If India & China go on war who will win?

[Han Patriot]

Sunny leoni is different from Sunny Deol.

Oooo thanks bro. I nearly turned gay there.

 

[ashok321]

If India & China go on war who will win?

 

[waz]

China has an overwhelming superiority on all fronts, and has a defence industry that produces everything they need. There is no contest.

 

[ashok321]

If India & China go on war who will win?

There is another dimension to it:

Pakistan will voluntarily jump into the fray to the consternation of Indians to bleed India profusely.

India = Aa bail mujhe maar

 

[Stephen Cohen]

China has an overwhelming superiority on all fronts, and has a defence industry that produces everything they need. There is no contest.

Have you ever wondered that INSPITE of Wanting Indian Territory ie South Tibet
(90000 SQ KM )
and inspite of Having Pakistan as an Ally which can join a War started by China
Still China has Not fired a single bullet after 1975

What is holding them back

These are the same Chinese that are fighting with Other Asian countries
for Fishing shoals and artificial islands

 

[waz]

Have you ever wondered that INSPITE of Wanting Indian Territory ie South Tibet
(90000 SQ KM )
and inspite of Having Pakistan as an Ally which can join a War started by China
Still China has Not fired a single bullet after 1975

What is holding them back

These are the same Chinese that are fighting with Other Asian countries
for Fishing shoals and artificial islands

They don't need to, their progress speaks for itself. Also remember they beat you in a conflict before. I can't believe you are ever contemplating the question.

 

[Stephen Cohen]

They don't need to, their progress speaks for itself. Also remember they beat you in a conflict before. I can't believe you are ever contemplating the question.

That was not a conflict ; it was a joke ; we were not expecting them to attack

We thought that they were friends but anyway it is another story

But we showed them some of our skills in 1967 when we killed 400 Chinese soldiers

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nathu_La_and_Cho_La_clashes

Also China ; IF it wanted could have intervened in 1965 ; 1971 and 1999 Kargil

This question needs to be answered

When they openly accuse us of occupying their South Tibet

Why not liberate it

Why they keep threatening Taiwan ; Philipines ; Vietnam and Japan
but refuse to open fire against India

 

[Brickwall]

What if China declares war on India or it happens to be the other way around (Highly unlikely) , is India strong enough to strike back?

Back in 1962 India lost war to China over the same issue , the non demarcated boundary has then since been a matter of conflict. The Chinese army has since been intervening regularly but this has now gone far beyond the limit.
Now that China signals for a possible war, let us analyze what does this have to mean and what do the number and stats say about comparison between the military strengths of the two countries.

Number of regular Armymen

China 16 lakh + Reserve forces 8 lakh + PAP 660000 = 3060000 total

India 1325000 + Reserve forces 18 lakh + territorial army = 37 lakh plus total.

China Tanks 7500, Artillery guns 20000, Helicopters 400, armoured vehicles 7500 +

India Tanks 5000, Artillery guns 19800, Helicopters 500, armoured vehicles number not known.

Surface to Air Missiles

China 210000 – India 190000

Besides these China has deployed around 1800 ballistic missiles some of which have nuclear warheads. (range between 280-350 kms upto 13000 kms).

On the other hand India has over 1700 missiles belonging to the Prithvi, Agni and Brahmos supersonic Cruise missile category (range between 150 kms upto 5500 kms). Besides these India has also developed a land based missile named Shaurya (range upto 2200 kms) and its submarine based version named Sagarika, both of which are supposed to be in service shortly or might have already been inducted.

The part where India really lags behind China in terms of numbers is the number of aircraft possessed by their airforces and the vessels operated by their respective navies.

China has over 2000 fighter and bomber aircrafts belonging to categories such as Jian, Jianhong, Chengdu, Hong 6, Qiang 5, FC-17, Sukhoi 27 and Sukhoi 30 MKK. (It has to be noted here that over 60% of these aircrafts are second and third generation aircrafts and a large number of those may not even be combat ready. The Sukhoi 30 MKK aircraft which is the premier fighter craft for China is technologically much inferior compared to the Sukhoi 30 MKI version that Indian Airforce operates. Sukhoi 30 MKK
can actively engage two targets simultaneously.

First of all, like it has already been repeated by the Armed Forces Personnels, any war is won 20% on the basis of equipments and 80% by morale. Thus, the statistics displayed doesn’t show all the picture. Otherwise, India would have lost to Pakistan also in 1965. But Pakistani Patton tanks and Sabrejets were no match to our low grade capabilities and superior men. We won because we had Havaldar Abdul Hameed, the destroyer of Patton tanks and Squadron Leader Travor Keeler, also known as the Sabre-Slayer.

http://dramaticindia.com/if-india-china-go-on-war-who-will-win/

Militarily China will be superior, But the countries in south asia and China will not be worth living.

Choice is simple either coexist or MAD

 

[Daghalodi]

But But But ...

Isnt Brahmos enough for china??

Enough US navy is scared of bharti brahmos

 

[ACE OF THE AIR]

They don't need to, their progress speaks for itself. Also remember they beat you in a conflict before. I can't believe you are ever contemplating the question.

The issue is where and how this war is to be fought. If it is only a border skirmish then it will be local and nothing much would be lost. The world will also keep a blind eye. India on the other hand will try to tell the world that a super power was attacked and it will not rest in peace. Opening doors for various defence deals.

If it escalates to an all out border war then then Indian armed forces will be fighting along many fronts severely undermining their capabilities. China can open the entire border that is along India.

Indian Air Force is not in a very good shape when it comes to China because it will find herself in a position where it might seem that Indian Navy Air arm will be given a task to counter Pakistan if the Western border is opened. Because India would fear that China would use this area to also attack in a way to expand the area of attack.

800 aircraft of IAF and her pilots would be flying non stop trying to defend Indian Airspace which will be a very difficult and tiring job.

If India tries to engage PLAN then it will need to do some thing proactive either by sending some ships towards the straits of malacca. Which will see a retaliation from PLAN.

All this will tend to take the issue to a stale mate increasing the chances of an all out nuclear strike.

A doomsday scenario.

 

[waz]

That was not a conflict ; it was a joke ; we were not expecting them to attack

We thought that they were friends but anyway it is another story

But we showed them some of our skills in 1967 when we killed 400 Chinese soldiers

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nathu_La_and_Cho_La_clashes

Also China ; IF it wanted could have intervened in 1965 ; 1971 and 1999 Kargil

This question needs to be answered

When they openly accuse us of occupying their South Tibet

Why not liberate it

Why they keep threatening Taiwan ; Philipines ; Vietnam and Japan
but refuse to open fire against India

"We were not expecting them to attack", that explains a great deal about your posts. Whenever there is even a remote chance of conflict or a form of hostile intent by the enemy, you should be prepared for anything.
The 1967 account only comes from Indian sources, please show me third party sources which confirm the casualties and conflict you speak about.
As for other times, China has been building its strength, you also had 65 and 71 under the shadow of the Soviets, so the Chinese would not intervene.
The South Tibet issue is a sideshow and is done to enrage the Indian establishment. They're not serious about it at the moment.
They haven't threatened the states you mentioned with direct military conflict, and the same is with India.
You just need to accept facts and understand that India is no match for China in any shape or form.

Militarily China will be superior, But the countries in south asia and China will not be worth living.

Choice is simple either coexist or MAD

You're going to nuke them with a landmass three times smaller and weaker weapons.

 

[navtrek]

India will, on the newspaper, like those fake surgika strika.

Its not fake you will come o know after a few years.

 

[ashok321]

What a hyperbole by right winger Modi followers here sans any reasoning:

You're going to nuke them with a landmass three times smaller and weaker weapons.

Yes, because the talk is cheap - the supply exceeds demand!

 

[rott]

China will win...India will be humiliated...

Bro, we're talking about a Supapowa vs China. I think the supapowa will win without doubts. China is still a 3rd world developing nation.

 

[Stephen Cohen]

"We were not expecting them to attack", that explains a great deal about your posts. Whenever there is even a remote chance of conflict or a form of hostile intent by the enemy, you should be prepared for anything.

Before 1962 ; India China relations were quite good

The whole thing flared up suddenly and un expectedly

The 1967 account only comes from Indian sources, please show me third party sources which confirm the casualties and conflict you speak about.

Why would China tell anybody of its defeats and losses

PLA secret files must be having those details

Anyway why go back to 1967

Talk of 1987 ; when INSPITE of all Bluff and Bluster
China BACKED out from a Conflict

https://www.thequint.com/opinion/2017/06/30/operation-falcon-sundarji-took-china-by-surprise

The South Tibet issue is a sideshow and is done to enrage the Indian establishment. They're not serious about it at the moment.

This stupid needling has Helped us to strengthen our capabilities
and also make Alliances with USA and Japan

So this net result speaks very poorly of Chinese Strategic thought and culture

They haven't threatened the states you mentioned with direct military conflict, and the same is with India.

You should ask these Asian countries what they think of China

You just need to accept facts and understand that India is no match for China in any shape or form.

That is just your opinion ; we are confident of our growing strength

Secondly we were vulnerable to China for a brief period from 2008 to 2011
Now we have " BEEFED " up our strength considerably