Mohajir province need of the hour: MST

[Sugarcane]

Similar ethnic background.
Ethnic divisions are what are exploited by vested interests.

Ultimately, people themselves are responsible for this exploitation - not specific to Urdu Speaking, Sindhis as well.

 

[SQ8]

I am living in Iran since few years but i can't speak Farsi and also don't have too much knowledge about their culture and traditions, mostly i spend my free time with Pakistani community here, but i have few good Iranian friends and living peacefully, Can you say that i am mixed-up with Iranians.

Isnt that what is important?
Why are you trying to force a mix-up..
The idea is to celebrate diversity.. and accept it.

 

[lem34]

If we go back far enough are we not all Mohajirs? My family 7 generations Punjabi but previously came from Jammu. But my family and I regard our self as Punjabi or Pakistani as anyone??

 

[darkinsky]

If we go back far enough are we not all Mohajirs? My family 7 generations Punjabi but previously came from Jammu. But my family and I regard our self as Punjabi or Pakistani as anyone??

giving up on one's true identity is really not cool

i dont know this, but why is that some kashmiris and pathans go to lahore and punjab and become punjabis, but when kashmiris and pathans come to karachi they want to be remained kashmiris and pathans?? do you guys have danda on you by punjabis??

how can people who dont want to be identified as sindhis, but as pathans and kashmiris expect us urdu speakers who esp built this country to be identified as sindhis?? we had lost all our property to come to pakistan and dont want to lose one last thing such as identity

 

[Sugarcane]

Isnt that what is important?
Why are you trying to force a mix-up..
The idea is to celebrate diversity.. and accept it.

I think you holds a different definition of mix-up than me, the mix-up i am talking about can't be forced, it's volunteer acceptance of others and enjoying while being in their company. You have to understand each-others culture, customs & traditions to understand each-other than comes the acceptance and celebration of diversity.

I think your definition of mix-up is in a town houses are occupied by different ethnicity is mix up, If that's that case than there is no need to have more arguments.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

giving up on one's true identity is really not cool

i dont know this, but why is that some kashmiris and pathans go to lahore and punjab and become punjabis, but when kashmiris and pathans come to karachi they want to be remained kashmiris and pathans?? do you guys have danda on you by punjabis??

how can people who dont want to be identified as sindhis, but as pathans and kashmiris expect us urdu speakers who esp built this country to be identified as sindhis?? we had lost all our property to come to pakistan and dont want to lose one last thing such as identity

1.4 million kashmiris alone migrated from india...aswell millions of punjabis ... so dnt brag abt how u lost what... urdu speakers had been comming to Pakistan till the 90s...

Also people assimilate in a society...lots of punjabis also live in NWFP and speak pashto.. just like kashmiris n pashtuns who speak punjabi n pashtu yet dnt retain their culture n idenity... unlike urdu speakers who dnt actually have a real identity of theirs... its a mixture of ethnic groups frm hyderabad,up,bihar etc heck they even claim to be pashtun... dnt they? so whats the big deal?

 

[lem34]

giving up on one's true identity is really not cool

7 generations man. We still go by the name Butt. But if you go back further what defines you when do you become Punjabi lets say100 years 200 years 1000 years? When do you become where you are?

 

[Uchiha]

We can call ourselves Karachiites. End of discussion? It's easier on the tongue too and sounds way cooler than the other proposals

 

[Sugarcane]

i dont know this, but why is that some kashmiris and pathans go to lahore and punjab and become punjabis, but when kashmiris and pathans come to karachi they want to be remained kashmiris and pathans?? do you guys have danda on you by punjabis??

That's funny, you have to visit Punjab. Pathans & Kashmiris etc. don't call themselves punjabis while in Punjab - They feel proud being called Pathans, Kashmiris, Balochs and no body mind it.

 

[darkinsky]

1.4 million kashmiris alone migrated from india...aswell millions of punjabis ... so dnt brag abt how u lost what... urdu speakers had been comming to Pakistan till the 90s...

Also people assimilate in a society...lots of punjabis also live in NWFP and speak pashto.. just like kashmiris n pashtuns who speak punjabi n pashtu yet dnt retain their culture n idenity... unlike urdu speakers who dnt actually have a real identity of theirs... its a mixture of ethnic groups frm hyderabad,up,bihar etc heck they even claim to be pashtun... dnt they? so whats the big deal?

urdu speakers dont have identity of their own??? and why is that??? you are not properly making your point, some urdu speakers are pathans who's ancestors settled in india long time ago, dont they have rights to call themselves pathans?? you are not implying that urdu speaker pathans like abdul qadeer khan are making all it up do you??

hyderabadi cooking is separate from behari and UP cooking, like we always get surprised when our neghbour sends some aftaari and its completely different from the normal food we eat

btw balochis living in karachi dont like to speak sindhi they speak balochi

 

[Sugarcane]

We can call ourselves Karachiites. End of discussion? It's easier on the tongue too and sounds way cooler than the other proposals

Also kick on the a$$ of ones who call you Muhajirs and tries to divide based on ethnicity

 

[Sugarcane]

urdu speakers dont have identity of their own??? and why is that??? you are not properly making your point, some urdu speakers are pathans who's ancestors settled in india long time ago, dont they have rights to call themselves pathans?? you are not implying that urdu speaker pathans like abdul qadeer khan are making all it up do you??

hyderabadi cooking is separate from behari and UP cooking, like we always get surprised when our neghbour sends some aftaari and its completely different from the normal food we eat

btw balochis living in karachi dont like to speak sindhi they speak balochi

Ok - If you want to maintain your ethnic identity than go with the original one

 

[darkinsky]

Ok - If you want to maintain your ethnic identity than go with the original one

whats wrong with urdu speakers?

We can call ourselves Karachiites. End of discussion? It's easier on the tongue too and sounds way cooler than the other proposals

karachiite is for every one who lives in karachi, like younus khan, shahid afridi, zaheer abbas

 

[Sugarcane]

whats wrong with urdu speakers?

As Pakistani Nationalist has pointed out, Urdu speaker is mixture of different ethnic groups.

 

[Fracker]

new province will create more mess, and new bread of discrimination will start i.e. behari urdu speakers, lakhnu urdu speakers, sindhi urdu speakers or punjabi urdu speakers etc, provinces must be desolved and city government type structure must be started, where a person who get vote from the city remain in the city and responsible for the city.

as far as mahajir province concern, this is a solagn to capture Karachi city. and increase bloodshed in the karachi