Kerala School Drops Vande Mataram from I-Day Programme as Radical Group Objects

[Iggy]

Some time people think that India is all about Hindu's.... and Everything done is by Hindu Radicals......

I know her for a long time.. Its her fashion to blame everything on Hindu radicals.. Even a muslim chopped the hand of a Hindu guy, she will blame the Hindu guy..

 

[punit]

I was surprised to since Kerala is the most Educated state in India

education has nothing to do with intellectual narrowness. Out of all states Kerala was the only one still supporting Left and Congress!

 

[Spring Onion]

Hey Onion I am not running away...the most famous version of Vande matram was composed by a muslim so you call him a non-muslim???
Enanu theryama olaratha kannu...
I did not point you I asked to whole of your countrymen who supported it or ignored it as internal thing....

Well if you think all are becoming one certainly my friend who provided biryani jus few days back for Ramadan isn't becoming one...Don't squirt the issue that reply was never intended to you it was to INDIANs from Kerala..

did i call him Hindu? the hindus are imposing it simple as that and the author was a known anti-Muslim figure.

and you also know that Anand math was also not something neutral. its full of anti-Muslim rhetoric.

as far as China and Pakistani posters i cant speak for them.

 

[nair]

I know her for a long time.. Its her fashion to blame everything on Hindu radicals.. Even a muslim chopped the hand of a Hindu guy, she will blame the Hindu guy..

She is entitled have her opinion..... Let us try to give her feel of ground reality..... By the way i just realised you also became a Radical Hindu

 

[Iggy]

When you make singing of vande mataram compulsory in schools then its FORCED.

Indeed when comes to imposing Hindu religious believes its difficult to understand word secularism for you Indians

Quit making up stories.. Where did you find the song was forced to sing in the school.. You are good at fabricating stories for your convenience..

 

[trueINDIANpatriot]

did i call him Hindu? the hindus are imposing it simple as that and the author was a known anti-Muslim figure.

and you also know that Anand math was also not something neutral. its full of anti-Muslim rhetoric.

as far as China and Pakistani posters i cant speak for them.

First stop dreamin all the muslims and hindus are at logger heads ..here my best mate is muslim..The issue that is being discussed here is there was no issue all these while and if suddenly this pops out we have the right to be suspicious..
Cant blame all the people of particular religion for it...
You cannot unite people from across border just based on religion atleast not in the Indo-pak context...no matter howmany times you call em brothers here they will still kick a$$ if you get in to our border..

 

[Spring Onion]

I am not ignorant at all .... you out of similar beliefs does have tendency to support Muslim by hook n crook whether they are on wrong side...... I don't neither support imposition nor support encroaching in religious beliefs.......

Muslims who are objecting to it in this case are NOT wrong. So surely i side with them.

I have many Muslims friends especially from Maharashtra n Gujrat(Bohra Muslim from Surat & Indore) even a Kashmiri Muslim who do sing the same song with same pride as we do....

Those who bow to idols are not our concern these Muslims who want to sing can do that not our problem since they already bow to idols they are already out of Islamic faith so we dont object if they have no issue.

The main point here is WHY vande mataram be compulsory in Indian schools?

 

[Iggy]

Good in a way, the rats are exposing themselves to the anti terrorism agencies.

The scary thing is that, even though they do not have much support.. They managed to field candidates in every constituency in Kerala.. Their income source should be checked.. Its becoming a matter of concern.

 

[Iggy]

Those who bow to idols are not our concern these Muslims who want to sing can do that not our problem since they already bow to idols they are already out of Islamic faith so we dont object if they have no issue.

The main point here is WHY vande mataram be compulsory in Indian schools?

Since when you become the custodian of Islam faith dear?? Who give you the authority to brand who is a muslim and who is a non muslim??

 

[Spring Onion]

First stop dreamin all the muslims and hindus are at logger heads here my best mate is muslim..

Where did i say that?

The issue that is being discussed here is there was no issue all these while and if suddenly this pops out we have the right to be suspicious..
Cant blame all the people of particular religion for it...

Indeed. But rifts over vande mataram are older than partition. Its not sudden popping up

 

[nair]

The scary thing is that, even though they do not have much support.. They managed to field candidates in every constituency in Kerala.. Their income source should be checked.. Its becoming a matter of concern.

Well they fielded one of their strongest candidate in malappuram, and expected to get a good amount of votes... Infact When i asked the CPM workers, whey are you wasting your time in campaign, they replied me SDPI may get some votes, which might help us.... But when the result came every one was surprised to see the votes they got....They do not have much support in their own community... But they need to be watched and watched very carefully...

 

[Spring Onion]

Since when you become the custodian of Islam faith dear?? Who give you the authority to brand who is a muslim and who is a non muslim??

you dont need any authority. its basic rule of Islam anyone who bows to idols is NOT a Muslim simple as that.

And am not custodian of Islam.

Why are you running short of reasoning ?

Why vande mataram should be sing in Indian schools????

 

[trueINDIANpatriot]

Muslims who are objecting to it in this case are NOT wrong. So surely i side with them.




Those who bow to idols are not our concern these Muslims who want to sing can do that not our problem since they already bow to idols they are already out of Islamic faith so we dont object if they have no issue.

The main point here is WHY vande mataram be compulsory in Indian schools?

Where did i say that?



Indeed. But rifts over vande mataram are older than partition. Its not sudden popping up

Read you replies where in you have cited that muslims are raisin against the evil Hindus...

Now stop that sh*t of separating us as Hindus and Muslims we are Indians period.

 

[nair]

The main point here is WHY vande mataram be compulsory in Indian schools?

I guessed you missed my post #84......

 

[Echo_419]

education has nothing to do with intellectual narrowness. Out of all states Kerala was the only one still supporting Left and Congress!

Well there is that also

It was not compulsory..... I would like to invite your attention to the OP




How can this be compulsory?????There is a cultural event is happening and there is a group which want to perform with a song "Vandematharam".... Does that makes entire HIndu's of kerala Radicals?????? Come on!!!!!!

There are cases where in Oppana is performed in school, There are cases where Daff muttu is performed in school (both of them are arts based on muslim culture) No one complains, Even this so called Radical Hindu's

This will defenitely pave the way for BJP to expand in Kerala