kankan326
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2011
- Messages
- 5,217
- Reaction score
- -13
- Country
- Location
Japan had overwhelming advantages in almost all aspects to China back then. China's territory size and population were bigger than Japan for sure. But in 1937 Japan empire was Japan+Korea+Taiwan+Manchuria combined. China looks big but it was a separated country and most of its population were illiterated. So China was not even in dominant position in territory size and human resources.I didn't call it as "China being the aggressor". I said they initiated a total war that they were not ready for. For the sake of saving the run away Chinese communists. It was losing (as expected since they were not ready) in that war that makes it easy to pass what happened as an invasion initiated by the Japanese. So the the cause of all the Chinese suffering you guys keep hammering about was partly sown by that very Chinese initiation. That doesn't mean Japanese remorse about that war has no place. But the Chinese did walk into it. If they waited until the Nationalists were better prepared and more developed, then the same objective of getting Manchuria or reducing Japanese rights in Shanghai coykd have been achieved, possibly bloodlessly even due to natural change in power. But that woukd grant the Nationalists even greater credibility over the run away communists now wouldn't it. So such a conclusion is not acceptable for the Pro-CCP posters.
Try getting off the Black-and-White-only state of mind.
It was only Japan that could decide when and where to start a war. It was only Japan that could decide the war scale. If Japan didn't want to wage the war, the war would simply not happen. The war broke out simply because many Japanese(not all) wanted to start a war with China. All the "Chinese attacked first" are just pretexts.
Last edited: