Indian Special Forces

[Indischer]

from starting there was no special thread for paramilitary and all guys are posting COBRA NSG AND SPG pics here though they are not military SFs.To ab phirse naya thread kholke sab pics waha pe thodi daalne vale hai. And usually we dont get many pics of military Sfs so we pics of other special units. If pics of SPG and NSG are posted then whats wrong with COBRA.Vaise I agree ki yaha pe sirf military sfs k pics hone chahiye. But i dont understand why some members here show such disrespect for COBRAS .after all they r also serving the nation.They are also a special soldiers and part of our armed forces. So this is not a big issue thats what i think. Agar sab log chahate jonge toh COBRA k pics INDIAN MILITARY PICTURE THREAD pe post karenge.

Firstly, apologies if my post hurt you in any way, as you're one of the best contributors here. But you very well know the answer to this question yourself. If COBRAs are designated as Special Forces, they'll definitely warrant a mention here. But they aren't, nor are they part of the Indian Army. So why put them in either of these two threads? As I said before, they deserve a sticky thread for themselves.

It's not a question of their Service to the Nation either. Nobody's disputing that. It's more an issue of diluting the express purpose of this thread. Hope you understand.

 

[Unknowncommando]

Firstly, apologies if my post hurt you in any way, as you're one of the best contributors here. But you very well know the answer to this question yourself. If COBRAs are designated as Special Forces, they'll definitely warrant a mention here. But they aren't, nor are they part of the Indian Army. So why put them in either of these two threads? As I said before, they deserve a sticky thread for themselves.

It's not a question of their Service to the Nation either. Nobody's disputing that. It's more an issue of diluting the express purpose of this thread. Hope you understand.

nahi bhai hurt vagera kuch bhi. I dnt get hurt by small things. So u r saying that someone should open a new sticky thread for paramilitary special units. But one thing i want to ask u. SPG and NSG also not part of army.NSG come under MHA and guys selected from paramilitary and army while SPGs are selected from NSG and DELHI POLICE then why r we posting their pics. Jane bhi they yara koi badi baat nahi hai. Itni choti batey bother nahi karte. Fir bhi if anyone is interested in opening new thread then he can open. Chal ab padhne de bhai 12 th board ki exam hai meri.

 

[Indischer]

nahi bhai hurt vagera kuch bhi. I dnt get hurt by small things. So u r saying that someone should open a new sticky thread for paramilitary special units. But one thing i want to ask u. SPG and NSG also not part of army.NSG come under MHA and guys selected from paramilitary and army while SPGs are selected from NSG and DELHI POLICE then why r we posting their pics. Jane bhi they yara koi badi baat nahi hai. Itni choti batey bother nahi karte. Fir bhi if anyone is interested in opening new thread then he can open. Chal ab padhne de bhai 12 th board ki exam hai meri.

ok bhai, rehne dete hain inko yaheen pe. Waise bhi mere kehne pe thodi kuch hota hai yahaan...chalo, ab padhai pe bhi dhyan do.

 

[shree835]

Who is the Best....??

MARCOS in Action....

 

[shree835]

 

[Abingdonboy]

NSG isn't a SF.
The ones on the ship aren't MARCOs but SPB
Relevant to SFs how?

 

[shree835]

NSG isn't a SF.

The ones on the ship aren't MARCOs but SPB

Relevant to SFs how?

I believe Wiki is wrong....Proof me...??????

The National Security Guard (NSG) is a special force in India that has primarily been utilised for counter-terrorism activities and was created by the Cabinet Secretariat under the National Security Guard Act of the Indian Parliament in 1986. It works completely within the Central Armed Police Forces structure. The NSG is an elite force providing a second line of defence to the nation. They have played a pivotal role in safeguarding the unity of India and have commendably foiled attempts of anti-national elements to tear apart the social fabric of the country. The NSG have maintained an edge over terrorist outfits in possession of latest technology and are considered among the best special operations units in the world.[1]

 

[Abingdonboy]

I believe Wiki is wrong....Proof me...??????

The National Security Guard (NSG) is a special force in India that has primarily been utilised for counter-terrorism activities and was created by the Cabinet Secretariat under the National Security Guard Act of the Indian Parliament in 1986. It works completely within the Central Armed Police Forces structure. The NSG is an elite force providing a second line of defence to the nation. They have played a pivotal role in safeguarding the unity of India and have commendably foiled attempts of anti-national elements to tear apart the social fabric of the country. The NSG have maintained an edge over terrorist outfits in possession of latest technology and are considered among the best special operations units in the world.[1]

Wiki is wrong or at least has worded it wrong. Look up the definition of SFs- the NSG is NOT one and was NEVER meant to be one- they are a highly specialist counter terror force. India only has THREE SFs as recognised by the GoI/MoD- PARA (SF), MARCOs and Garuds- that is ALL.

 

[shree835]

Wiki is wrong or at least has worded it wrong. Look up the definition of SFs- the NSG is NOT one and was NEVER meant to be one- they are a highly specialist counter terror force. India only has THREE SFs as recognised by the GoI/MoD- PARA (SF), MARCOs and Garuds- that is ALL.

What I should take it as...your PERCEPTION or JUDGEMENT... I would like to see proof that supports your statement....I can show you N number of supporting docs to support my comment.

 

[Abingdonboy]

What I should take it as...your PERCEPTION or JUDGEMENT... I would like to see proof that supports your statement....I can show you N number of supporting docs to support my comment.

You can show me all the Indian media produced BS about every other specialist force being "commandos" and "special forces" I mean have you seen that series on the COBRAs that calls them Special forces every 5 seconds and compares them to US SEALs and Green Berets?!!

Look up the term for Special Forces, the NSG does not conform to this definition and again, there are ONLY THREE SFs in India- this much is confirmed by the GoI/MoD- which forces wear the red SF tabs in India? ONLY the MARCOs,PARA(SF) and Garuds.

 

[shree835]

You can show me all the Indian media produced BS about every other specialist force being "commandos" and "special forces" I mean have you seen that series on the COBRAs that calls them Special forces every 5 seconds and compares them to US SEALs and Green Berets?!!

Look up the term for Special Forces, the NSG does not conform to this definition and again, there are ONLY THREE SFs in India- this much is confirmed by the GoI/MoD- which forces wear the red SF tabs in India? ONLY the MARCOs,PARA(SF) and Garuds.

I asked you supporting docs...But here I can see You are getting personal...and trying to give me Bol Bachan...waiting for your supporting docs...If you are correct ...I would love to correct myself...I don have ego issue.

FYI...One of my cousin brother is a Commando in NSG...My family relates with Army, Air Force and Navy.

 

[Abingdonboy]

I asked you supporting docs...But here I can see You are getting personal...and trying to give me Bol Bachan...waiting for your supporting docs...If you are correct ...I would love to correct myself...I don have ego issue.

This is an accepted fact, I don't know what evidence you want me to provide.

Just like the GSG-9, FBI's HRT or GIGN aren't SFs just very specialised counter terror units, neither is the NSG. The NSG was raised on the lines of the GSG-9 and holds training sessions with other police/federal counter terror units around the world but NOT military SFs like Green Berets or USN SEALS (like the PARA (SF) and MARCOs do).


What I'm saying isn't at all controversial but is common knowledge. One just needs to understand what SFs are otherwise one, like many of the other ignorant Indians, will go around calling Police SWAT teams Special Forces for God's sake!!

FYI...One of my cousin brother is a Commando in NSG...My family relates with Army, Air Force and Navy.

Fair enough and respect to anyone who serves their nation. Why don't you ask him whether the NSG considers themselves as part of India's SFs? Is he SRG or SAG btw?

 

[me_itsme]

NSG is not special forces, they are a specialist counter terrorist unit. More on the lines of FBI HRT. @shree835 SF's are different their operational profile may overlap with that of specialist CT but that's just one of their role, they have wide variety of roles from hostage rescue to assassinations to unconventional warfare, where as the NSG's role is just limited to internal response against terrorist threats and more over they come under the home ministry.

 

[COLDHEARTED AVIATOR]

nahi bhai hurt vagera kuch bhi. I dnt get hurt by small things. So u r saying that someone should open a new sticky thread for paramilitary special units. But one thing i want to ask u. SPG and NSG also not part of army.NSG come under MHA and guys selected from paramilitary and army while SPGs are selected from NSG and DELHI POLICE then why r we posting their pics. Jane bhi they yara koi badi baat nahi hai. Itni choti batey bother nahi karte. Fir bhi if anyone is interested in opening new thread then he can open. Chal ab padhne de bhai 12 th board ki exam hai meri.

nahi bhai hurt vagera kuch bhi. I dnt get hurt by small things. So u r saying that someone should open a new sticky thread for paramilitary special units. But one thing i want to ask u. SPG and NSG also not part of army.NSG come under MHA and guys selected from paramilitary and army while SPGs are selected from NSG and DELHI POLICE then why r we posting their pics. Jane bhi they yara koi badi baat nahi hai. Itni choti batey bother nahi karte. Fir bhi if anyone is interested in opening new thread then he can open. Chal ab padhne de bhai 12 th board ki exam hai meri.

SPG are not recruited from NSG and Delhi Police.

 

[Unknowncommando]

SPG are not recruited from NSG and Delhi Police.

ohhk thank you......_/\_