Iran: Three prisoners sentenced to hand amputation or lashes

[acetophenol]

Iran-you are doing it wrong!

 

[Alshawi1234]

Yes, the 11 Imams you're worshipping on daily basis DID execute people in the same way we do, so did they in extreme rubbery cases.




I'm not sure that I can believe you.





Iraq's corruption is extremely alarming bro, I hear you.


No, in serious rubbery cases, people get their hands chopped off, in both faiths Sunni and Shia.

Again, no one worships humans, and what you said about the Imams is a factual mistake, they were never in a government position to be issuing OR carrying out such punishments. The only Imam which had Authority was Imam Ali Ibn Abi Talib who was the third caliph according to Sunnis and the first Imam according to Shias. He engaged in many battles and as you know people used swords back then, swords are quite sharp.

As for amputating a persons hand off, these are the rules according to Shias/ Imami/ Jaafari/ twelvers (different names, same meaning)
1-the stolen goods must be in a safe, or personal space and not out in the open. You don't get your hand cut for finding a wallet on the street and taking it, but if you break into someone's home or vehicle, only then can a punishment by pursued.
- the theft must not be out of need, if a person is stealing to feed himself or family (considering he steals only as much as he needs), the punishment is forbidden.
- The crime must not be committed as a result of threats or incitement for another group or person, otherwise the punishment is invalid
-If it's persons first theft, and he regrets his actions, the punishment is invalid. The punishment can only be carried out on a person who is know for being a theif.
- the victims have the right to forgive, and Allah promised to reward those who forgive.
-The punishments is meant as a means to stop people from commiting crime, the sole intention is not to punish.


-The major difference between Jaafari jurisdiction and other schools of thought is about where the hand get amputated from. Sunnis differ greatly, some say the wrist, some up to the elbow, and some say the entire arm. However, the Jaafari jurisdiction states that only the fingers are To be amputated, and that "Mawadhi3 Alsalah" or the places of where a person uses to pray must not be touched, that includes the palm. .

Agree or not, these are the rules. And after seeing all the sick people who are willing to get as low as to starve orphans, I believe this punishment is fair. I am not speaking of this specific incident, but if all the rules above apply, that the suspect deserves what he is getting.

 

[Syrian Lion]

@Yzd Khalifa
Are you against Islamic Shariah ?

 

[Hussein]

Iran: Three prisoners sentenced to hand amputation or lashes

FILE PHOTO
NCRI - The head of the Iranian regime's judiciary in southern city of Abadan has sentenced a man to hand amputation. He has also been sentenced to 10 months of imprisonment and 99 lashes for alleged financial crimes.

The state-run Mehr news agency, quoted Nematollah Behroozi on Wednesday (July 31) that also a woman working with him had been sentenced to 74 lashes and two years imprisonment for financial crimes and 99 lashes for alleged adultery.

Another man working with them had been charged with 74 lashes and two years imprisonment, the report said.

your source is the website of MeK, a terrorist organization

even if it is related from Iranian website, pls try to avoid use such website
it is like i was putting al qaida articles to speak about KSA

 

[Yzd Khalifa]

@Yzd Khalifa
Are you against Islamic Shariah ?

I'd rather not answer this question, Sir.

 

[Hack-Hook]

This is gross. Amputating a man's hand for adultery? This is inhuman savagery! And just because he screwed a woman who is not his wife?? So fu@kin' what? What's the big deal if it was consensual sex? He could have been given imprisonment for a couple of years instead. But this? It sucks!

where you saw Adultery in the news .
and here amputation of the hand (well technically its fingers ) is for Armed rubbery .

and by the way the sentence for adultery is death penalty if proven not cutting hands .

Does this stop adultery?

from where the adultery part come from ?

 

[Hack-Hook]

We don't chop people's hands

DAILY POST: Arms of an African man CUT OFF in Saudi Arabia for STEALING

The Arabic textbooks which show children how to chop off hands and feet under Sharia law | Mail Online

We don't chop people's hands

http://www.kenyan-post.com/2012/11/arms-of-african-man-cut-off-in-saudi.html

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2077658/The-Arabic-textbooks-children-chop-hands-feet-Sharia-law.html

 

[Yzd Khalifa]

A- Teaching kids about their religion is one thing, and application is another thing, nice try through

B- The African man's case took place centuries ago.

DAILY POST: Arms of an African man CUT OFF in Saudi Arabia for STEALING

The Arabic textbooks which show children how to chop off hands and feet under Sharia law | Mail Online

 

[Hack-Hook]

A- Teaching kids about their religion is one thing, and application is another thing, nice try through

B- The African man's case took place centuries ago.

by centuries ago you mean 1-2 year ago

in 2002 you cut the hand of an afghan
in 2007 you cut the hand of an Egyptian
in 2012 you cut the hand of a Nigerian

in 2013 those punishment were not enough so you put 7 people in row for death because of thievery

 

[Yzd Khalifa]

Rubbish Savafid.

by centuries ago you mean 1-2 year ago

in 2002 you cut the hand of an afghan
in 2007 you cut the hand of an Egyptian
in 2012 you cut the hand of a Nigerian

in 2013 those punishment were not enough so you put 7 people in row for death because of thievery

 

[Serpentine]

Rubbish Savafid.

Do you always get to name calling when you are defeated in a logical argument?

 

[Yzd Khalifa]

Do you always get to name calling when you are defeated in a logical argument?

Your beloved fellow countryman appears to be more determined to point his fingers on groundless accusations, and he has to be put in his rightful place.

 

[Serpentine]

Your beloved fellow countryman appears to be more determined to point his fingers on groundless accusations, and he has to be put in his rightful place.

Oh, groundless? How nice.Now that you understood you are doing it worse in your own country, it's groundless, right?
You just started a thread based on news from an Iranian terrorist group and it's all genuine, but when he answers you by posting a news from America's most popular newspaper, it's groundless?Why don't you just admit you made a mistake by opening this thread?


You don't throw stone at people when you live in a glass house.

 

[Yzd Khalifa]

Oh, groundless? How nice.Now that you understood you are doing it worse in your own country, it's groundless, right?
You just started a thread based on news from an Iranian terrorist group and it's all genuine, but when he answers you by posting a news from America's most popular newspaper, it's groundless?Why don't you just admit you made a mistake by opening this thread?


You don't throw stone at people when you live in a glass house.

Nothing wrong I did, no need to get emotional homie xD.

Chao

 

[Serpentine]

Nothing wrong I did, no need to get emotional homie xD.

Chao

Now you are playing my own game.