Imran Khan defend Taliban justice system on BBC

[Taimoor Khan]

He is talking about Pakhtun culture and Jirga system. Taliban happen to be a Pakhtun movement.

 

[Finer]

Imran Khan messed it up big time. He failed to distinct between TTP and Afghan Taliban and the history of 80s in regards to the collaboration between USA and Pakistan on Afghan Mujahideen - later became Afghan Taliban.

Instead he ended up justifying the backward system of Taliban denouncing the Zarb-e-Azb and all the sacrifices Pakistan army made for the safety of Pakistan since it was Pakistan's war given the official confession from Ajit Doval, Indian NSA, handpicked by Genocidal communal Modi with the background of hatred on Indian Muslims and Pakistan.

Bilawal Bhutto summed it very well in one of BBC interview in the past on foreign policy and why Zarb-e-Azb was imperative to succeed against Indian-funded Afghan-based TTP that is responsible for the death of more than 100,000 including children and women and beyond.

And Imran Khan is saying that Bilawal Bhutto was parachuted into the politics he knows nothing of. Unfortunately, it is Imran Khan who is rigid and still fails to see the threat that TTP imposes on Pakistan in terms of politically, economically, societal of the state, and the safety of the citizens.

It is no wonder why Imran Khan was pro-TTP who brought peace proposal in COAS meeting to counter the proposal of General Kiyani, and judging by BBC interview, that hasn't changed unfortunately. I doubt the main establishment would take risk with the rigid Khan who pretty much undermined the foreign policy of the main establishment knowingly or unknowingly.

I suspect Bilawal Bhutto might be shocker surprise in the upcoming election since Zardari was well behaved for the main establishment and i suspect that the main establishment cannot afford drama any more at this stage. At the end, GOD knows best.

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

terrorist why don't you go to Afghanistan to live in taliban heaven and leave rest of sane Pakistanis alone in peace?

This is not an appropriate thing to say. We are all Pakistanis and Muslims here. Take a look at the Indian who liked your post.

Regarding the topic, Pukhtoon system of justice is a model for the rest of Pakistan. Imran Khan is totally correct here. As we become a more homogeneous country, there will be a lot of borrowing between provinces.

Imran Khan messed it up big time. He failed to distinct between TTP and Afghan Taliban and the history of 80s in regards to the collaboration between USA and Pakistan on Afghan Mujahideen - later became Afghan Taliban.

Instead he ended up justifying the backward system of Taliban denouncing the Zarb-e-Azb and all the sacrifices Pakistan army made for the safety of Pakistan since it was Pakistan's war given the official confession from Ajit Doval, Indian NSA, handpicked by Genocidal communal Modi with the background of hatred on Indian Muslims and Pakistan.

Bilawal Bhutto summed it very well in one of BBC interview in the past on foreign policy and why Zarb-e-Azb was imperative to succeed against Indian-funded Afghan-based TTP that is responsible for the death of more than 100,000 including children and women and beyond.

And Imran Khan is saying that Bilawal Bhutto was parachuted into the politics he knows nothing of. Unfortunately, it is Imran Khan who is rigid and still fails to see the threat that TTP imposes on Pakistan in terms of politically, economically, societal of the state, and the safety of the citizens.

It is no wonder why Imran Khan was pro-TTP who brought peace proposal in COAS meeting to counter the proposal of General Kiyani, and judging by BBC interview, that hasn't changed unfortunately. I doubt the main establishment would take risk with the rigid Khan who pretty much undermined the foreign policy of the main establishment knowingly or unknowingly.

I suspect Bilawal Bhutto might be shocker surprise in the upcoming election since Zardari was well behaved for the main establishment and i suspect that the main establishment cannot afford drama any more at this stage. At the end, GOD knows best.

TTP is not pro-Imran Khan. They have put a bounty on him. Pukhtoon leaders of former-FATA respect Imran Khan for his stances against operations and drone attacks. Imran Khan did not want a repeat of the displacement of tribals like Musharraf did which would breed TTP and other extremist groups. However, Imran Khan always applauds the army for its good role in rooting out TTP.

Aren’t political leaders allowed to have different points of view and also be wrong? Imran Khan has never criticized the army like Nawaz and Zardari.

In KPK, you either have Imran Khan’s pro-nationalist movement or you get anti-Pakistan and actual pro-TTP movements like PTM, MMA, or ANP.

 

[313ghazi]

are you advocating to introduce it all over pakistan....

The exact system - no. Only because there is no guaruntee that the Jirga is aware of the correct legal rights of the parties involved.

The principles - yes. Justice should be easily accessible, it should be free to access, it should be quick, should be transparent and most importantly - should be just in accordance to Shariah and any other laws of the state of Pakistan which are not in contradition with the Quran and Sunnah.

 

[veg]

That was the ttp scum, imran was talking abt the afghan taliban.

The Foolishness of Imran Khan was also responsible of Swat Crises and displacement of 10 million people

This is not the first time, but Imran Khan did exactly the same thing in the Past, where Imran Khan was praising the "Nizam-e-Muhammadi" of Mullah Sufi.

At that time Imran Khan was also telling the nation that people of Swat want Jirga System and they want the Sharia system, and canals of honey and milk are going to flow in Swat due to this Nizam-e-Muhammadi system.

Due to the Foolishness of Imran Khan and other foolish politicians like him, Pak Army had to take out it's forces from the Swat and hand it over to the Mullah Sufi Muhammad.

And then result was this that Taliban came back (while earlier they fled from the city due to the Army presence) and within 3 days Taliban got control of whole Swat, and then started slaughtering people in the Mian Bazar of Swat in name of Sharia, and then started offensives in the nearby areas towards Islamabad.

Due to this foolishness of Imran Khan like leaders, finally Army was compelled to start a huge OPERATION with in the city of Swat, displacing 10 million people, destroying the whole city, and state had to bear the expenses of billions of Rs.


But this gutter dirty Imran Khan still didn't learn the lesson.

He kept on giving money to the Sami ul Haq Madrassas (as bribe, but his blind worshippers still not able to see it).

He kept on giving statements that Pak Army now should leave Swat.

He kept on hindering the Army Operation against Taliban in every possible way.

 

[abc123xyx]

He is talking about Pakhtun culture and Jirga system. Taliban happen to be a Pakhtun movement.

no please for god....don't blame every thing on pustoones...

 

[Taimoor Khan]

no please for god....don't blame every thing on pustoones...

Where is the blame? Did you actually saw IK interview? His government is already implementing a similar Jirga system at police stations for easy and free justice for people of KPK.

Btw, what this got to do with you, an Indian?

 

[Reichsmarschall]

no please for god....don't blame every thing on pustoones...

Daa tor makh de wrak sha!

 

[defence_analyst]

well ill suggest you read Mullah Zaeefs book i forgot the title it was released long time back ull understand many things about Afghan taliban and not ttp or isis!

and i was wathching this 10 mins doc on theguardian (wll share link when i find it) it was interview of Mi6 spy who infiltrated Al qaeda and he was aksed how he views isis and how is it different from Al Qaeda his reply was Al qaeda no matter how twisted their ideology was and wrong they were they it was a group of highly educated people engineers drs etc Isis has thugs rapist criminals etc and they are out of conteol...so same is the difference bw Afghan taliban and Ttp!

Afghan taliban fought for their country and people of Afghanistan!

Afghani taliban and TTP is same. Same ideology and same tactics. Only difference is one is fighting Pakistan state so is bad and other is fighting afghani state so its good in twisted Pakistani mindset.

 

[Proudpakistaniguy]

Imran Khan messed it up big time. He failed to distinct between TTP and Afghan Taliban and the history of 80s in regards to the collaboration between USA and Pakistan on Afghan Mujahideen - later became Afghan Taliban.

Instead he ended up justifying the backward system of Taliban denouncing the Zarb-e-Azb and all the sacrifices Pakistan army made for the safety of Pakistan since it was Pakistan's war given the official confession from Ajit Doval, Indian NSA, handpicked by Genocidal communal Modi with the background of hatred on Indian Muslims and Pakistan.

Bilawal Bhutto summed it very well in one of BBC interview in the past on foreign policy and why Zarb-e-Azb was imperative to succeed against Indian-funded Afghan-based TTP that is responsible for the death of more than 100,000 including children and women and beyond.

And Imran Khan is saying that Bilawal Bhutto was parachuted into the politics he knows nothing of. Unfortunately, it is Imran Khan who is rigid and still fails to see the threat that TTP imposes on Pakistan in terms of politically, economically, societal of the state, and the safety of the citizens.

It is no wonder why Imran Khan was pro-TTP who brought peace proposal in COAS meeting to counter the proposal of General Kiyani, and judging by BBC interview, that hasn't changed unfortunately. I doubt the main establishment would take risk with the rigid Khan who pretty much undermined the foreign policy of the main establishment knowingly or unknowingly.

I suspect Bilawal Bhutto might be shocker surprise in the upcoming election since Zardari was well behaved for the main establishment and i suspect that the main establishment cannot afford drama any more at this stage. At the end, GOD knows best.

I dont like ANP party but they were right about taliban and i was completely agree with their strong stand against talibans. They challenge them because of which they had to sacrificed many of their political workers whom taliban targeted while on other hand PTI or Imran always has softer approach toward talibans

well taliban ruled afghanistan and created law so technically they were following law of land! and that law ensure speedy justice to people of afghanistan not like phuddu corrupt Pakistani courts!

Techically they had no right to impose themselves on others ..First of all how they got in power? Who elected them? Speedy justice without any due process of law is barbarism otherwise you will end up getting lashes just for watching TV, talking with girls, listening music, or even not keeping beard

You should be given opportunity to live under taliabni system if you are so fond of them because naive peopel like you glorify buchter and opporessor..Few good things done by taliban cannot justify their cruelty and barbarism

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

Imran Khan already clarified that he meant the Pukhtoon system of justice and not Taliban law.

Let’s bury this topic.

 

[pzfz]

So now you posted a video all the sudden which should had been done when you opened the thread?
So defending a Jigra system is the same as defending taliban system? What kind of moronic logic is this? Do you know that Jigra system was there way before any taliban ever exited?
Every society and culture has its on norms and values and If you dont accept it, who gives you the right to impose your version of the justice system on them? By doing so you no better either and actually fall into the same category, that you accuse taliban off?
PS stop nitpicking IK speech and twist it to suit your own agenda here. Readers can decide it for themselves. You should had the decency to put forward his video first before opening a thread with a doctored title.

IceCold yaar, another tattu has graced PDF. This defence_analyst sounds like a 2-bit copy of "defense analyst" ayesha siddiqa. Anyways kudos to those call it like it is: Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan (Afghan Taliban) and TTP are completely different. One is an indigenous Afghanistani movement against foreign occupation with massive local support and the other is a foreign-based entity fighting a losing battle against the Pakistani people.

 

[Finer]

TTP is not pro-Imran Khan. They have put a bounty on him. Pukhtoon leaders of former-FATA respect Imran Khan for his stances against operations and drone attacks. Imran Khan did not want a repeat of the displacement of tribals like Musharraf did which would breed TTP and other extremist groups. However, Imran Khan always applauds the army for its good role in rooting out TTP.

Given the history of Imran Khan's pro stance on TTP, his official stance in regards to peace proposal with TTP in the COAS meeting, 2014, and just now, he just said on BBC interview that it is not Pakistan's war.

Are you telling me that Indian-funded Afghan-based Terrorist-outfit TTP aka khawarij is not threat to Pakistan given that they are responsible for more than 100,000 deaths including children and women and beyond?

Aren’t political leaders allowed to have different points of view and also be wrong? Imran Khan has never criticized the army like Nawaz and Zardari.

Debate is one thing but terrorism is another. And pro-stance on Indian-funded Afghan-based Terrorist-outfit aka TTP qualifies for treason.

In KPK, you either have Imran Khan’s pro-nationalist movement or you get anti-Pakistan and actual pro-TTP movements like PTM, MMA, or ANP.

Anyone who support terrorism is not just anti-Pakistani but also anti-humanity, and the enemy of GOD.

We are talking about Indian-funded Afghan-based Terrorist-outfit aka TTP that is khawarij which Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) warned us and told us to kill those khawarij by any means necessary for what they are from dogs of hellfire.