The US immigration laws are based on nationalities (which is basically discriminatory based on nationality then) but not based on Religion - the CAA+NRC is looking at religion of people and only singling out Muslims. If a law states that illegals from Bangladesh shall not be allowed, that may be acceptable. But if it says only illegal Muslims won’t be allowed and rest can get rights, then your issue is not with Illegal immigrants but only with Illegal Muslims (i.e discriminatory based on religion). Imagine if US law said that Hindus from India shall not be granted visas? But Sikhs, Christians etc. can?
You are right about Indian supreme court, for Indians it can surely decide what ever it wants by declaring Muslims as less equal humans. Joe Biden and rest of the world is not obligatory to follow Indian supreme court and is entitled to formulate its own policies. And then in the end Indian muslims can also decide what political discourse they want to take as well, they can either accept their status as second class citizens or do something else about it.
Well that's the law. When Bangladesh has declared itself to be Islamic state, and this law is supposedly for discriminated minorities, then questions will arise how it will be given to majority of those countries.
Remember India hasn't banned migration. Every year people get citizenship. From Pakistan, BD, Iraq etc. We prefer to treat our illegals differently due to unique historical incidents in 1947. Basically everyone can be treated equal only if they are from a place where everyone is equal. Since they are not, the question of discrimination arise, and is also the basis of India's caste based reservation system which I wholeheartedly support.
As for the US, their discrimination is based on race, then nationality and religion. Whoever tells otherwise is kidding. I would say Canada is one of the few really open countries around at this time. But at the rate they are doing, I would not be surprised if there is another local Trump in next 15 years.
Yes few countries have Free Visa policy with USA and it works both ways like American don't need any Visa to enter those countries either. But that didn't give them the right to work in USA without a work permit. I know Brits Canadian and European citizens who got deported because they were found working without a work permit.
I mentioned about minimal paperwork if you read my post. If a company in US wants to hire someone from white majority nations, the process is almost fast. A week or 2 at best. I can't remember the countless times I have got job interview offers across the border assuming I am Canadian. Its not the same when trying to hire from non white majority countries. I mean if India were to be offered reciprocal visa opportunity India would lap it. But would US do?
There you go- discrimination.
You're wrong again. You cannot.. Again cannot work in the united states without proper work documentation. You can only work if you work off the books. There are countries that the United States has agreements with and you can visit those countries without Visas but they cannot work here and you cant work there. Don't spread misinformation because you have no idea what you are talking about.
Lastly, the US is a migrant-friendly country and has immigration quotas for most countries. It also provides work visas for people across the world. Certain people are not allowed in the United States because they break immigration laws. It has nothing to do with racism or discrimination. If you are from a poor country and visit the US, you are more likely to break the immigration laws for work opportunities but it has nothing to do with color.
America is not a banana republic like India so do not spew bs here, please.
Gosh. How tough it is to even read my post properly? Or suddenly US is now Pakistanis Supreme buddy after bashing them all week long to support China?
I said 'minimal paperwork'. Do you know what it means? It means US company can hire someone from white majority countries in 2 weeks at best. Paperwork is fast for them. Can the same companies do the same for countries like India or any African countries for that matter? Even good African ones? Hell NATO partner Turkey hasn't got that. You know the reason. They aren't white nor Christian.
I have seen my Canadian friends move across the border for work as if changing another company. Its easy.
Discrimination is discrimination. The way we want to call it differs. If me and another guy applied for the same green card or citizenship, both have contributed equally to US, and yet only I have to wait longer to get the same just cos I am from a country where application is longer or non white country? The Americans call it law and it's their land their rules. The way India treats her foreign illegals is also our land our rules. If anyone should fight it, it's Indians that should do it. Not an American white guy.
