If India & China go on war who will win?

[gambit]

Not sure about China having fought any modern wars?

Have you ? And please do not bring up Korea. Modern means at most in our fathers' lifetime, not our grandfathers'. Weapons changed, so have tactics and doctrines.

 

[Canuck786]

..air supremacy-India..

Really, There Airforce hasn't been able to compete with Pakistan and you're saying its better than china.

The only serious question that no one has posed to India and its an absolute a must in this situation should be:

ANY LAST WISH BEFORE ANNIHILATION?

 

[mangekyo]

Have you ? And please do not bring up Korea. Modern means at most in our fathers' lifetime, not our grandfathers'. Weapons changed, so have tactics and doctrines.

That comment was meant for me. Hes saying Im stupid for not knowing about Chinese war history

 

[terranMarine]

Is there a problem? Do I have to know about Chinese history?

When you talk about modern warfare i assume you are talking about 90s to current time. Does that require you to know 5000 years old Chinese history? Everyone knows China has not fought a war during that time and you are asking something that's obvious. Seems pointless to me

 

[C130]

do you agree with the assessment regarding US?

what are you talking about?

 

[terranMarine]

Have you ? And please do not bring up Korea. Modern means at most in our fathers' lifetime, not our grandfathers'. Weapons changed, so have tactics and doctrines.

Well old man that's the point only USA has modern warfare experiences , seems like some people are still asleep.

How about the Indian assessment of US being bogged down in all wars against even the smallest countries?

what are you talking about?

see post #197

That comment was meant for me. Hes saying Im stupid for not knowing about Chinese war history

I never said that

 

[mangekyo]

Well old man that's the point only USA has modern warfare experiences , seems like some people are still asleep.

There you see man. We are human, we are not meant to know everything.. you forget about Israel - Hezbollah war of 2008. That is modern warfare. And if I remember correctly, Israel had its arse whooped even though they have "one of the best" military in the world.

 

[jetray]

limited war
ground fight-tie or edge to china
air supremacy-India
naval battle-edge china

how does china have naval advantage in Indian ocean? they are far from home base and their vessels are already tracked by most of the allied countries. If they cross the malacca straits then its advantage India. Only issue that Indian peninsula will get exposed which might be an advantage or disadvantage.

 

[gambit]

That comment was meant for me. Hes saying Im stupid for not knowing about Chinese war history

Does not matter. This is a publicly accessible forum. Anyone's comment is available for anyone to respond.

The problem is that he -- and the Chinese membership in general -- do not know what they are talking about. The more technologies changes and the faster those changes, the greater the need to emphasize the lack of war experience inside the time of those changes. Since the end of the Korean War, the US have been in the lead more than any country in creating new weapons systems. Not only that, the US have the most experience in using new technologies in war. If you do not have an aircraft carrier, it is extremely difficult to formulate a defensive posture against an opponent who have an aircraft carrier, and the US can bring to any theater more than just one. Nationalistic passion can only go so far.

 

[Azadkashmir]

SUNNY DEOL

 

[terranMarine]

There you see man. We are human, we are not meant to know everything.. you forget about Israel - Hezbollah war of 2008. That is modern warfare. And if I remember correctly, Israel had its arse whooped even though they have "one of the best" military in the world.

If you have not read anything about China fighting any war between the 90s to today then you know China has not fought any modern warfare. I'm surprised you know India has no modern warfare experiences.

 

[gambit]

Well old man that's the point only USA has modern warfare experiences , seems like some people are still asleep.

How about the Indian assessment of US being bogged down in all wars against even the smallest countries?

Young pup, getting 'bogged down' is a political condition, not a military one. Ask the Iraqi Army on how ruthless the US military can be.

 

[terranMarine]

Does not matter. This is a publicly accessible forum. Anyone's comment is available for anyone to respond.

The problem is that he -- and the Chinese membership in general -- do not know what they are talking about. The more technologies changes and the faster those changes, the greater the need to emphasize the lack of war experience inside the time of those changes. Since the end of the Korean War, the US have been in the lead more than any country in creating new weapons systems. Not only that, the US have the most experience in using new technologies in war. If you do not have an aircraft carrier, it is extremely difficult to formulate a defensive posture against an opponent who have an aircraft carrier, and the US can bring to any theater more than just one. Nationalistic passion can only go so far.

Well Old man i never said China had modern warfare experiences, our Iranian friend wasn't sure though which i find it surprising considering China is not a warmonger like US. And yes the US is the only super power

 

[CaptainJackSparrow]

FYI, you don't go 'on' war; you go 'to' war.

Continue...

 

[mangekyo]

Young pup, getting 'bogged down' is a political condition, not a military one. Ask the Iraqi Army on how ruthless the US military can be.

You cannot compare the military US had during Bush administration to the current one. Why not you ask me? Well, because of fighting spirit. First of, it was about revenge for 9/11. Secondly US soldiers truly believed that they were fighting terror and bringing democracy and freedom to poor innocent civilians. They fought not only for their country. But for humanity, at least that was what they thought. Now they know better. The fighting spirit is completely gone and thus IMO so is your military.