Is Chinese threat to India real?

[peaceful]

I have seen some talk shows of some very famous defense experts on India-China and they claim that even if China attacks and capture Arunachal and Sikkim, they are not capable of retaining it for long time. India has a large number of mountain divisions and they would take over as soon as winter come because China cannot support forces over there for a long time. This is why China is increasing its presence in Oceans and seas.

This is based on a huge false assumption: China will never across Burma to attack india.

Let's be honest, in case of a full out military conflict with india, China is not going to seek permission from Burma whether we can across their country or not. We would make a simple and easy choice for them: 1) allow PLA access, we promise for 20 years of economic & infrastructure support, we block all crap in the UNSC against the regime in Burma. 2) PLA cross Burma, take your capital, install a pro-China puppet regime, and then fight with india.

This has been discussed about a million times on Chinese forums, we don't see any reason how Burma would reject the first offer.

 

[Agnostic_Indian]

we had a discussion on a Chinese forum that "what happens if india choose to block the indian ocean, how we are going to get oil from ME".
the conclusion is our army will be able to cross the border, push forward to new delhi and capture it within a few days.

let me remind you dude, you don't have any single weapon to match our: Type-99 MBT, WS-2 rocket launcher, CJ-10 missiles. and the experience of the 1962 war also tells something.

Period.

we have enough weapons and soldiers to defend our country..if you concluded you will be on delhi with in few days..that's just a foolish conclusion..no big war is going to happen whether it's india china, india pak or china america..by the way nice name ' PEACEFUL'.

 

[peaceful]

what is India without Russia and Israel ...??...

if there is going to be a full out war with india, we will ask Russia and Israel to consider whether they want to be with us or with india. this is a no brainer really:

1. russia needs our support in UNSC in all those big matters. otherwise it is singled out.
israel knows it need China's silence in middle east.

what india can offer in terms of the above stuff?

2. they are close to india, because of $$$.
however when it comes to $$$, China has far more

the request will be simple: stop selling weapons to india, we buy whatever india wants, with all prices doubled and we pay cash.

 

[peaceful]

we have enough weapons and soldiers to defend our country..if you concluded you will be on delhi with in few days..that's just a foolish conclusion..no big war is going to happen whether it's india china, india pak or china america..by the way nice name ' PEACEFUL'.

soldiers? sorry, we are still the country with the biggest active troops, and our troops are much better trained and equipped.

btw, we Chinese do not want war with india or any nation, the problem is your regime and media is keep cooking up such China threat stories as if we want a fight. I am telling you: this is killing your economy & growth, this is like the cold war version 2. india is not having a up hand because our economy is 4 times as big as yours.

period.

 

[Secret Service]

if there is going to be a full out war with india, we will ask Russia and Israel to consider whether they want to be with us or with india. this is a no brainer really:

1. russia needs our support in UNSC in all those big matters. otherwise it is singled out.
israel knows it need China's silence in middle east.

what india can offer in terms of the above stuff?

2. they are close to india, because of $$$.
however when it comes to $$$, China has far more

the request will be simple: stop selling weapons to india, we buy whatever india wants, with all prices doubled and we pay cash.

i was talking about weapons not money......
and if there is a full war then there ll be No Oil for India, from middle east ..
and i agree with your points.....

 

[cross1993]

I do not think India is a threat. Our threat in the Western Pacific.

 

[perplexed]

This is based on a huge false assumption: China will never across Burma to attack india.

Let's be honest, in case of a full out military conflict with india, China is not going to seek permission from Burma whether we can across their country or not. We would make a simple and easy choice for them: 1) allow PLA access, we promise for 20 years of economic & infrastructure support, we block all crap in the UNSC against the regime in Burma. 2) PLA cross Burma, take your capital, install a pro-China puppet regime, and then fight with india.

This has been discussed about a million times on Chinese forums, we don't see any reason how Burma would reject the first offer.

I dont know if chinese troops are capable or not but what i know is chinese people dont know geography.
Why would they want to attack us through Burma ( Its called myanmar for the last decade atleast)

 

[peaceful]

to all indian friends:

we Chinese are in general peaceful people, we didn't invade your country even when we were at our peak times in Tang and Han. We built the great wall of China for defense, not invasion. such mindset is not changed today, we want peace.

however, your media and the Singh regime wants you to see China as a threat, why? because you will thus question less on their failure and corruption.

let's just face the fact even your far right nationalists can never deny: China beat you hard in the 1962 war, but we didn't take any single inch of your land after the war. why we want to threat you now when we are focusing on development?

your biggest enemy is the Singh regime, an middle east style uprising against the Singh regime will change the life of yourself, your children and grandchildren.

 

[peaceful]

I dont know if chinese troops are capable or not but what i know is chinese people dont know geography.
Why would they want to attack us through Burma

just a snapshot of what you said.

no explanation.

 

[Basanti]

This is based on a huge false assumption: China will never across Burma to attack india.
Let's be honest, in case of a full out military conflict with india, China is not going to seek permission from Burma whether we can across their country or not. We would make a simple and easy choice for them: 1) allow PLA access, we promise for 20 years of economic & infrastructure support, we block all crap in the UNSC against the regime in Burma. 2) PLA cross Burma, take your capital, install a pro-China puppet regime, and then fight with india.
This has been discussed about a million times on Chinese forums, we don't see any reason how Burma would reject the first offer.

peaceful, peaceful, you are not a peaceful han chinese after all... do you really think you can cross fight all the way into new delhi and establiish a puppet government there?? In your dreams dude..

and if you are talking about capturing the seven sister states and establishing a pro-china government there, not going to happen.. Most of the NE people i know would rather stay with India rather than china.. India has very strong mountain divisons there in the east.. It is gonna make the chinese run for shelter from the rain of bullets if you get what i mean..
Even if you succeed in capturing our territory, you see what is happening in Libya?? Thats gonna happen there too..in winter.. Plus, it can gonna spread into Tibet.. Plus, remember that they will be backed by the IA, IN and IAF.. Frying your off.. And if the chinese govt tries to contain the problem by firing on them, that'll be extra frying for the chinese govt..

if there is going to be a full out war with india, we will ask Russia and Israel to consider whether they want to be with us or with india. this is a no brainer really:

1. russia needs our support in UNSC in all those big matters. otherwise it is singled out.
israel knows it need China's silence in middle east.

what india can offer in terms of the above stuff?

2. they are close to india, because of $$$.
however when it comes to $$$, China has far more

the request will be simple: stop selling weapons to india, we buy whatever india wants, with all prices doubled and we pay cash.

I guess you have left out the matters of national security.. Russia is strong in the region due to India.. Russia+India keeps china at bay..
same is the thing for India.. Russia is a reason we can be strong in the Region.

and Israeli's have got more brains than you would imagine.. What will they gain if they join china? they will alienate the US. They become weak. What if they join India? they get the support of US and India. Got it??
And regarding all the $$$ china has, its not going to help.
And if you want to bring up all that US treasury bonds stuff, China cant do about it if the US decides to freeze it.. Just as it happened in the case of Libya.. Get it??

Damn, you are such a good troller peaceful, i thought you had more brains than that

 

[Basanti]

we Chinese are in general peaceful people, we didn't invade your country even when we were at our peak times in Tang and Han. We built the great wall of China for defense, not invasion. such mindset is not changed today, we want peace.

however, your media and the Singh regime wants you to see China as a threat, why? because you will thus question less on their failure and corruption.

let's just face the fact even your far right nationalists can never deny: China beat you hard in the 1962 war, but we didn't take any single inch of your land after the war. why we want to threat you now when we are focusing on development?

your biggest enemy is the Singh regime, an middle east style uprising against the Singh regime will change the life of yourself, your children and grandchildren.

go to bed peaceful, you need some rest

 

[Agnostic_Indian]

soldiers? sorry, we are still the country with the biggest active troops, and our troops are much better trained and equipped.

btw, we Chinese do not want war with india or any nation, the problem is your regime and media is keep cooking up such China threat stories as if we want a fight. I am telling you: this is killing your economy & growth, this is like the cold war version 2. india is not having a up hand because our economy is 4 times as big as yours.

period.

if you being bigger means "can defeat any body then america would have attacked half the world.war is not only about strength but it's also about international politics, calculating what you gain and lose,we have enough force to defend ourselves..and we don't have any interest in attacking china..all we need is to maintain statues quo.as long as your forces maintain ALOC indian govt is cool..and about media..they are just rushing the govt to strengthen security because right now there is a big imbalance between indian and chinese infrastructure in AP border.

 

[harsh1488]

i was talking about weapons not money......
and if there is a full war then there ll be No Oil for India, from middle east ..
and i agree with your points.....

why will the be no oil for india?

 

[Kevrai]

if there is going to be a full out war with india, we will ask Russia and Israel to consider whether they want to be with us or with india. this is a no brainer really:

1. russia needs our support in UNSC in all those big matters. otherwise it is singled out.
israel knows it need China's silence in middle east.

what india can offer in terms of the above stuff?

2. they are close to india, because of $$$.
however when it comes to $$$, China has far more

the request will be simple: stop selling weapons to india, we buy whatever india wants, with all prices doubled and we pay cash.

what big matters are you referring to??? Russia is a country that doesn't need anybody's help.....they don't need little chinese help

 

[Royan]

i was talking about weapons not money......
and if there is a full war then there ll be No Oil for India, from middle east ..
and i agree with your points.....

What make you say that???