If India & China go on war who will win?

[aakash_2410]

Lool Who will declare the war though? Nothing of that sort will ever happen between China and India. They do too much trade together, they're not gonna ruin their economic growth for a few square miles of uninhabited land.

 

[abrar khan]

Again it is your opinion versus mine

What we believe is that Pakistan will definitely enter a war started by China

So a Two front war becomes inevitable

I dont understand why Pakistanis DISBELIEVE that India is serious about
a Two Front Scenario

we doubt indias capabilities of 2 front war, but she may take a foolish step ... a suicidal act, instead i believe there will be no war , possibly only border skirmish or back to their positions.

 

[shahbaz baig]

we are with China

 

[itaskol]

Improve infrastructure doesn't shorten the distance of mainland China and Indian frontiers- Tibet has three main roads connecting It with China, The one in east takes 10 days from Chengdu, and is most treacherous, this one can be hit by India, The one in west is also a long road It takes 5-6 days to reach Tibet from Kashghar and can be hit by India. The the 3rd is from Golmud, It takes 2-3 days from there there is also rail link along this route, this one is the safest though, you can be sure Golmud will be on Indian radar as soon as hostility breaks out, since all of Tibet's oil comes from there- This 3rd route has more than 100 bridges and tunnels-

When an army moves it needs food, oil and ammunition, every few 100 Km covered means thousands of million dollars and in this case we are talking about thousands of Km, long treacherous valleys in hostile climate, the Chinese troops will need oxygen supply chain also to reduce altitude related sickness- Indian army is not moving much, they are right there within 50-100km range- 300 thousand troops sit in the North East which has oil wells, refineries, produce food, with very good weather unlike Tibetan cold desert which stretches thousands of Km- You must be knowing the story of Salahuddin, and what he did with Europeans who marched out in deserts of Syria- Tibet is not the same but both raised Logistical question- improved infrastructure may reduce costs and time but It will still be costly-

Chinese withdrew in 1962 because the geography didn't suit them, and feared that a counter attack from India could expose them else where-

Who will win remains to be seen, the local population and Tibetans are with India, There are Tibetans enlisted as Special Forces battalions in India- We are better placed strategically and our logistics are short- The only problem with our forces is the inability to put heavy armor and mechanized equipment in some sectors like Tawang-

View attachment 408198

Note the patch on his shoulder- These are X-factor in any India-China future war, their numbers are unknown- These battalions were used very well in 1971 India-Pakistan war-



You can consult any artillery officer on this- Or even a normal soldier, these are basics, only a kid will do such things like ChineseDragon suggested in his lego games-

the main trouble is not oxygen but hymalaya weather. build road also cannot change hymalaya snow. if snow comes it will block us

but pakistan is the key， in 2 front war in future， pakistan may allow us attack from pakistan.
and pakistan may also support our navy.

we can not attack indian from tibet， but we can deploy missile interceptor and air force and missiles there ，our core area is far away from indian， but whole indian is near

 

[dray]

All the arguments I've seen from the Indian members here start with this same assumption, that China will simply decide to "invade" India out of the blue.

Because that's what happened in the last Sino-Indian War right? Nope, according to the Indian Army's own internal report (Henderson-Brooks report) it was in fact India who started the 1962 war.

But I never see any Indian members discussing an equally likely scenario, that India will start the war again by trying to extend their forces into Chinese territory. And that China might not actually push deep into India, but rather use mass produced conventional rocket artillery (with over 400+ km range) to destroy the Chicken's Neck corridor, as well as most of the military targets in North and Northeast India while preventing supplies from getting through the Chicken's Neck via constant bombardment. While simultaneously giving full military support to all the separatist groups in NE India to break away under the cover of another Sino-Indian War.

Dude, we have stopped the road construction, now it's your turn to show us what you got. Btw, the 'warning power' warnings are getting really boring.

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

Dude, we have stopped the road construction, now it's your turn to show us what you got. Btw, the 'warning power' warnings are getting really boring.

Well India says we destroyed their bunkers right?

Anyway you didn't answer my question. What if India starts the war (again... as usual) and China doesn't invade, but simply launches near-infinite amounts of mass produced conventional rocket artillery shells (with over 400+ km range) at every target in North and Northeast India, starting with cutting off the Chicken's Neck corridor?

 

[PaklovesTurkiye]

Yes, China would win in a duel between India and China.

But before going down,India would bomb the shit out of Military Industrial complex of China .China would be so weaken after war that it's regional enemy like Vietnam,Japan,Taiwan,Mangolia etc would capture the rest of what remains after Nuclear Holocaust .

Why are you bringing nuclear threat? Scared of China? How many nuke threat you bring? It only tells your fear..

 

[dray]

Well India says we destroyed their bunkers right?

Anyway you didn't answer my question. What if India starts the war (again... as usual) and China doesn't invade, but simply launches near-infinite amounts of mass produced conventional rocket artillery shells (with over 400+ km range) at every target in North and Northeast India, starting with cutting off the Chicken's Neck corridor?

Our goal was to stop the road construction, and we did it in reality. Yours is just fantasy, do it in reality, then talk. So far China couldn't do anything other than issuing boring warnings...No compromise from our side, no chinese road there...Do whatever you can do.

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

So far China couldn't do anything other than issuing boring warnings...

Nehru thought so as well.

India is making the same mistake of poking China while in a state of extreme military weakness. Do you know Chinese infrastructure reaches all the way to the LaC, while Indian infrastructure does not?

It will take several days of trekking over difficult mountainous terrain for the Indian troops to even arrive at the LaC, which will be several days too late. They will arrive days late in a state of exhaustion, with severely lacking equipment, how do you expect them to win in such a scenario?

 

[dray]

Nehru thought so as well.

India is making the same mistake of poking China while in a state of extreme military weakness. Do you know Chinese infrastructure reaches all the way to the LaC, while Indian infrastructure does not?

It will take several days of trekking over difficult mountainous terrain for the Indian troops to even arrive at the LaC, which will be several days too late. They will arrive days late in a state of exhaustion, with severely lacking equipment, how do you expect them to win in such a scenario?

Don't worry about us, start worrying about yours.

 

[PaklovesTurkiye]

Haan tumhe hi to pata hai Indian Doctrines saari. Over the last decade India has had a considerable shift towards the Chinese front. The process was started right after 1962 to reinforce remote areas of Sikkim, Ladakh, Arunachal. Only 5 years later, China got a bloody nose at Nathu La and Cho La. There is enough logistical, mental and physical preparedness to defend against any Chinese threat and then some.

Here you go...latest news

http://economictimes.indiatimes.com...r-india-china-border/articleshow/59445298.cms

 

[rott]

I am old enough to play with your mommas titties, son.

I have a cow and her name is "momma" please feel free to play.

 

[manlion]

Tamils are with China.

In 1962 Tamils sacrificed their demand for Dravida Nadu for India security, what did Tamils get in return ?

Hindi Imposition, exploitation of their resources, suppression of their rights , oppression of their identity and Tamil genocide

 

[salimpheku]

Tamils are with China.

I thought it was complete South which is with China!

Right now Madras regiment is playing ping pong with Chinese on the border, may be you should tell them to join China. Do it face to face

 

[tw00tw00]

India will declare moral victory for sure and give itself a participation trophy.