Indian opinion on CPEC

[Chhatrapati]

How stupid are you?

LOC is NOT an International Border!

Apparently the stupid ones are who declared war on us and waited for our response.

Then got their arse handed over. Lost half of the nation.

When you declare war, there is no limit to which side it should be served. You expect the conflict to be confined to J&K.

 

[hussain0216]

Yogi says, that Sanghi says, this sanghi says. You should stop listening to sanghi gospels. Modi did this and that.

These are not just sanghi's, they are YOUR CMs, they are YOUR PMs. They make your laws and are busy setting the hindutva agenda for the future of your country

blind and stupid is not an excuse for whst indian muslims are doing

One of us!! While many of you die in bomb .

Pakistan has worked hard, built up our military and independence and countered the schemes and plans of our enemies.
terrorism is a scourge but one we have by en large broken

Then a tribal leader is not happy with another and his village go war with them.
What a mess. Stop behaving like holier than thou.

This is some retarded bollywood film you have been watching your more likely to have wars between village panchayats in UP

Watch your words Hussain, don't call stuffs or refer words on us. This is not a place to show your degenerated upbringing.

You take exception to being called a dog on a leash then respond by saying

Then we will suffer the fate

This is dog on leash talk, you know they are going to hurt you but you will just accept the yank on the leash and kick up the ***

This is shameful behaviour, how is it better then having your own independent country with your own military, own government and never having to give a fcuk about hindus

 

[Verve]

Apparently the stupid ones are who declared war on us and waited for our response.

Then got their arse handed over. Lost half of the nation.

When you declare war, there is no limit to which side it should be served. You expect the conflict to be confined to J&K.

lol ... typical baniya! Can't differentiate between armies crossing an International Border and LOC, so comes up with the above vomit!

 

[ziaulislam]

Now Baloch are not a majority in Balochistan.



Please read my earlier post slowly. It said that we will fix these problems and I thank you for showing us the way.

correct, now pushtoons are the majority, and you know what pushtoons did to you in kashmir

this what bbc says..pakistan was already in multiple agreement with the hindhu raja
"Instead he signed a "standstill" agreement with Pakistan in order that services such as trade, travel and communication would be uninterrupted.India did not sign a similar agreement.
In October 1947, Pashtun tribesmen from Pakistan's North-West Frontier Province invaded Kashmir."

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/1762146.stm

 

[Kaniska]

That makes no sense...
The road has always existed between pakistan and China... so why now?

I sense it is more of the "moo par ram ram baghaal may chooree" dogma.

You can sense anything you like, same way everyone is entitled to have their own sense...It is an individual mindset how someone will perceive an argument for his own consumption.

Fact is, India will keep on protesting for any venture, be in CPEC or any small time activity in the land that is being claimed in an international forum.

 

[Clutch]

You can sense anything you like, same way everyone is entitled to have their own sense...It is an individual mindset how someone will perceive an argument for his own consumption.

Fact is, India will keep on protesting for any venture, be in CPEC or any small time activity in the land that is being claimed in an international forum.

But your objection is the route through GB? If yes, that road has always existed. Then what is your objection?

 

[Jackdaws]

Kashmiris a muslim state forced under a increasingly hindutva India

Jinnah always knew india would head this way and when it did Muslim's of south Asia would require independent lands.

indian muslims must live and suffer

why should Kashmiris be forced under such a union against their will

Jinnah conveniently asked Nehru to not touch his bungalow in Bombay and keep it safe and just before partition bought shares in Air India. So, it seems he didn't really think the way you assume he did.

How stupid are you?

LOC is NOT an International Border!

It still marks out the land in each other's control and is the de facto border, not the de jure border. Neither North Korea nor South Korea cross the Armistice Line and one of it has been ruled by 3 generations of lunatics. Pakistan crossed the LoC - it was probably known as something else in 1965 and expected the theater to remain localized.

 

[American Pakistani]

Pakistan is a multicultural country like India. Historically it wasn't a part of Pakistan either. (Pakistan never existed before 1947). Islam is a religion, it is not a native religion of Pakistan, it originated towards the west of Pakistan. Linguistically Koshur is not similar to Urdu, it has a very different style. Geograhically Kashmir is Part of Indian sub continent.

Kashmir, was, is and will remain part of India for the time to come. You lost the best chance in 65. Now it's gone for ever.

Don't jump on any referendum crap. Nobody cares about that since a long time. UN is useless, UNSC is useless, your only option is to take it by force. Looking at your current state, there is no such hope.


If you love the Kashmiri so much, then take them to GB, AJK, or any other place. The land and it's rivers and all other resources belong to India.

And will remain so. LOC will become the border.

We don't give a fkk about your nonsense education. During most of the historical empire's and IVC, Kashmir was part of Pakistan. Geographically only ferozpur and gurdaspur are the only gateway all year round to Kashmir which were deliberately given to india despite of having muslim majority regions in Punjab. Their religious beliefs are same as of any other Pakistani and religion impact their lives just like other Pakistanis. Lingustically their scripts are same as Pakistanis, Urdu is widely spoken throughout Kashmir.

And no matter what indian dream, today, tomorrow or in 100 years but victory will be Kashmir's future. Your 7 lakh indian occupier terrorists couldn't win Kashmir, nothing will.

 

[Chhatrapati]

During most of the historical empire's and IVC, Kashmir was part of Pakistan.

There was no Pakistan before 1947.

Lingustically their scripts are same as Pakistanis, Urdu is widely spoken throughout Kashmir.

Koshur the language of Kashmir. It has less correlation with Urdu, although it has a lot of loan words. Grammer is very different.

And no matter what indian dream, today, tomorrow or in 100 years but victory will be Kashmir's future. Your 7 lakh indian occupier terrorists couldn't win Kashmir, nothing will.

Nice speech though.

 

[American Pakistani]

There was no Pakistan before 1947.

You mean the land of Pakistan suddenly appears as a land here in the crossroads of South, Central Asia and Middle East?

Koshur the language of Kashmir. It has less correlation with Urdu, although it has a lot of loan words. Grammer is very different.

Urdu is very popular in Kashmir just like in Gilgit/Baltistan, Azad Kashmir, FATA, KPK, Punjab, Balochistan, Sindh...they have their own languages though. For instance Sindhi has less correlation with Urdu, Or Pashto or Balochi.

Nice speech though.

Yes, when facts are put into speech, they become nice.

 

[Chhatrapati]

Urdu is very popular in Kashmir just like in Gilgit/Baltistan, Azad Kashmir, FATA, KPK, Punjab, Balochistan, Sindh...they have their own languages though. For instance Sindhi has less correlation with Urdu, Or Pashto or Balochi.

The orginal and unique language of Kashmir is called Koshur. So, no linguistic connection with Pakistani urdu or Punjabi. Although loan words are still there.

You mean the land of Pakistan suddenly appears as a land here in the crossroads of South, Central Asia and Middle East?

No, the land exclusive for Muslims didn't exist before Pakistan. Pakistan was created for Muslims. Such a nation was not created from any country or land mass.

 

[American Pakistani]

The orginal and unique language of Kashmir is called Koshur. So, no linguistic connection with Pakistani urdu or Punjabi. Although loan words are still there.

Why are you repeating yourself like a parrot when you are educated? The unique language of KPK is Pashto but Urdu is popular there, the unique language of Balochistan is Balochi but Urdu is popular there, the unique language of Punjab is Punjabi but Urdu is popular there, the unique language of my home province is Sindhi but Urdu is popular there, similarly the regional language of Kashmir is Kashmiri or Koshur but Urdu is popular there.

No, the land exclusive for Muslims didn't exist before Pakistan. Pakistan was created for Muslims. Such a nation was not created from any country or land mass.

The name Pakistan came into existence in late 1930's but the area of Pakistan was mostly united historically under one empire or civilizations. Just like the name of Iran or Saudia Arabia came into existence not so long ago.

 

[Chhatrapati]

Why are you repeating yourself like a parrot when you are educated?

Because you keep repeating your illogical narrative. Urdu is a second language these are linguistically divided language spoken in the region.
1. Jammu-Dogri
2. Kashmir, valley-Kashmiri (Koshur)
3. Ladakh- Ladakhi
and many more languages. Which changes with region.

Urdu and Hindi are for outsiders to communicate, and a necessity. Kashmir has a unique culture and it's not Pakistani or Punjabi culture.

The name Pakistan came into existence in late 1930's but the area of Pakistan was mostly united historically under one empire or civilizations. Just like the name of Iran or Saudia Arabia came into existence not so long ago.

The name India was there even before Christ. While that being part of the subcontinent.

You have no legal claim over Kashmir, it was a princely state, it was given the right to stay neutral or join any of the union. The decision was supposed to be made by the ruler of the nation. While Hyderabad in India, despite having Hindu majority was ruled by Nizams. We allowed the rule for 7 years since Independence.

 

[American Pakistani]

Because you keep repeating your illogical narrative. Urdu is a second language these are linguistically divided language spoken in the region.
1. Jammu-Dogri
2. Kashmir, valley-Kashmiri (Koshur)
3. Ladakh- Ladakhi
and many more languages. Which changes with region.

Urdu and Hindi are for outsiders to communicate, and a necessity. Kashmir has a unique culture and it's not Pakistani or Punjabi culture.

Phir wohi raag.

The coconut would shatter into pieces if it hit your skull, if you know what I mean. Just like Urdu is popular in entire Pakistan, it is in Kashmir too. No matter if each house speaks their own language.

Pakistan doesn't have punjabi culture. But a common islamic and sufi influenced culture.

The name India was there even before Christ. While that being part of the subcontinent.


You have no legal claim over Kashmir, it was a princely state, it was given the right to stay neutral or join any of the union. The decision was supposed to be made by the ruler of the nation. While Hyderabad in India, despite having Hindu majority was ruled by Nizams. We allowed the rule for 7 years since Independence.

Lol, the name india is borrowed from my home province Sind. Your old name was bharat.

Just like Junagadh, Manvadar and Hyderabad Deccan decided against India but India claimed the areas due to hindu majority and held refrendums.

 

[Chhatrapati]

The coconut would shatter into pieces if it hit your skull, if you know what I mean. Just like Urdu is popular in entire Pakistan, it is in Kashmir too. No matter if each house speaks their own language.

Pakistan doesn't have punjabi culture. But a common islamic and sufi influenced culture.

You are just romanticizing. Major language in Pakistan is Punjabi. Urdu is just official language. Pakistan is a Sunni nation. May be there is Sufi influence. But Sufism is not true Islam.

the name india is borrowed from my home province Sind. Your old name was bharat.

Just like Junagadh, Manvadar and Hyderabad Deccan decided against India but India claimed the areas due to hindu majority and held refrendums.

No, it's a name given to the river Indus which flows through India and then through Pakistan Originating in Tibet.

Sindh is another name derived from Sanskrit word Sindhu meaning river. Indio/India was the name given by the greeks, and formalized by the Iranians, like the name Hindu which went further derivations to form India. Although every name was connected to the River.

India never held referendums in Hyderabad. We invaded Hyderabad and seized control. Those were princely states, that is why they refused to join the union. Similarly Pakistan invaded the princely state of Jammu and Kashmir. He seeded territory to India, we stopped your invasion. How difficult is to understand?