Jallikattu ban lifited

[Maravan]

In alanganallur "vaadi vasals" are under huge police protection, not able to open the bulls.. In karaikudi surrounding area yesterday morning jallikattu was conducted in an open ground which belong to an oil mill... Yesterday a newly formed kadaladi supreme court in ramanathapuram district vacated the SC order on jallikattu ban and jallikattu planned on Monday..

 

[Maravan]

In a federal system all state have certain level of autonomy but a central body will always have overreaching powers this is the case with all federal system like US, Mexico, Germany, Brazil. If we didn't have this kind of balance of power we could never have abolished practices like untouchability.

US Germany aren't countries having very diverse cultures like india.

States simply have no autonomy in any policies.. You tell me one section where a state decision can not be over turned by the centre?

And which state supported untouchability that centre has to overturn? All the states were united against abolishing this.. This is the second time after kashmir where a states wish is overturned.

 

[Lonely Hermit]

US Germany aren't countries having very diverse cultures like india.

States simply have no autonomy in any policies.. You tell me one section where a state decision can not be over turned by the centre?

Not by the centre but by the court the central legislative just to win votes will accept all kind of bull shit. Your argument should be judiciary vs legislative. The legislative will always be populist but the judiciary will always have to follow rule of law. That is why I said such a balance power is important in society like ours.

 

[Maravan]

Not by the centre but by the court the central legislative just to win votes will accept all kind of bull shit. Your argument should be judiciary vs legislative. The legislative will always be populist but the judiciary will always have to follow rule of law. That is why I said such a balance power is important in society like ours.

I am not questioning what judiciary has to follow. If legislative process itself a flaw, there is nothing to do with judiciary since it has to follow rule book of the flawed system. Flaw in legislation = flaw in judiciary.

What's the rule of law here? If accepted by the majority, minority's can not have a say and the law will be implemented irrespective of the state and it's concern. There is no unity in diversity here.

You didn't remember why Bangladeshis revolted against Pakistan at first point? Law was to accept urdu, even if a complete bengali state wasn't ready to accept. Like that indian parliament is passing laws which is not at all acceptable for a complete state.

Even if we want to move ahead, this sick indian system is pushing our state back. When hindi was imposed in 1960s irrespective of the states concern, a brutal revolt stopped hindi in TN. It's like if you want your requests to be heard do brutal revolts, we won't accept any request comes in a genuine way, is the Indian mentality.

 

[Darmashkian]

@Maravan @Bombermanx1
Jallikattu & Bull racing is common in Southern AP too

https://twitter.com/x/status/688191000695578624

https://twitter.com/x/status/688198883617288195

Tamil Nadu village defies SC order, hosts jallikattu with 65 bulls - Times of India

Many Andhra Pradesh villages defy SC, hold Jallikattu - Times of India
We Telugus & Tamils really have a lot in common with each other


There stupid imbecilic anti-Hindu jobless animal rights lovers should go get a job or work towards banning the slaughter of goats during Bakrid!!

 

[Bombermanx1]

3000 year old Hindu Customs are targeted by court!. Please use people power to bring back sati...

Sati,Jauhar were started to protect dignity of women from Islamic Invaders who would even rape the corpses of women after their conquest.There are no Islamic invaders now, if they ever try their Homelands will be a nuclear wasteland for 10000 years.
So understand where Sati,Jauhar,Ghoonghat,purdah and Khaps came from, it was a Necessity in that time to be safe from Islamic Invaders.

Tamil Nadu village defies SC order, hosts jallikattu with 65 bulls - Times of India

Massive Egg on face of Supreme Court.Like i said Supreme Court cannot rule against the will of people to stop a 3000 year old tradition.

 

[mooppan]

@Maravan @Bombermanx1
Jallikattu & Bull racing is common in Southern AP too

https://twitter.com/x/status/688191000695578624

https://twitter.com/x/status/688198883617288195

Tamil Nadu village defies SC order, hosts jallikattu with 65 bulls - Times of India

Many Andhra Pradesh villages defy SC, hold Jallikattu - Times of India
We Telugus & Tamils really have a lot in common with each other


There stupid imbecilic anti-Hindu jobless animal rights lovers should go get a job or work towards banning the slaughter of goats during Bakrid!!

We have 'bull eating'' competition in Kerala,our 2000 year old tradition...

 

[Bombermanx1]

@Maravan @Bombermanx1
Jallikattu & Bull racing is common in Southern AP too

https://twitter.com/x/status/688191000695578624

https://twitter.com/x/status/688198883617288195

Tamil Nadu village defies SC order, hosts jallikattu with 65 bulls - Times of India

Many Andhra Pradesh villages defy SC, hold Jallikattu - Times of India
We Telugus & Tamils really have a lot in common with each other


There stupid imbecilic anti-Hindu jobless animal rights lovers should go get a job or work towards banning the slaughter of goats during Bakrid!!

Supreme Court or no court cannot stop Bakrid likewise it cannot stop Cock fights during Sankranti In Andhra and Jallikattu in TamilNadu and AP.It will happen as always and even the law cannot do anything about it.

We have 'bull eating'' competition in Kerala,our 2000 year old tradition...

2000 year old? Jesus was born 2000 years ago, how come he came to Kerala 2000 years ago?

 

[Lonely Hermit]

I am not questioning what judiciary has to follow. If legislative process itself a flaw, there is nothing to do with judiciary since it has to follow rule book of the flawed system. Flaw in legislation = flaw in judiciary.

What's the rule of law here? If accepted by the majority, minority's can not have a say and the law will be implemented irrespective of the state and it's concern. There is no unity in diversity here.

You didn't remember why Bangladeshis revolted against Pakistan at first point? Law was to accept urdu, even if a complete bengali state wasn't ready to accept. Like that indian parliament is passing laws which is not at all acceptable for a complete state.

Even if we want to move ahead, this sick indian system is pushing our state back. When hindi was imposed in 1960s irrespective of the states concern, a brutal revolt stopped hindi in TN. It's like if you want your requests to be heard do brutal revolts, we won't accept any request comes in a genuine way, is the Indian mentality.

As i stated before "You need to follow due legal process in civilized society not rant and spread propaganda about perceived suppression of Tamil."
Was Supreme Court oppressing Tamils when it asked Karnataka to release water or asked kerala to raise mullaperiyar dam height. You are just a frog in a well who hasn't seen the wider world

 

[mooppan]

Supreme Court or no court cannot stop Bakrid likewise it cannot stop Cock fights during Sankranti In Andhra and Jallikattu in TamilNadu and AP.It will happen as always and even the law cannot do anything about it.


2000 year old? Jesus was born 2000 years ago, how come he came to Kerala 2000 years ago?

what it has to do with Jesus??..Telegu language(Telegu identity) is barely 1900-2000 years old...Is that means there was no one living in Andra Pradesh before 1900-2000 years??... Don't mix religion with ethnicity..I am talking here as a Malayali...

 

[Bombermanx1]

what it has to do with Jesus??..Telegu language(Telegu identity) is barely 1900-2000 years old...Is that means there was no one living in Andra Pradesh before 1900-2000 years??... Don't mix religion with ethnicity..I am talking here as a Malayali...

Because only Jesus people talk about eating Bull as a tradition.

 

[mooppan]

Because only Jesus people talk about eating Bull as a tradition.

If bull racing is a tradition for you telegus,so does bull eating for us non sanghi Malayalis..
Who are you to question our centuries old tradition???..

 

[Bombermanx1]

If bull racing is a tradition for you telegus,so does bull eating for us non sanghi Malayalis..
Who are you to question our centuries old tradition???..

You non Hindus came into picture only after portugese came and made you eat beef under Inquisition.
We will question as it hurts our sentiments.

 

[mooppan]

You non Hindus came into picture only after portugese came and made you eat beef under Inquisition.
We will question as it hurts our sentiments.

what Portuguese???...You are confusing us with goan Christians,i think.

 

[Maravan]

As i stated before "You need to follow due legal process in civilized society not rant and spread propaganda about perceived suppression of Tamil."
Was Supreme Court oppressing Tamils when it asked Karnataka to release water or asked kerala to raise mullaperiyar dam height. You are just a frog in a well who hasn't seen the wider world

Again, you must be a fool to compare a modern day water crisis with a thousands of year old cultural tradition.