If India & China go on war who will win?

[jetray]

We have Y-20 strategic transport from now on, since it's made in China we can build this by hundred, and you can be sure that our supply line will have FedEx overnight service.

all we need is few stinger missiles to bring them down. Again you can only land them far away from battle field and have to use ground based transport to reach the battle field.

 

[waz]

Yes thats right but infra can be easily destroyed and once winter sets in the passes will be blocked. Once infra is neutralized odds will even out as it. India will not face utter defeat as its economic hinterland is far away from the battlefield and the economic activity will still continue. It will be the same case for china as well.

Its only the all out war using missiles that will lead will lead to disaster for both sides as any attack on populated cities will lead to heavy causalities. Again here it will be who will cause the max damage, china wont fight a war for the same reason India doesnt fight a war with pakistan.

I agree with parts of the post but to destroy infrastructure far from the Indian line you would have to either resort to ballistic missiles, but remember rail lines can be repaired quite easily, and you'll also need a great number of them. The other option is to send in the IAF but that's risky with Chinese air defence and of course the PLAF will also be there.
Economic activity will always be effected by war mate, because you must remember the role that expectations plays with markets, investment and trade. Expectations and confidence will be shot to hell in the event of a conflict. I don't believe either side will attack population centres, it would be a straight fight with each other's military.

 

[Ajaxpaul]

And that's the very reason that you can stop us over CPEC even without the treaty.

I could not get you....As far as CPEC goes India has a problem in Kashmir that's it. We don't intend to stop CPEC. If we had a corridor to Afghanistan and central Asia via OBOR we would have been great ful.

 

[Kiss_of_the_Dragon]

all we need is few stinger missiles to bring them down.

Lol before you could even arm your stinger, these cargo plane deliver enough of fire power to our force to completely put Indian army out of commission.

 

[jetray]

Lol before you could even arm your stinger, these cargo plane deliver enough of fire power to our force to completely put Indian army out of commission.

yeah keep dreaming, u will spend more time supplying food packets and blankets. Its a mountainous region and a small number of troops can harass a large number of troops. There is nothing much on Indian side to destroy not even roads.

 

[satishkumarcsc]

The West.

 

[Eminent Mainstream Media]

That's why they are churning out transport craft and building infrastructure to bride that gap.

https://jamestown.org/program/china-and-indias-border-infrastructure-race/

Read under China.

Yes there will be damage to both sides, but India will face utter defeat.

Do you understand how costly It would be for China to sustain a campaign in Tibet- What are the problems associated with such altitude, climate and geography- forget about man, even machines under perform and fail regularly-

India has to sit on the ridges and make sure the standoff situation for 5-8 years with a minimum presence of 400-600 thousand Chinese troops near Indian border- China will fall, I am not even talking about Tibet. For China to win they have to cut across Silliguri corridor with Tank and Mechanized divisions and mount a Naval Marine landing of 200-300 thousand troops in Calcutta or Bangladesh-

There's a reason China withdrew in 1962 war even when they had already won the territory they are so ferociously claiming even today- Tawang and the region around that was captured by China, yet they withdrew- In 1986 when the Indian troops again crossed the line and took positions on Sumdorong Chu they choose peace and negotiation and Indian demand of keeping that zone demilitarized was accepted-

Interestingly Sumdorong Chu is on the eastern ridges opposite to Namka Chu which triggered the 1962 war when Indian troops occupied that position- Indians troops as of Today is in far better positions near Namka Chu and Sumdorong Chu, In the event of war these positions will fall quicker and they will be in a position of creating another valley of death in the Tawang region as they already have in Sikkim region WRT to Chumbi valley thanks to the higher positions at Nathu la, and Dokh la- Place where current stand off is going on-

I would advice you to open the Google map and see the regions and geography, Indians are at disadvantage in Daulat Beg oldie in Laddakh sector and Tawang, rest of the places our troops are in good positions- As of Infrastructure the roads are of the class of what you saw during Kargil war or better, you would remember Indian troops mobilization during that war and how fast It was done-

In 5-6 years there will be rail connectivity to both Tawang and Leh laddakh- Chinese rail is presently at Lahsa which is 200-300km from the Indian border- The closes Chinese airfield is also 200km from Indian border-

We have Y-20 strategic transport from now on, since it's made in China we can build this by hundred, and you can be sure that our supply line will have FedEx overnight service.

The one who keeps their combat plane flying high, with greater loads and for longer will maintain Air Dominance- Geography suits India here-

 

[Kiss_of_the_Dragon]

I could not get you....As far as CPEC goes India has a problem in Kashmir that's it. We don't intend to stop CPEC. If we had a corridor to Afghanistan and central Asia via OBOR we would have been great ful.

Sure you have intention but not the capability to stop CPEC and that is why Indian government are whining about this corridor all the time, what I'm trying to say if India can have such security treaty with Bhutan and don't come to complain that we have "informal" treaty Pakistan and help Pakistan over J&K issue...this what we call geo-politic parity...we will get even.

 

[Ajaxpaul]

Sure you have intention but not the capability to stop CPEC and that is why Indian government are whining about this corridor all the time, what I'm trying to say if India can have such security treaty with Bhutan and don't come to complain that we have "informal" treaty Pakistan and help Pakistan over J&K issue...this what we call geo-politic parity...we will get even.

We have a treaty and we got into the action as per the treaty. What is the outcome...I don't know. Will come to know gradually.

But you may have informal treaty with pakistan but history shows china not getting involved. Of course it may change with CPEC but this is irrelevant in this thread.

 

[Eminent Mainstream Media]

Dude, you have no idea who Sunny Deol is, she has natural assets

He is Sunny Deol-

You Should see some of his movies-

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

They can use ballistic missiles but that will all out war and will cause a lot of damage to both sides.

No need for ballistic missiles, even China's conventional rocket artillery has a range of over 400+ km. And conventional rocket artillery shells are extremely cheap and easy to mass produce.

It's India's misfortune that New Delhi is only 300 km from the border, and needless to say, basically every major target in North and Northeast India will also be in range.

Not a favorable situation for India, to say the least.

 

[Kiss_of_the_Dragon]

yeah keep dreaming, u will spend more time supplying food packets and blankets. Its a mountainous region and a small number of troops can harass a large number of troops. There is nothing much on Indian side to destroy not even roads.

Tibet today is not Tibet in 1962, you can be sure we will bring more army and supply faster than India either para-drop or using airport.

 

[Arsalan 345]

All I know is that China compares itself with america but comparing India with China is not justified.China is much bigger and they are making all their weapons specially transport aircrafts and artillery so they have massive advantage over India.and that chickens neck is so important for India and China knows it.this pla is way ahead in planning.what India will get with this conflict? It will create panic and I don't think that India is ready for a war with China.look at homegrown tejas and t-90s and look at China,they are making everything,from gun to aircrafts.only a fool can fight a war with China.use diplomatic channels and relax India.

 

[mirage]

China will win...India will be humiliated...

Remember 1962?

Most of the tactics/doctrine of Indian armed forces are made and applied at Pakistani border...China knows that and will take advantage of it...

Pakistan will help them for sure, covertly or overtly...

yea , on PDF 100 % china will win, BTW do wear panties while cheerleading , bye for now 62

 

[Ajaxpaul]

All I know is that China compares itself with america but comparing India with China is not justified.China is much bigger and they are making all their weapons specially transport aircrafts and artillery so they have massive advantage over India.and that chickens neck is so important for India and China knows it.this pla is way ahead in planning.what India will get with this conflict? It will create panic and I don't think that India is ready for a war with China.look at homegrown tejas and t-90s and look at China,they are making everything,from gun to aircrafts.only a fool can fight a war with China.use diplomatic channels and relax India.

Who says there will be war ? Idiots in PDF maybe