idiots ,they may be corrupt but when it is the question of the nation they do what is best for us.

They do what is best for themselves.

This whole Mumbai thing, they told you guys that People that had linked with Pakistan did this.

Wonder why they did it ?

Cause they could save their own azz, they know the only thing that will unite india would be to say something ill about Pakistan.

 

[roadrunner]

Wonder if it has the truth serum results in it.

 

[Vinod2070]

Also if the "kalava" has been put in the dossier or not!

 

[shrivatsa]

They do what is best for themselves.

This whole Mumbai thing, they told you guys that People that had linked with Pakistan did this.

Wonder why they did it ?

Cause they could save their own azz, they know the only thing that will unite india would be to say something ill about Pakistan.

No they said that because killers were from Pakistan,we don't need barbaric incidents to unite us that will be superficial.

Not people linked with Pakistan but Pakistani "non state actors" did it.

 

[roadrunner]

Also if the "kalava" has been put in the dossier or not!

Lol, I'm 105% sure there'll be no mention of the Kalava