Karachi should be made a separate province

[priti]

i think not just karachi , sindh should separate. if you see the votes are all regional. NS wone only in punjab and ppp only in sindh and pti only in pashtunpur and that decided who the PM is. this is not the right way as Punjab will rule pakistan and this proves that every state of pak is a separate country.

 

[W.11]

Making Karachi a seprate Province will give MQM half victory for their dream to have a sperate country.

My answer is NO.

but MQM also has hyderabad in the pocket and we arnt talking about hyderabad, why will MQM want separate country without hyderabad?

i think not just karachi , sindh should separate. if you see the votes are all regional. NS wone only in punjab and ppp only in sindh and pti only in pashtunpur and that decided who the PM is. this is not the right way as Punjab will rule pakistan and this proves that every state of pak is a separate country.

it also seems this time pakistan has the most divided mandate, PMLN has only come to power because one single province gave them absolute amount of seats even gave them clear majority

gotta say this will create even more division then previous time

pakistan surely needs some form of presidential system to bring voices of smaller provinces or it wont end well

 

[priti]

^^ but coalition politics has different problems

 

[Spring Onion]

i think not just karachi , sindh should separate. if you see the votes are all regional. NS wone only in punjab and ppp only in sindh and pti only in pashtunpur and that decided who the PM is. this is not the right way as Punjab will rule pakistan and this proves that every state of pak is a separate country.

i think youy should keep your long nose to yourself.

And i also think Tamil Nadu should be a separate country. rather South India should be a separate country . This is so unjust that South Indians impose their tamilian terrorism on others specially Sri Lanka.

Mahrashtian terrorism, or to say Bal Thakray, RSS. VHP. Bajrangi and so on proves that every state in India is a separate country.

 

[W.11]

i think youy should keep your long nose to yourself.

And i also think Tamil Nadu should be a separate country. rather South India should be a separate country . This is so unjust that Sount Indians impose their tamilian terrorism on others specially Sri Lanka.

Mahrashtian terrorism, or to say Bal Thakray, RSS. VHP. Bajrangi and so on proves that every state in India is a separate country.

lol cat fight @priti @Spring Onion

 

[Spring Onion]

if PTI demands it will be seen as punjabi invasion also, that punjab wants to divide sindh and make karachi punjabi influenced, karachi is important port and punjab has no port dont you think it will irk sindhis more than it will irk them because of MQM?

MQM has the mandate of karachi since 20 years and if suddenly PTI comes to the scene where will this action be showed as? punjabi domination?

any further suggestions?

lets play ethnicity card, MQM demands local bodies and it is also seen as dividing sindh by ethnicity now where the hell local bodies divide sindh on ethnic grounds? please explain sir!

i think after 20 years MQM and karachi deserves to get it mandated applied to the city, MQM has taken all the blames for the incompetencies of sindh government i think MQM deserves it more than your supposed suggestion for PTI to have it rather than MQM

i think karachi will go to the gutter once again if it is not made a separate province

and nobody said Mohajir or hindustani domination for MQM so far?

are you MQM guy? i am sure you are.

Karachi for the first time stood against MQM gundagardi . MQM had been going to rigged mandate for last 20 years.

Time for change. And stop this nonsense like Punjabi, Sindhi etc etc . despite rigging MQM faced a fall, despite nationalist slogans our Pukhtun national party faced a bad fall.

the only option is perform and get votes.

PML- N got vote because they had worked for Punjab as a ruling party in the province. PPP miserably failed to initiate any even while at center.

whereas ANP failed us badly and we here in KPK can bring even a peon if he performs if NOT we dont care even if he is a king.

in interior Sindh its always biradry vote and PPP has a strong base there or you can say individuals there have birdary vote.

MQM was only have control in Karachi and now people are fed up of their ghundagardi. Be it an aam MQM man a streetboy or wealthy person which MQM had been claiming given chance , well whats the difference? their strings are in hands of Altaf Hussain and they are as much ghundas as any

lol cat fight @priti @Spring Onion

i dont fight with cats i take down giants

 

[W.11]

the only option is perform and get votes.

there you are, the gist of my post

In Karachi Zardari had 100% control because the Sindh CM was his guy, but his own brother, Tappi, was the real de-facto CM making all the decisions.

People blame MQM for all the mess in Karachi, but they had almost no control in running the city. They had a governor but the governor has no power.

MQM cannot perform if there is not local body system because of the reasons above, so the only chance is that MQM implements the LG system itself which is only possible through a separate province because in PPP govt its impossible

im centain, no, infact im confident that PTI will perform badly in KPK in the long run, they are very immature, PMLN is clever, it wont let PTI succeed and neither PTI has enough maturity and guts to make bold decisions until unless suddenly it get matured which i dont think will happen any time sooner, just stay tuned

 

[A.Rafay]

That wont solve ANY problem. The provinces/SEZs need to be developed on administrative basis. Turkey might be a good blueprint for us.

Lol there's a province named BATMAN in turkey! We should name sindh as SpiderMan!

 

[Bratva]

If whole sindh agrees on this fact, than karachi be made another province. Karachi is not Jageer of MQM where everything should be done as they wishes. It's a part of sindh

 

[W.11]

If whole sindh agrees on this fact, than karachi be made another province. Karachi is not Jageer of MQM where everything should be done as they wishes. It's a part of sindh

if its a part of sindh then why are sindhis behaving like a step father to karachi? why do they start crying is LG system is in place in sindh or karachi?

 

[Bratva]

if its a part of sindh then why are sindhis behaving like a step father to karachi? why do they start crying is LG system is in place in sindh or karachi?

it's the politics silly, elites controlling the minds of Harri's just like MQM control minds through fear factor. Plus You still call yourself mohajirs instead of sindhis, then how come sindhis will allow a minority wish to be accepted in such manner?

 

[W.11]

it's the politics silly, elites controlling the minds of Harri's just like MQM control minds through fear factor. Plus You still call yourself mohajirs instead of sindhis, then how come sindhis will allow a minority wish to be accepted in such manner?

because we live in one idiot?

if its politics then karachi wants different political environment it is striving for since 65 years? karachi never had PPP mandate where as PPP has always controlled and destroyed karachi

 

[Bratva]

because we live in one idiot?

if its politics then karachi wants different political environment it is striving for since 65 years? karachi never had PPP mandate where as PPP has always controlled and destroyed karachi

Now I understand, why MQM never raised this issue Sindh assembly, they would be eaten alive by all sindhi's in no time. If only mandate is the factor that karachi should be made another province, Pashtun majority areas in karachi should be made another province, Urdu majority areas should be made another one, Liyari should be merged with balochistan.

 

[Mav3rick]

@W.11, Altaf Hussain has already called for Karachi to be "detached" from rest of Pakistan. Are you agreeing with Altaf Hussain?

AH has never 'called' for such a detachment and rather left the decision to the administration to either accept the mandate of the city or to separate it. Basically, you accept the mandate of the people of Karachi and everything is hunky dorey, you don't and well......we got problems.

 

[Musalman]

I support the idea but creating only a Karachi province will create resentment in the Sindhi population. I suggest all divisions of Pakistan be converted into a province.