What's new

India has almost wiped out extreme poverty: International Monetary Fund

I know that when the reports came in that India has slipped into poverty, all those eho are questioning today were ready to believe anything damn. India has taken walfare steps for their people found unparallel in the hisyory of mankind. Rs 5 lakh free medical treatment rights to over 10 crore families, over 2 crore free houses to poor, over 10 crore free electricity connections, 99 pc coverage of bank accounts and sanitation. Today in India, a poor guy can do bypass surgery in India in an expense lower than a guy taking dinner in a good restaurant in US or Europe. Small operations like cataract, teeth tratment etc is done free in hundreds of places by expert doctors. Nothing amongs above is highlighted. India does not believe in spending on showoff of wealth while people can not afford basic medicine and treatment like in western nations, China etc. Skills of Indian medical practitioners are at different level with lots of alternate therapies. Today, cancer, kideny failures, heart blockages etc are treated without any medicines by people having no formal degrees in medicine. There are many people who are asked to do bypass surgery are treated and made made healthy without any medicines. Many critical cancer Pations are treated and made decease free without medicines or with hurble medicines. People hardly know anything about India.
 
Last edited:
.
Pakistan and Sri Lanka in South Asia wiped it out more than 20 years ago afaik
Screenshot_2020-12-11 World Poverty Clock.png
 
Last edited:
.
With super powa like India who are masters of farts and love to dance to the rhythm of the Bollywood with bru like no other anything is possible.
Actually I studied in the top Universities of your master country which used to stick notices on their doors in your country which used to state "Indians and dogs are not allowed".

They may be masters of yours. Our second grade intellectuals rules the countries you are refering to. You must have taken coaching from an Indian teacher if you had studied in any good university.
 
.
As much as I wish this report was true, I doubt its credibility considering it was written by an Indian nationalist. It just isn't in the interest of their corrupted rulers to wipe out poverty just like Pakistan even though both easily can.
 
.
This is some"still working "publication meant for Indian consumption of modi regime.Not official IMF publication.All in all just a scam,as if beggars of streets disappeared.
 
Last edited:
.
While I hope it is true (since I don't want the poor to starve and die) It is IMF, a well known liar and the main reasons countries are facing poverty in the first place
 
. .
Pakistan and Sri Lanka in South Asia wiped it out more than 20 years ago afaik
Pakistan - 1250 usd per capita
sri Lanka - 3800 usd per capita

Pakistan is above wartorn Afghanistan .
Same as nepal.

This is some"still working "publication meant for Indian consumption of modi regime.Not official IMF publication.All in all just a scam,as if beggars if streets disappeared.
i was chased by beggers in your shiny china just outside a high speed rail station.
 
.

India has almost wiped out extreme poverty: International Monetary Fund​

In India, the number of people living in extreme poverty -- defined by the World Bank as living on US$1.9 or less in purchasing power parity (PPP) terms -- was 0.8% of the population in the pre-pandemic year 2019, stated the IMF paper, published on April 5, 2022.




file-photo-international-monetary-fund-logo-seen_e1b65fb6-1414-11eb-b504-c4c734a23405_1649312936408.jpg
India has almost wiped out extreme poverty, says IMF(REUTERS)
Updated on Apr 07, 2022 05:40 PM IST

ByZia Haq
New Delhi: India has almost eradicated extreme poverty and brought down consumption inequality to its lowest levels in 40 years through state-provided food handouts, according to a new working paper published by the International Monetary Fund (IMF).
The IMF working paper -- authored by economists Surjit Bhalla, Arvind Virmani and Karan Bhasin -- said that the proportion of people living in extreme poverty, at less than 1%, remained steady even during the pandemic on the back of “in-kind” subsidies, especially food rations.


The study comes at a time when several recent global reports have pointed to the widening gap between the rich and poor in Asia’s third-largest economy, while studies on the economic shocks of the Covid-19 pandemic vary in their conclusions.

In India, the number of people living in extreme poverty -- defined by the World Bank as living on US$1.9 or less in purchasing power parity (PPP) terms -- was 0.8% of the population in the pre-pandemic year 2019, stated the IMF paper, published on April 5, 2022.

Food rations were “instrumental” in ensuring that extreme poverty did not increase and “remained at that low level” in the pandemic year 2020, the study found. PPP is a metric that equalises the buying power of different currencies to make comparisons easy.
Our results also demonstrate the social safety net provided by the expansion of India’s food subsidy program absorbed a major part of the pandemic shock,” the authors stated. Such back-to-back low poverty rates suggest India has eliminated extreme poverty, they concluded.

Also read:

What sets their study apart, according to the authors, is the effect of subsidy adjustments on poverty. The results are “striking”, they said in the working paper. Food handouts curbed poverty by acting like “cash transfers”.

IMF states that its working papers describe research in progress, and are published to elicit comments.

Real (inflation-adjusted) inequality, as measured by the Gini coefficient, which stands at 0.294, is now very close to its lowest level 0.284 observed in 1993-94, the paper stated. The Gini coefficient ranges from 0 to 1, with 0 representing perfect equality and 1 representing perfect inequality.

The food subsidy is 5kg per person. In terms of a household, that would be about 25 kg a month. Now if you convert that into prices, that would come to about ₹750. This is not an insignificant amount for really poor households,” said Pronab Sen, former chief statistician of India.

“But I cannot imagine ₹750 changing the inequality part of it. Absolute poverty in terms of hunger…yes, but inequality is a different ballgame. ₹750 is just not enough to move the needle on inequality,” Sen added.

Also read: Why IMF praised PM Modi’s food security scheme during pandemic

Most previous studies and measures of poverty and inequality did not account for the role of food handouts, the paper’s authors noted. “These (new) estimates include, for the first time, the effect of in-kind food subsides on poverty and inequality,” the paper stated.

I like this, I want to believe this, but I don't trust Surjit Bhalla one millimetre. He has carried a chip on his shoulder for decades now, nursing a huge grudge that he has been left out and sidelined by the economics establishment.

This is a top down study, and it is preferable to do empirical work on food and calorific intake in the field, and put these together for a fair understanding.

And that's it? That's your reaction?

Haha yea right. everyone calls india slumistan for a reason
Usually the Schadenfreude of losers looking for someone to look down upon.

That is why I would like to see the empirical work that would back up these papers.
It also needs to be said that your name to a post about India is a sure sign of dredging the Internet for negative news. You lack personal credibility.

Do you know who wrote that report?

"Surjit Bhalla never fails to amaze one with his imaginative rendition of otherwise boring and clinical economics. For starters, Surjit is known or understood differently to different people: a “reputed economist”, a “pro-Modi economist”, someone who “looks for a dog who did not bark”, an economist “who molests poverty data”, to just sample a few.


For the record: He is the executive director for India, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and Bhutan at the International Monetary Fund (IMF). He was also a part-time Member of the Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister (of India) before resigning from the position in December 2018.


His latest paper Pandemic poverty and Inequality: Evidence from India has been published on the IMF website under the ‘IMF Working Paper’ section. Such papers are supposed to elicit comments and discussions, and as IMF has reiterated, views expressed in this paper “do not necessarily represent the views of the IMF, its executive board, or IMF management.”



He does inspire scepticism.

If bill gates reaches india will feel poor.
If he doesn't, India will feel rich. Great.

India is a giant malnourished toilet with extreme poverty. They literally have a slave race by caste.
You need to stop examining the toilet bowl. There are better ways to spend your time.
 
Last edited:
.
Exactly. Half-baked one-word pundits are total rubbish.

Are you sure or very sure or very very sure then what next? Indians living on the Mars and taking their dogs for a walk??
Possibly. Want someone to take out the leash? Naturally, I am referring to a real live dog.

The next stage of removal of hunger poverty is walking on Mars? Where have you studed? Re-education camp school?
Let's not get personal. Sometimes the results are horrifying. Not all of these wise men have gone beyond school.

With super powa like India who are masters of farts and love to dance to the rhythm of the Bollywood with bru like no other anything is possible.
@Surya 1

I told you so. This is all they are capable of.

Pakistan and Sri Lanka in South Asia wiped it out more than 20 years ago afaik
Does that make a later achievement NOT an achievement? What is your logic here?

They may be masters of yours. Our second grade intellectuals rules the countries you are refering to. You must have taken coaching from an Indian teacher if you had studied in any good university.
Again, you are rushing into dangerous territory.

While I hope it is true (since I don't want the poor to starve and die) It is IMF, a well known liar and the main reasons countries are facing poverty in the first place
Are you still resentful of not getting their money?
 
Last edited:
.
LOL... One of the biggest jokes of the day... Unless you re-define extreme poverty..
Does that mean you looked at the definition, understood it, and object to it? What defines extreme poverty, according to you? Can we get specific?

Pakistan - 1250 usd per capita
sri Lanka - 3800 usd per capita

Pakistan is above wartorn Afghanistan .
Same as nepal.


i was chased by beggers in your shiny china just outside a high speed rail station.
Not HIS China. He is a Mizo.
 
.
Are you still resentful of not getting their money
Maybe you didn’t care to read my statement properly
I called imf the root of all problems why would I want their loans?

Or lack of comprehension is another issue alongside extreme poverty in India?
 
. .
Pakistan - 1250 usd per capita
sri Lanka - 3800 usd per capita

Pakistan is above wartorn Afghanistan .
Same as nepal.


i was chased by beggers in your shiny china just outside a high speed rail station.
Not HIS China. He is a Mizo.
Maybe you didn’t care to read my statement properly
I called imf the root of all problems why would I want their loans?

Or lack of comprehension is another issue alongside extreme poverty in India?
I did not think that you, as an individual, were eligible for IMF intervention. What a surprise!
 
.
Does that mean you looked at the definition, understood it, and object to it? What defines extreme poverty, according to you? Can we get specific?
Its very easy, Just look at India you will know what extreme poverty is because any source or definition would be hogwash for you..
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom