Indian P-17A frigates superior to Pakistan's Type-054A frigates: Senior Indian Navy officer

[Canuck786]

tomorrow aliens will attack earth
we have barahmos
global warming is an.issue
we have barahmos
world may face food shortage
we have barahmos
modi ki gaand main kisi ne ungli ki
we have barahmos .

Oh I agree with you 110%. Just felt vaginas were being insulted a bit.

 

[xyxmt]

Indian fishing boats are far superior that Type 54, come on folks it is "Indian"

 

[tanlixiang28776]

P17A also costs 1.1 billion per unit. For that price Pakistan could get type 055 .

While the Type 54A is less than a quarter of the price of the P17A and almost 3000 tones lighter it is equal in Air defence, equal in antishipping with the export YJ 12, and superior in CIWS with its 1130s and only inferior in ASW with its single helicopter vs two of the P17A.

Oh and the P17A has a bigger main gun

 

[Crystal-Clear]

indians is like "aaaaalllll is welllllllll"

 

[tanlixiang28776]

The Indians are actually comparing their top of the line Destroyers which cost over a billion dollars each vs Chinas export frigates which cost around 250 million each. Sad part is Armnament wise the P17A is so underwhelming for its size that it doesn't even compare favorably vs type 054As.

 

[Rashid Mahmood]

What a joke these Indians are, PN have not formally shown its ship design so only they know what will be final product.

@Rashid Mahmood please share your opinion.

Just like their Tejas is "superior" to our JF-17
Arjunk is "superior" to our Al-Khalid....

and so on...

When our FFG is operational, then we will compare it with any other vessel, not before.

 

[tanlixiang28776]

Hey if Indians want to boast that fine. Lets compare in the same price category then. The type 055 is estimated to cost 950 million dollars. The P17A cost 1.1 billion dollars.

vs

The 150 million difference can almost buy a 054A

So China can make a 055 and 054A for the price of a P17A

 

[PradoTLC]

Rear Admiral TK Sen (retired) was in-charge of operations of Western Naval Command in 2005-07.

so what ?

you have morons who operate them

 

[Chanakyaa]

All my Dear Pakistani Members Read this excellent article :

https://defencyclopedia.com/2014/12...vy-can-shoot-down-the-deadly-brahmos-missile/

 

[Areesh]

Indian Navy officers should keep their mouths shut over these issues. Leave it to other navies for such opinions.

They should only give their opinion about swapping wife and things like that.

 

[Cuirassier]

Who gave these boys access to social media like this, and they say our forces are too vocal? Hypocrites.

 

[Type59]

HHQ-16 or rather its base HQ-16 is derived/copied from Russian Buk / SA-11 or SA-17 air defence system.

LY-80, HQ-16's export version.

SA-11 Gadfly
View attachment 528771


As such these are dated system which cannot defeat a maneuvering high speed supersonic missile like Onik P-800.

The missile has been updated. Latest version is hq 16b. I also doubt you know the capabilities of baseline hq 16.

 

[Areesh]

By the way as I said before

Multiple ID rat is back. OP is the multiple ID rat. @waz @Oscar @Dubious @The Eagle

 

[BringHarmony]

The 150 million difference can almost buy a 054A

Not quite.

https://web.archive.org/web/2013060...065975734&channel=defence&subChannel=business

Thailand was offered 3 Type-054 frigates for 1 billion dollars in 2013. 200 million or so is just the cost of the frigate. Any idea how much Pakistan is paying for the ship?

 

[ARMalik]

Rear Admiral TK Sen (retired) was in-charge of operations of Western Naval Command in 2005-07.

TK Sen ... another jackas.s indian talking from his rear ..... there is another clown called "Bi-Pin", the general who has 'two' pins sticking our of his arse