Making Karachi a province

[batmannow]

Yeah just cuz more population doesn't mean more provinces.

What we lack is good local govt. otherwise new provinces won't make as big impact. It'd just mean another CM, another VIP jet, another cabinet etc.

Doesn't matters how many local govts been made they still will be controlled by provincial govts , their budgets will Stoll be stuck with them, so making more provinces will , let more freedom.to local govts ?

 

[Devil Soul]

Doesn't matters , I am proud of them all , I tried my best , but failed miserably , even though 37 bones inside my body been broken.
But giving the names of provinces on our shaheeds name will kill , all the stupid , dam eithinicity used by politicians all over Pakistan ?

Sadly No, its the mindset which needs to be changed...

 

[batmannow]

Sadly No, its the mindset which needs to be changed...

Kill both of them brutally , friend ?lolzzz
You only get , that from a kargill warrior,s mind ?lolzzz

 

[Jaanbaz]

Offcourse it is but huge opposition like sindhi nationalists , PTI & PPP .. No one cares about PTI any way they have very little support or representation in karachi or urban sindh but they can make a big fuss in National assembly however we need to have support of rural sindhis .. new province can be named Southern or South Sindh or Sindh 2 .. it doesnt change a thing except will help administration better.

Best idea so far. Just make two provinces out of Sindh=North Sindh & South Sindh. Punjab should be divided into West and East Punjab. Baluchistan into two provinces, New province for Hazara in KPK, Tribal Areas be renamed into something the Tribal people want and made a province so that the people can decide their own fate not some civil bureaucrat in Rawalpindi/Islamabad.

 

[Fracker]

All provinces should be abolished and Pakistan should be divided in Administrative Divisions.
(The whole infrastructure is already in place)

Punjab- 9 Divisions
Sind - 7 Divisions
KPK - 7 Divisions
Baluchistan - 6 Divisions, (can be increased to 7 Gwadar)
GB - 2 Divisions
AJK - 3 Divisions

There shouldn't be any province or provincial government. District Government should take care of the cities, while national issues.

 

[third eye]

All provinces should be abolished and Pakistan should be divided in Administrative Divisions.
(The whole infrastructure is already in place)

Punjab- 9 Divisions
Sind - 7 Divisions
KPK - 7 Divisions
Baluchistan - 6 Divisions, (can be increased to 7 Gwadar)
GB - 2 Divisions
AJK - 3 Divisions

Politicians will lose their job ..and their clout.

How will they then make money if everything is handled by the Divisional Commissioner ?

 

[saurav]

Not needed what needed is local government bodies

How so..? Both are different solutions imo.

 

[haviZsultan]

The divisions should be turned into provinces. It will ease the governance structure in the country.

 

[Patriots]

 

[airmarshal]

Not on MQM demand. NEVER.

the reason is simple. MQM through its 30 years politics has created so much polarization, any such demand by it will be met with violent and vociferous denunciation. MQM has created the rural urban divide more stark than before. If MQM needs rights, so do Sindhis.

Province should be based on administrative delineation not ethnic. Even though Karachi being a huge city needs its own govt, demand coming from MQM is construed as an ethnic demand.

This is why I m always against politics based on ethnic identity. It creates fissures and muddles the environment where even genuine demands are met with skepticism.

 

[JOEY TRIBIANI]

Need of an hour . ( i am not a supporter of mqm )

 

[Jazzbot]

Sindh should be divided to make more provinces, same goes for Pubjan and rest of the provinces. But provinces for specific ethnic groups is a big NO. Especially for Muhajirs, who call themselves Muhajir even after becoming Pakistanis for around 70 years and their leader called creation of Pakistan biggest blunder in history of mankind.

 

[Patriots]

Not on MQM demand. NEVER.

the reason is simple. MQM through its 30 years politics has created so much polarization, any such demand by it will be met with violent and vociferous denunciation. MQM has created the rural urban divide more stark than before. If MQM needs rights, so do Sindhis.

Province should be based on administrative delineation not ethnic. Even though Karachi being a huge city needs its own govt, demand coming from MQM is construed as an ethnic demand.

This is why I m always against politics based on ethnic identity. It creates fissures and muddles the environment where even genuine demands are met with skepticism.

As I am against ethnic divide ... So in my opinion Punjab, Sindh, Khyber Pakhtoonkhwa & Balochistan should be renamed ... Would you support it...?????????

 

[salmanACCA]

i am also in favour of another province but after MQM terrorists are wiped out

 

[Gunsnroses]

I will also vote for it and for other provinces provided that terrorist leaders of MQM of Karachi, and terrorist leaders of MQM of Punjab aka PMLN are hanged.