drmeson
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Sep 2, 2016
- Messages
- 2,002
- Reaction score
- 0
- Country
- Location
well two aircraft can do that in IRIAF. F-14 and Kowsar , problem is we have A2A missile to do that for F-14 , for kowsar our hand is somehow tied
Yes IRIAF should get PL-15 from China or R-77-1 from Moscow for Kowsar Program and if MIG fleet gets local upgrade. This is a must.
AND
Babaei Missile Industries, the makers of Fakour-90, Fattar sidewinders can focus on bringing the Fatter (heavier AIM-9J/P) to AIM-9X Block II/III standard range of ~60 km. That will be the game changer for IRIAF.
No doubt the latter two points - cost effectiveness and already existing basic infrastructure, represent a weighty argument for a modernization of the existing Mig-29 fleet over purchase of new Su-35 airframes (along with phasing out the Mig-29).
Still, to arrive to a definitive conclusion one would need to compare the capabilities of the types in the interception role and weigh it against the costs generated by these two hypothetical undertakings. Brand new Su-35 will likely be superior to upgraded IRIAF Mig-29. By how much, and would this be worth the price differential are thus the decisive questions.
SU-35S costs around 85 Million USD. Even a small order of 24 planes will cost 2.0 Billion USD for just the fighters ... almost 3.0 Billion USD with armaments, maintenance infrastructure and training cost. IRIAF can get MLUed 80 x MIG-29M/SMT or 48 x MIG-35 for the same amount of money. Both have similar air to air capabilities (IRIAF needs that only) compared to a SU-35S all the while these hypothetical 80 MIG-29M or 48 MIG-35 can fit easily in IRIAF in the current infrastructure we have developed for MIG-29 fleet.
More realistically, even without the procurement of anything fancy, the same 2.5 billion USD can give IRIAF the following:
- 100-150 Million for 46-48 x F-14AM. Cost is 2-3 Million USD/unit, fleet gets heavy MLU, upgrade.
- 1.5 Billion for 150 Kowsar-I/II. Cost is 10 million/unit for from-scratch production and 7 million/unit for repository-built airframe + upgrade. Current capacity is 6-7 airframes per year from one assembly line. If they setup another assembly line for future improved Kowsar-II than production can be doubled. There is a need, there is a solution.
- 700 Million for 60 MIG-29M. Additional airframes from Russia/anywhere + IRIAF's 23 x MIG-29 9.12 MLU + heavy avionics upgrade with Russian help. R-74E and R-77SD gets procured with HMD package.
- 200 Million for 100 x + Shahed-171 and KAMAN-22 in ELINT/SIGINT and PGM strike roles.
This is a proper force that if fights in small battle groups for A2/AD will not let the enemy enter the Iranian airspace easily along with Ambush SAMs on ground.
Prop imposters like like MirageF1, F-7N, F5E/D all retire or sold to whoever wants.
su-35 will track Rafale and F16 block-60+ from that distance only if the electronic warfare system were turned off , otherwise the range will probably get reduced a lot.
Any western/European fighter will deploy heavy jamming when being tracked.
Unrelated but here is something interesting. I read that there was a talk in IRIAF of converting a few old stored/damaged F-14A airframes to dedicated mini AWACS + E-warfare platforms with datalinking. Not sure what became of that.