Leaked report: Pakistan had 'major failures' during OBL incident

[Saleem]

who was DGMO at that time?

 

[Sedqal]

I hear you bro. I hear you.


Look, you gotta realize that our army (and by extension) our country gets badly needed hard currency from Uncle Sam.

Every one does. China does it, India does it, So does S Korea and Japan.

Just the mode of earning money is different. And there is no shame in earning money. As long as your earn your keep.


Pak army in case of Ben mofo Laden was genuinely worried, that his killing will result in some nation wide Islamist revolution.

So they didn't want to get Ben's blood on their hands.

and simply asked Americans to do the dirty work.


peace



Thanks meray bhai. Thank you.

Did the mofos in Pakistan Army think for a second how humiliating it will be for Pakistan, a nation already being accused of being a terrorist hub? They could have killed him and dropped his dead body in Pak-Afghan border where everyone thought Laden was hiding.

Why would they do such a thing if not $. (it still is an assumption). Yesterday in a program General Hamid Gul said that he was sure some one in ISI was protecting Laden and brought him here. He also said that for him that person was a hero. This is the pathetic state of affairs in Pakistan.

 

[third eye]

Pak army in case of Ben mofo Laden was genuinely worried, that his killing will result in some nation wide Islamist revolution.
So they didn't want to get Ben's blood on their hands.
and simply asked Americans to do the dirty work.

Ha ha

That was a very smooth attempt to cover up a gigantic SNAFU.

Ppl in Pak may believe this or similar stories as it would suit them , the rest of the civilised world will find it preposterous !

This implies that the recent commission was all balls & so was its findings or the author of this story considers himself to be the smartest kid in the block.

Another story please..

 

[airmarshal]

Of course!! This ia major failure.

If this not a failure, then having foreign troop in the country for two hours, well inside Pakistan, is a failure. Failure of intelligence and defense of the country. And its the failure of Army and intelligence. But these two institutions will never accept their mistake. So forget it.

 

[GURU DUTT]

Many may actually be conspiracy theories, but the interviews of local residents immediately after Abbotabad Raid was quite different. All of them were unanimous in voicing the following:

1) Curfew was imposed before any operation, Everybody was ordered to remain indoors.
2) Soldiers were patrolling the streets.
3) Electric power to the area was shut off.

Some other things to consider:

1) What was the real objective of Raymond Davis an his team.
2) Why was the OBL compound destroyed? It was the only real peace of evidence that existed.
3) Why was OBL buried at Sea? I mean seriously, why?

Finally, the most important thing. What was the impact of OBL operation around the world, what was the impact on the US Presidential elections? And were not many analysts predicting production of OBL before these elections, to influence their outcome?

well of all the pakistani Posters i think you have some valid questions Sir

i was watching special program on the OBL commision report on al jazeera last night where among others there was senior retiered officials of CIA & PA among many were the General from pakistan and after listening to his and the cia guys answers i had a strong feeling that CIA and PA both knew about the OBL Raid in advance and the PA gave USA the OBL so they dont have to face the hostile musick from both from within the ARMY(some obl sympathisers officers) & Civilians(ghairat brigade) and the media so they asked the USA do to the dirty work

and to show how serious USA was it compromised one of its so called stealth chopper

but the funny thing is that nobody gave any serous thought when a big flying machine blew up some few hundred meters from the PMA & they even then went owt safeli after compleating the mission with all the gear , prisnors , evidence & other things they gathered from the site and flew back safeli while remaing for more than a hour in pakistani air space & its hillaious that the PAF dint knew

nobody can beleve this at least there must have been some police in there pickets for general security around the area as it has the PMA & it is well known that many serior retired PA , ISI & other Generals and elite officers are "rihaish wazeer" in abbotabad

so i have doughts that PA , ISI officials dint knew about this raid and they might have feeded information about this so called "super hot patato" according to the CIA official on al jazeera program and PA,ISI & PAF genrals & Officers were handsomeli paid for the same as it is very clear that ISI has a very very big say in internal security and intellegence gathering assets in almost all the areas of Pakistan and abbotabad is like dehradoon of pakistan

 

[Awesome]

The most alarming thing is how he made his house. Moving about in a place like Pakistan isn't that great of a deal...but a 3 storey mansion!!!

Firstly it was made on a fake NIC and an old one, only CNIC's are to be used for buying and selling property. Then he made a 3 storey house in a blatant violation of building codes of the area. Then the huge walls and fort like structure. When our neighbors bought the plot next door and made a new house in place of the old one, they were making huge walls...we went and asked them about it. Maybe it's just in our community, the practice of knowing your neighbors is slowly decreasing in Pakistan.

That's easy too, 1000 rps note at every junction can fix any issue.

 

[Axis Of Logic]

What has happened to Hamid Gul!!? Watched him on Times Now claiming that Osama was not an enemy of Pakistan and it is, indeed, an achievement to hide Bin-Laden in PK for 9 years!!

 

[Jango]

What has happened to Hamid Gul!!? Watched him on Times Now claiming that Osama was not an enemy of Pakistan and it is, indeed, an achievement to hide Bin-Laden in PK for 9 years!!

There are 2 people in Pakistan who have gone bonkers yet are still being entertained...Dr AQ Khan and Hamid Gul.

 

[Parul]

There are 2 people in Pakistan who have gone bonkers yet are still being entertained...Dr AQ Khan and Hamid Gul.

I too watch Hamod Gul's Interview and Had a Good Laugh

 

[GURU DUTT]

I too watch Hamod Gul's Interview and Had a Good Laugh

can u give the link


Please

 

[Developereo]

There could be a bright side to all this. Better to be surprised by hostile American choppers than Indian ones.

After all, failure, however humiliating, can be a learning experience and a wake up call.

Is it?

 

[Saleem]

just confirms what a sorry lot the top leadership of the forces is..DGMO crying that they were betrayed...PAF chied and DCAS (Ops) doing the same....they should have contingency plans for all eventualities....the whole lot should be coutmartialled and shot....Malick the newman had a good point--even if they known they would and could have done nothing........

 

[Awesome]

COAS Kayani has to be dishonorably discharged in the wake of this report. From beginning to end - it was his failure the most.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Somebody should ask him right away - what about the countless innocents killed by his ideology? If Osama is a 'not an enemy', then Pakistan does not need enemies.

What has happened to Hamid Gul!!? Watched him on Times Now claiming that Osama was not an enemy of Pakistan and it is, indeed, an achievement to hide Bin-Laden in PK for 9 years!!

 

[muse]

COAS Kayani has to be dishonorably discharged in the wake of this report. From beginning to end - it was his failure the most.

And uey no such thing will happen - if you think about it, Mr. Gen. Kiyani as DG ISI and COAS have been disastrous for Pakistan, however, Pakistan's larger problem is not so much Mr. Gen kiyani but the so called Pakistan Army.