R&AW is/was part of IB ?
Kashmiri man Air Commodore Hilal Ahmad Rather who played key role in Rafale’s India journey
- Thread starter INDIAPOSITIVE
- Start date
I wish you power trying to understand Pakistan but you won't be able to. So why not give up on it?
Why some other country has any kind of expectation from other countries
That's like saying ISI takes dictation from IB. No way!
I was just telling the pot that he is more black then kettle
In India R&AW takes work force from IB , you cant compare R&AW with ISI . R&AW is civilian wing while ISI is quasi paramilitary force ....you can compare ISI with DIA which is still led by a Lt. From minority community
In India R&AW takes work force from IB , you cant compare R&AW with ISI . R&AW is civilian wing while ISI is quasi paramilitary force ....you can compare ISI with DIA which is still led by a Lt. From minority community
Trango Towers
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Oct 29, 2016
- Messages
- 21,951
- Reaction score
- -18
- Country
- Location
With more than 3000 hours of accident-free flying on MiG 21s, Mirage-2000, and Kiran aircraft,
Looooooooool
Looooooooool
namefield_empty
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Mar 19, 2019
- Messages
- 2,653
- Reaction score
- -8
- Country
- Location
Indeed, as an Islamic Republic, Pakistan finds itself in the glorious company of Afghanistan, Iran and Mauritania..
And the baggage that comed with it.
xeuss
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Aug 22, 2019
- Messages
- 4,355
- Reaction score
- 6
- Country
- Location
I disagree. A token poster boy is usually a political appointment to serve a political purpose. Examples that come to mind are Giani Zail Singh who was made President of India during the Sikh crisis of the 1980s or Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed after the 1971 war.
With around 15% of Muslim population, Muslims lag behind on every social indicator and subject to discrimination at all levels. The few people like SA Ibrahim and Air Commodore Hilal Ahmed who make the top ranks are extraordinary individuals whose talents and expertise stand above and beyond all, that even a discriminatory society like India has no option but to promote them.
There are two factors that work against such people. One is the Muslim name and the other is the normal bureaucratic infighting that goes along with the territory. For a Muslim to overcome such adversity and move to the top, is indeed an achievement that must be appreciated.
However, when we measure the success of a community within society, we should not take the few examples of brilliant individuals and use it as a yardstick. Success of a community is measured by the overall performance of the community, and sadly, in that regard, the Muslims lag far behind the Hindus at every social/economic/educational level.
Last edited:
https://www.outlookindia.com/magazine/story/muslims-and-sikhs-need-not-apply/233087
Excerpt:
"From 1969 till today—RAW’s current staff strength is about 10,000—it has avoided recruiting any Muslim officer."
Where do they teach English in indya?
They are talking about the agents which work on adhocs and ares borderig Pakistan are mainly non muslim majority areas .... like smugglers , I gave you the name of chief of IB who is muslim by faith and just FYI IB also operates in Pakistan
Areesh
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Mar 30, 2010
- Messages
- 45,157
- Reaction score
- 3
- Country
- Location
Control the islamphobia man. You aren't a Switzerland either
Trust WikiLeaks.
Excerpt:
"No reason was stated for the curt instruction on Muslims. They were also kept away from handling sensitive posts in RAW and Intelligence Bureau (IB) with the exception of Syed Ibrahim, who recently retired as the chief of IB."
Read more at: https://www.deccanherald.com/content/488755/intelligence-agencies-not-favour-involving.html
Dude ,I dont know why R&AW is such a big thing for you guys , real valuable intelligence is with NTRO and IB ....R&AW is a dud to best a tea club of IPS...... and no one knows the actual strength of R&AW and forget about the faith of officers .
Whats the source of information about the faith of officers of R&AW , Asif Ibrahim was the chief of IB which is by all means more powerful then R&AW strength wise , budget wise and resources wise.... capable muslims did attained some very very powerful position in India on the basis of their sheer hard work and capabilities
Dr APJ kalam achieved more then any Indian can on the basis of sheer hardwork
Whats the source of information about the faith of officers of R&AW , Asif Ibrahim was the chief of IB which is by all means more powerful then R&AW strength wise , budget wise and resources wise.... capable muslims did attained some very very powerful position in India on the basis of their sheer hard work and capabilities
Dr APJ kalam achieved more then any Indian can on the basis of sheer hardwork
Is that why clouds block radar waves because NTRO advises to chaiwallah directly?
Now stick to the point.
Excerpt:
Intelligence agencies in India have long followed an unwritten ‘no entry’ policy for Muslims (though there have been a few Muslim officers in the IB), while Sikhs are banned from SPG, formed in 1984 to provide security to the prime minister, and the National Security Guard (NSG), the elite anti-terror force functioning under the Union Ministry of Home Affairs. “This is not a new policy. There have been no Muslim officers in RAW since its formation in 1969,” says a former RAW officer. “It has its own reasons for following this policy.”
http://old.tehelka.com/the-bias-against-minorities-in-intelligence-recruitments/
Similar threads
