Kerala School Drops Vande Mataram from I-Day Programme as Radical Group Objects

[nair]

what you think they would have angered the Hindu radicals and ruin their business? just look at the response from your Hindu countrymen just because one school stopped its singing.

Anyway coming to the core issue which is vande mataram, why should it be sung for the same of Hindus? when you have Jana Gana Mana'?

Again i will bring back to the point.... No one is forced..... If some one dont want to sing Vande Matharam, They dont need to..... But one cannot force others not to sing either.....

 

[Spring Onion]

None forced to sing that ....
Why should i need to cry for pakistani text book material i merely mentioned i m not surprised how n why radicalism spreaded into pakistani society at large .......

I also am not surprised why India is full of radical hindus NVM

Again i will bring back to the point.... No one is forced..... If some one dont want to sing Vande Matharam, They dont need to..... But one cannot force others not to sing either.....

Schools are educational institutes so why a religious song be imposed on students to sing in India when you also claim to be champion of secularism ?

 

[nair]

)))))))))))))))))))))))))) you mean Indian Muslims should move out?



If NOT Then why vande mataram a controversial Hindu song which had been an issue even before partition?

why dont you accept that you are also biased

I am not.... I live in a society which probably you wont understand or can imagine.... My point is If some one is forced to sing then you are right..... But no one is forced here... And i know very well the designs of SDPI because i lived in a place very close to thier head quarters.... And i used to play cricket next to its HQ

I also am not surprised why India is full of radical hindus NVM



Schools are educational institutes so why a religious song be imposed on students to sing in India when you also claim to be champion of secularism ?

You know there are Christian schools which uses christian songs for prayer... No one stops them either... I know it is difficult to understand the word secularism.....

This school is owned by a Muslim and this place has a significant population of Muslims.....

 

[trueINDIANpatriot]

what you think they would have angered the Hindu radicals and ruin their business? just look at the response from your Hindu countrymen just because one school stopped its singing.

Anyway coming to the core issue which is vande mataram, why should it be sung for the same of Hindus? when you have Jana Gana Mana'?

If worried so much abt other's internal affairs where did you guys go when China banned people from fasting???
Does the taller than mountain hides these things from ya??I have seen many paks answering them as China internal affairs so if its with India its the same now stop advising us...

@Kerala:Wats happenin??? too many news nowadays abt extremism emanating from Kerala..I have been to kerala to muslim home.. they were jus so welcoming .. now wats this shit in between?Guys throw out the communists and congress first...

 

[Spring Onion]

I am not.... I live in a society which probably you wont understand or can imagine.... My point is If some one is forced to sing then you are right..... But no one is forced here... And i know very well the designs of SDPI because i lived in a place very close to thier head quarters.... And i used to play cricket next to its HQ



You know there are Christian schools which uses christian songs for prayer... No one stops them either... I know it is difficult to understand the word secularism.....

When you make singing of vande mataram compulsory in schools then its FORCED.

Indeed when comes to imposing Hindu religious believes its difficult to understand word secularism for you Indians

 

[Indrani]

)))))))))))))))))))))))))) you mean Indian Muslims should move out?



If NOT Then why vande mataram a controversial Hindu song which had been an issue even before partition?

why dont you accept that you are also biased

Yes, we gave them Pakistan where they do not have to sing Vande Mataram. So they should go there if they feel oppressed.

 

[Spring Onion]

If worried so much abt other's internal affairs where did you guys go when China banned people from fasting???
Does the taller than mountain hides these things from ya??I have seen many paks answering them as China internal affairs so if its with India its the same now stop advising us...

you are running away.

if you can debate issues about Pakistan so can we.

and as far as china is concerned go ask those who supported that ban NOT me.

@Kerala:Wats happenin??? too many news nowadays abt extremism emanating from Kerala..I have been to kerala to muslim home.. they were jus so welcoming .. now wats this shit in between?Guys throw out the communists and congress first...

yeh when Muslims object to Hindu extremism these Muslims just become extremists

Yes, we gave them Pakistan where they do not have to sing Vande Mataram. So they should go there if they feel oppressed.

Wrong. Those who knew your radical nature moved out and those poor Muslims who put their trust in you Hindus and remained in India supported you are now ask to leave by radical Indian hindus.

These poor souls were of the believe that they wont be forced to sing hindu song vande mataram but they were highly mistaken.

Today people like you are telling them to sing vande mataram or go to Pakistan

 

[Iggy]

what you think they would have angered the Hindu radicals and ruin their business? just look at the response from your Hindu countrymen just because one school stopped its singing.

Where in the heck did Hindu radicals come in to play here?? Where did you see Hindu radicals forced anyone to sing Vande Matharam.. Its just not Hindu countrymen.. Many people here are just frustrated because of this.. I am one of them.. Your support for all the ill doings of some people just because they are Muslims has not gone unnoticed.. This is very sick phenomena..

Anyway coming to the core issue which is vande mataram, why should it be sung for the same of Hindus? when you have Jana Gana Mana'?

This song was sung in every school and other instrtutions during independence day.. Why make it a religious issue?? If you dont want to sing, then dont sing it. Nobody was forcing any one to sing it.. Its our national song and no one have any right to stop it from singing..

 

[nair]

When you make singing of vande mataram compulsory in schools then its FORCED.

Indeed when comes to imposing Hindu religious believes its difficult to understand word secularism for you Indians

It was not compulsory..... I would like to invite your attention to the OP

According to Hindustan Times, the TKM Centenary School in Kollam was to have a dance planned on Vande Mataram, which is a popular song played as a patriotic symbol on days such as the Independence Day.

How can this be compulsory?????There is a cultural event is happening and there is a group which want to perform with a song "Vandematharam".... Does that makes entire HIndu's of kerala Radicals?????? Come on!!!!!!

There are cases where in Oppana is performed in school, There are cases where Daff muttu is performed in school (both of them are arts based on muslim culture) No one complains, Even this so called Radical Hindu's

 

[trueINDIANpatriot]

you are running away.

if you can debate issues about Pakistan so can we.

and as far as china is concerned go ask those who supported that ban NOT me.




yeh when Muslims object to Hindu extremism these Muslims just become extremists

Hey Onion I am not running away...the most famous version of Vande matram was composed by a muslim so you call him a non-muslim???
Enanu theryama olaratha kannu...
I did not point you I asked to whole of your countrymen who supported it or ignored it as China's internal thing....

Well if you think all are becoming one certainly my friend who provided biryani jus few days back for Ramadan isn't becoming one...Don't squirt the issue that reply was never intended to you it was to INDIANs from Kerala..

 

[Indrani]

Wrong. Those who knew your radical nature moved out and those poor Muslims who put their trust in you Hindus and remained in India supported you are now ask to leave by radical Indian hindus.
These poor souls were of the believe that they wont be forced to sing hindu song vande mataram but they were highly mistaken.
Today people like you are telling them to sing vande mataram or go to Pakistan

Too bad. We live in a harsh world. We will have to deal with the cards we are given.

 

[illusion8]

Good in a way, the rats are exposing themselves to the anti terrorism agencies.

 

[utraash]

You are ignorant. You need to read other groups also objected to this controversial hindu religious song .

And why you want an exception for Hidnus here? Jana Gana Mana' is your national song/anthem so why impose vande mataram just for the sake of Hindus?

I am not ignorant at all .... you out of similar beliefs does have tendency to support Muslim by hook n crook whether they are on wrong side...... I don't neither support imposition nor support encroaching in religious beliefs.......
I have many Muslims friends especially from Maharashtra n Gujrat(Bohra Muslim from Surat & Indore) even a Kashmiri Muslim who do sing the same song with same pride as we do....

 

[nair]

So if some one object the view of a muslim, He automatically become a "Radical", Then i have no hesitation in calling myself a "Radical"

 

[lightoftruth]

When you make singing of vande mataram compulsory in schools then its FORCED.

Indeed when comes to imposing Hindu religious believes its difficult to understand word secularism for you Indians

Here comes a citizen of Islamic republic giving lecture on secularism without knowing a shit.

"

Mr. President: There is one matter which has been pending for discussion, namely the question of the National Anthem. At one time it was thought that the matter might be brought up before the House and a decision taken by the House by way of a resolution. But it has been felt that, instead of taking a formal decision by means of a resolution, it is better if I make a statement with regard to the National Anthem. Accordingly I make this statement.

The composition consisting of the words and music known as Jana Gana Mana is the National Anthem of India, subject to such alterations in the words as the Government may authorise as occasion arises; and the song Vande Mataram, which has played a historic part in the struggle for Indian freedom, shall be honoured equally with Jana Gana Mana and shall have equal status with it. (Applause). I hope this will satisfy the Members."

http://parliamentofindia.nic.in/ls/debates/vol12p1.htm

its part of the freedom struggle used to be sung by everyone including muslims much before secularism was added in the constitution ,for few losers and failed political outfits only an idiot can generalize an entire community.