Indian Americans ahead of all other ethnic minorities in US

[neutral_person]

I think big credit goes to the American people and their system, they dont discriminate people on the basis of colour or religion, and that is one of the major cornerstones of American success as a nation.

 

[Korean]

Indian Americans lead all in income, education: Survey - The Economic Times

Their pathways into the US are different, the Pew survey found. About half of all Korean and Indian immigrants who received green cards in 2011 got them on the basis of employer sponsorship, compared with about a third of Japanese, a fifth of Chinese, one-in-eight Filipinos and just one per cent of Vietnamese.

Interesting. So while Indians and Korean immigrants are majority professionals sponsored by US corporations, 80% of Chinese are family sponsored immigrants who then move to Chinatown and open Chinese restaurants or some other sweatshop businesses. Almost all of Vietnamese immigrants are family sponsored.

As you can see, the quality of Asian immigrants are not equal. The whole claims of Chinese scientists and engineers flooding the US is a BS false claim.

My experience back in college was that Chinese students were usually "farmer-looking" people who were in no way equal to Indian students in academic performance. Indians on the other hand were super-impressive and super-professional.

 

[conworldus]

well, aren't 38% NASA scientists Indians?

 

[timetravel]

Indian Americans lead all in income, education: Survey - The Economic Times



Interesting. So while Indians and Korean immigrants are majority professionals sponsored by US corporations, 80% of Chinese are family sponsored immigrants who then move to Chinatown and open Chinese restaurants or some other sweatshop businesses. Almost all of Vietnamese immigrants are family sponsored.

As you can see, the quality of Asian immigrants are not equal. The whole claims of Chinese scientists and engineers flooding the US is a BS false claim.

My experience back in college was that Chinese students were usually "farmer-looking" people who were in no way equal to Indian students in academic performance. Indians on the other hand were super-impressive and super-professional.

the good talent gets the VISA. Americans find the best talent in the world here in India and give them Visa.. Otherwise also Most of the rich people are like normal Indians who went their and earned millions by their sheer hard work... (other then the professionals)

Indians are 10x ahead of Chinese in talent and capabilities.... Just see how India develops in next two decades..

 

[Bond]

what a loser !!!

I see this “India Americans have the highest average earning” fastly becoming “38% of NASA scientists are Indians” V 2.0.

If the latter is just a blatant lie, the former is a crook piece of shameless propaganda with drastically manipulated data!

1. Indians coming to the US are highly selected, unlike Chinese Americans (for numerous generations already) or Euro Americans for example, hence the average earning makes no sense at all to compare with others. It’s apple-orange comparison.

2. The article also stated Indians has almost half of H1B1 of 2011. It means by default Indians landed in America are the best of the best of India, on average, and receive, required by H1BI regulation, much higher wages than the American average. Of course they have “higher average income” compared with others.

3. Further, these H1B1ers are mostly young people, single, white collar, working age, not like other ethnic group for instance, the Chinese Americans or German or Italian or Swiss Americans, being scientists or doctors or builders or civil servants or railway employees… they come from all walks of life unlike highly selected Indian H1B1 which forms the lion share of Indian Americans.

4. Plus, not all working age Americans of other ethnicities work, some between jobs, some are unhealthy or disadvantaged physically receiving govt welfare, while Indians being mostly H1B1 have no such an issue in comparison.

5. Do you know what is Dutch American average income? And those of Spanish Americans? Norwegian Americans? Israeli/Jewish Americans? Belgian Americans? Japanese Americans?... etc. etc. yes, they don’t count other successful ethnicities independently to compare with Indians, as they only count Indians.

6. More, of course they don’t illegal Indians there who are many many more! Far more than 3 or 4 million Indians reported. Every time I go to America, I can readily see many Indians working in 7/11s, shabby car wash, motels along highways… of course, they don’t count those.

7. If the US were to sets up a visa called H100B2 tomorrow and employ 20 best Africans from Congo Republic with USD 70,000 salary, in the same logic and comparison method aren’t the Congonese the most successful ethnicity of America? --- as ridiculous and as manipulated as what the OP “polls” claim!

Last, there is no such a thing as “Asian American”. Indian American originally didn’t belong to “Asia” category. Indians lobbied the congress to out them under “Asian” title in order to qualify the very juicy Minority Loans. Utter shameless!

Those minority loans are sort of “compensation”frankly to many real minorities such as the Chinese for their historical huge contributions made to the rise of America while being unfairly treated/discriminated. Indians are the new comers in comparison, mostly coming in for the last 2 decades or so, and they contributed nothing, nothing! , to the rise of America historically while stealing these precious and limited loans! A bunch of thieves, really!

 

[fallstuff]

I see this “India Americans have the highest average earning” fastly becoming “38% of NASA scientists are Indians” V 2.0.

If the latter is just a blatant lie, the former is a crook piece of shameless propaganda with drastically manipulated data!

1. Indians coming to the US are highly selected, unlike Chinese Americans (for numerous generations already) or Euro Americans for example, hence the average earning makes no sense at all to compare with others. It’s apple-orange comparison.

2. The article also stated Indians has almost half of H1B1 of 2011. It means by default Indians landed in America are the best of the best of India, on average, and receive, required by H1BI regulation, much higher wages than the American average. Of course they have “higher average income” compared with others.

3. Further, these H1B1ers are mostly young people, single, white collar, working age, not like other ethnic group for instance, the Chinese Americans or German or Italian or Swiss Americans, being scientists or doctors or builders or civil servants or railway employees… they come from all walks of life unlike highly selected Indian H1B1 which forms the lion share of Indian Americans.

4. Plus, not all working age Americans of other ethnicities work, some between jobs, some are unhealthy or disadvantaged physically receiving govt welfare, while Indians being mostly H1B1 have no such an issue in comparison.

5. Do you know what is Dutch American average income? And those of Spanish Americans? Norwegian Americans? Israeli/Jewish Americans? Belgian Americans? Japanese Americans?... etc. etc. yes, they don’t count other successful ethnicities independently to compare with Indians, as they only count Indians.

6. More, of course they don’t illegal Indians there who are many many more! Far more than 3 or 4 million Indians reported. Every time I go to America, I can readily see many Indians working in 7/11s, shabby car wash, motels along highways… of course, they don’t count those.

7. If the US were to sets up a visa called H100B2 tomorrow and employ 20 best Africans from Congo Republic with USD 70,000 salary, in the same logic and comparison method aren’t the Congonese the most successful ethnicity of America? --- as ridiculous and as manipulated as what the OP “polls” claim!

Last, there is no such a thing as “Asian American”. Indian American originally didn’t belong to “Asia” category. Indians lobbied the congress to out them under “Asian” title in order to qualify the very juicy Minority Loans. Utter shameless!

Those minority loans are sort of “compensation”frankly to many real minorities such as the Chinese for their historical huge contributions made to the rise of America while being unfairly treated/discriminated. Indians are the new comers in comparison, mostly coming in for the last 2 decades or so, and they contributed nothing, nothing! , to the rise of America historically while stealing these precious and limited loans! A bunch of thieves, really!

How is an H1 Visa holder an Indian-American ? Certainly an Indian, but not an Indian-American.

 

[notsuperstitious]

Most importantly Indian Americans acknowledge the gift of opportunity that country offered them and are generally grateful and loyal to that nation. Infact applies to all Indian all over the world. I'm living out of India for a long time now and half my family is American.

Living in one country, enjoying their good parts and then dissing it the same time is fortunately not a trait non resident indians exhibit.

 

[shuttler]

indians need a predominant white country to confrim their worth. how pathetic!

 

[Omar1984]

china's population is more than India. I'm afraid you're gonna have to ask them about no sex policy.

China has a land mass 4 times bigger than India and the population of both countries are almost the same.

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

China has a land mass 4 times bigger than India and the population of both countries are almost the same.

Firstly china is 3 times as big as India and apart from that India has more arable land than China . 'Real population density' is always measured on arable land .

 

[Omar1984]

Indians do well everywhere except in their own country

That's because all the rich Indians dream of leaving India to serve coffee and donuts to white people in America.

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

That's because all the rich Indians dream of leaving India to serve coffee and donuts to white people in America.

That's what your people are doing that is why they are nowhere in the list of well performing communities . Infact in UK and Canda , Pakistanis are one of the poorest communities falling below poverty line .

 

[Omar1984]

Firstly china is 3 times as big as India and apart from that India has more arable land than China . 'Real population density' is always measured on arable land .

China is less crowded than india.

List of sovereign states and dependent territories by population density - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[ChinaToday]

I see this “India Americans have the highest average earning” fastly becoming “38% of NASA scientists are Indians” V 2.0.

If the latter is just a blatant lie, the former is a crook piece of shameless propaganda with drastically manipulated data!

1. Indians coming to the US are highly selected, unlike Chinese Americans (for numerous generations already) or Euro Americans for example, hence the average earning makes no sense at all to compare with others. It’s apple-orange comparison.

2. The article also stated Indians has almost half of H1B1 of 2011. It means by default Indians landed in America are the best of the best of India, on average, and receive, required by H1BI regulation, much higher wages than the American average. Of course they have “higher average income” compared with others.

3. Further, these H1B1ers are mostly young people, single, white collar, working age, not like other ethnic group for instance, the Chinese Americans or German or Italian or Swiss Americans, being scientists or doctors or builders or civil servants or railway employees… they come from all walks of life unlike highly selected Indian H1B1 which forms the lion share of Indian Americans.

4. Plus, not all working age Americans of other ethnicities work, some between jobs, some are unhealthy or disadvantaged physically receiving govt welfare, while Indians being mostly H1B1 have no such an issue in comparison.

5. Do you know what is Dutch American average income? And those of Spanish Americans? Norwegian Americans? Israeli/Jewish Americans? Belgian Americans? Japanese Americans?... etc. etc. yes, they don’t count other successful ethnicities independently to compare with Indians, as they only count Indians.

6. More, of course they don’t illegal Indians there who are many many more! Far more than 3 or 4 million Indians reported. Every time I go to America, I can readily see many Indians working in 7/11s, shabby car wash, motels along highways… of course, they don’t count those.

7. If the US were to sets up a visa called H100B2 tomorrow and employ 20 best Africans from Congo Republic with USD 70,000 salary, in the same logic and comparison method aren’t the Congonese the most successful ethnicity of America? --- as ridiculous and as manipulated as what the OP “polls” claim!

Last, there is no such a thing as “Asian American”. Indian American originally didn’t belong to “Asia” category. Indians lobbied the congress to out them under “Asian” title in order to qualify the very juicy Minority Loans. Utter shameless!

Those minority loans are sort of “compensation”frankly to many real minorities such as the Chinese for their historical huge contributions made to the rise of America while being unfairly treated/discriminated. Indians are the new comers in comparison, mostly coming in for the last 2 decades or so, and they contributed nothing, nothing! , to the rise of America historically while stealing these precious and limited loans! A bunch of thieves, really!

Wow hats off to you man for the details analysis to bust the indian bubble

 

[Javad]

So like I said, since Indians are very successful in US, could it also be one of the reasons paks play Indians there?
I mean
nobody likes to be known as unsuccessful and failed, its an obvious human tendency.

Well I guess indians would have done the same thing in case they were discriminated and had security issues.