India's unfair tirade against Bangladesh puzzles Indians too

[gslv mk3]

Believe me, we couldn't care less.

 

[kris]

Actually, India can threaten with deportation of 5 million Bangladeshis if more deals are not given. India does not need Bangladesh, Bangladesh needs India.

Bangladesh is not friendly to India in any way. Bangladesh and India simply have truce agreement for 10-15 years that there will be give and take deals. Any infringement on the agreement will change situation drastically.

Bangladesh has sea access. It's not dependent on India

A lot of trade deals with India need to be renegotiated. If necessary we will have to consider blocking transit to NE. We should tell India to get rid of the tariffs on Bangladeshi goods otherwise we will block the transit.

Pls explain

This will burn your own house in return. You have a much larger and diverse Muslim population in India who are also active politically. Also your state govts are very unlikely to approve this as well. States that borders Bangladesh, cares about having good relation with Bangladesh. Just look at WB.

BD never tried this with full focus. And in 2000's BD wasn't capable of doing anything to begin with. If we do we will also look covert support for China as well.

We buy your food with money. You don't give them for free.

Explain.

Every day every one wants a good neighbor. Isn't it the same with Bangladesh?
No point of arguing here..
India hasn't used stupid things like shooting fishermen etc even on Pakistan. I would wonder why it will be on Bangladesh

The day bangladesh tries something stupid like insurgency it will become like Pakistan.. are you willing to see ur state in that position

It's just not trade, it's about services. India provides good services at relatively small distance and largely similar social environment benefiting Bangladeshi S-10 can u deny it. Money won't buy u somethings

 

[Vijyes Yechury]

Bangladesh has sea access. It's not dependent on India

Bangladesh needs India to not deport muslims and make it starve. India has no reason to show restraint towards Bangladesh. Bangladesh has regularly assisted insurgencies in India and India can take revenge against Bangladesh, making Bangladesh lives miserable. Sea access is irrelevant

 

[Kaniska]

A lot of trade deals with India need to be renegotiated. If necessary we will have to consider blocking transit to NE. We should tell India to get rid of the tariffs on Bangladeshi goods otherwise we will block the transit.

If it is really possible for BD to do such things, they could have done it earlier..

Coming to the point..even i beleive..if illegals are coming to eastern part of India...then it is more of an Indian headache rather than BD...Why to blame them when it is not the fault of BD Gov??

 

[Vijyes Yechury]

This will burn your own house in return. You have a much larger and diverse Muslim population in India who are also active politically. Also your state govts are very unlikely to approve this as well. States that borders Bangladesh, cares about having good relation with Bangladesh. Just look at WB.

Muslims are a threat to India anyways. So, why do you think any muslim will be spared who goes against? Who says that WB will not agree? If a referendum is held, things will be very different. Bengal and Assam will agree because the people will force. It is better to have no Bangladesh at all than have friendly relation with Bangladesh. Why should a country that is threatening India for so long be allowed to continue to exist?

BD never tried this with full focus. And in 2000's BD wasn't capable of doing anything to begin with. If we do we will also look covert support for China as well.

BD was never fully capable but still tried its best. Why will China support BD against India? What will China get in return? India has already mended fence with China with

We buy your food with money. You don't give them for free.

India gives more food to Bangladeshis who are illegally in India which also BD has to pay in addition to land rent. Is BD paying that too?

The day bangladesh tries something stupid like insurgency it will become like Pakistan.. are you willing to see ur state in that position

BD has done it even in 2000s. Were you sleeping? BD is no different than Pakistan except that it is surrounded by India and Myanmar, both of who are hostile to BD and hence it keeps low for the right time.

Coming to the point..even i beleive..if illegals are coming to eastern part of India...then it is more of an Indian headache rather than BD...Why to blame them when it is not the fault of BD Gov??

It is the fault of BD govt as they are helping in the process. Also, BD is asking India to not shoot at borders and forcibly push in infiltrators.

 

[Kaniska]

Muslims are a threat to India anyways. So, why do you think any muslim will be spared who goes against? Who says that WB will not agree? If a referendum is held, things will be very different. Bengal and Assam will agree because the people will force. It is better to have no Bangladesh at all than have friendly relation with Bangladesh. Why should a country that is threatening India for so long be allowed to continue to exist?


BD was never fully capable but still tried its best. Why will China support BD against India? What will China get in return? India has already mended fence with China with


India gives more food to Bangladeshis who are illegally in India which also BD has to pay in addition to land rent. Is BD paying that too?


BD has done it even in 2000s. Were you sleeping? BD is no different than Pakistan except that it is surrounded by India and Myanmar, both of who are hostile to BD and hence it keeps low for the right time.

It is the fault of BD govt as they are helping in the process. Also, BD is asking India to not shoot at borders and forcibly push in infiltrators.

Do you know that there are illegal immigration of Indian to West???Did you ever see Western nations blame Indian gov for it???

 

[Vijyes Yechury]

Do you know that there are illegal immigration of Indian to West???Did you ever see Western nations blame Indian gov for it???

How can Indian migrants go to west? Via boats? There may be people who have gone on Visa and not returned but there are not many who entered illegally. Most important, Indians don't cause problems politically or otherwise to anyone unlike Muslims.

So, combining low number of illegal Indians and lack of problems, Indian govt is not blamed

 

[Mage]

Muslims are a threat to India anyways. So, why do you think any muslim will be spared who goes against? Who says that WB will not agree? If a referendum is held, things will be very different. Bengal and Assam will agree because the people will force. It is better to have no Bangladesh at all than have friendly relation with Bangladesh. Why should a country that is threatening India for so long be allowed to continue to exist?


BD was never fully capable but still tried its best. Why will China support BD against India? What will China get in return? India has already mended fence with China with


India gives more food to Bangladeshis who are illegally in India which also BD has to pay in addition to land rent. Is BD paying that too?


BD has done it even in 2000s. Were you sleeping? BD is no different than Pakistan except that it is surrounded by India and Myanmar, both of who are hostile to BD and hence it keeps low for the right time.

It is the fault of BD govt as they are helping in the process. Also, BD is asking India to not shoot at borders and forcibly push in infiltrators.

Think whatever you want. I'm not gonna entertain your daydreaming.

 

[randomradio]

I don't need to.

http://www.dailyindustry.news/bangladesh-becomes-4th-largest-remittance-source-india/

That's mostly related to trade.

 

[Vijyes Yechury]

Think whatever you want. I'm not gonna entertain your daydreaming.

You are the one who is day dreaming. All I am saying is that BD has to give favourable deals to India if it wants India to keep quiet. Entertaining your sense of grandioseness and imposing restrictions on India is your day dream

 

[Species]

You are the one who is day dreaming. All I am saying is that BD has to give favourable deals to India if it wants India to keep quiet. Entertaining your sense of grandioseness and imposing restrictions on India is your day dream

It's rather the other way round. India is an artificial state that will always have to rely on its neighbors for its survival. If we let loose, it wouldn't even take a week for India to get ripped into pieces.

 

[Flynn Swagmire]

Hey, Bangladesh. Dont mess with !ndia! The rape hyppa pawwa since unknown time...

Just scream, Gay hind...

 

[Vijyes Yechury]

It's rather the other way round. India is an artificial state that will always have to rely on its neighbors for its survival. If we let loose, it wouldn't even take a week for India to get ripped into pieces.

How will you do that? Hw can Bangladesh let loose that will rip India apart? Don't utter anything without giving a proper method

 

[kris]

1.Bangladesh needs India to not deport muslims and make it starve. India has no reason to show restraint towards Bangladesh.

2.Bangladesh has regularly assisted insurgencies in India and

3.India can take revenge against Bangladesh, making Bangladesh lives miserable.

4.Sea access is irrelevant

1.Technically not possible.....
2.its one pakistan tilting political partynot bangladesh. Many Bangladeshi hold good respect for India and Indians. No point in destroying it for nothing
3. You should have a target for targeting and some benefit for targeting. What's both in this case?
4. You have no idea what you are talking about

 

[Mage]

Pls explain

We have huge trade deficit with India. That needs to be addressed. We import a lot while our exports are miniscule. India imposes a lot of tariffs in our goods. Removing it will do. Also in the long term agreement on Teesta water sharing would take both countries relation to new heights. That's all I ask. Remove tariff barrier on our goods and a Teesta water sharing deal where no party loses. I don't understand what's so unreasonable here.