If India & China go on war who will win?

[rott]

I am talking of Real war ;not the PDF wars

We are ready for a Two front war

Just ready?

 

[ohmrlobalobayeh]

I dont think China will target New Delhi, bro. We just need to subdue them in the border.

Any favorable n conclusive peace treaty to the entire Sino-India boundary question would have to be facilitated with an occupation of New Delhi by the PLA.

War goal should not be annexation of any territory that didnt belong to her, but to liberate South Tibet, Demchok and the parts in dispute with Bhutan

It's the same thing during the US-Mexican war over where the Southern states of the US are today. US army penetrated deep into Mexico n occupied Mexico City to add on a trump card to the negotiating table.

China has an easier time cos New Delhi is only 995km from the LAC

http://www.dnaindia.com/india/repor...risky-could-lead-to-war-bhutan-public-2490189

China's actions on border risky, could lead to war: Bhutan public

India is fully supported by Bhutan," Bhutanese local Chundu Singye told ANI.

Criticising China for constructing a road inside Bhutanese territory, residents here have stated that this action by Beijing could lead to war and cautioned the latter not to transgress Bhutan's territorial integrity and sovereignty.

"What China is doing on the border lines is very risky and it encourages war. India is just trying to warn them that China should respect Bhutan?s sovereignty. India is fully supported by Bhutan," Bhutanese local Chundu Singye told ANI.

Singye further stated, "Bhutan is a small country, but no one can invade our territory because the topography and geography is such, that invasion is nearly next to impossible."

Another Thimphu resident Tsheltrim Dorji said, ?I think China, India and Bhutan should come together and find a solution to the issue.?

?Indo-Bhutan share a really good relationship. Bhutan is small country, not proper way to acquire forcefully,? Choki Wangmo, another Bhutanese local said.

Echoing similar sentiments, one more Bhutanese local Namgay Dorji said, ?India and Bhutan are having good relationship since 1961. India is supporting our government in every aspect.?

Locals in Bhutan are severely critical about China proposing to construct the road inside Bhutanese territory, which they say is a direct violation of the agreements and affect the process of demarcating the boundary between the two countries.

Bhutan had last month issued a demarche to the Chinese envoy in India, asking Beijing to restore the status quo in the Doklam area where Chinese soldiers tried to unilaterally build a road towards their army camp in the Zomplri area.

China who refer to Doklam as Donglang was part of Chinese territory ?since ancient times and it doesn?t belong to Bhutan?.

Here is something trvial for those who didnt know:

Bhutan use to be part of Tibet.

Bhutan has a total population of less than ONE million ppl(600,000+).

Bhutan also, has never had a clear, demarcated border with China n both sides do NOT have any diplomatic relations with each other.

Bhutan is more like an Indian state than an independant country.

 

[manlion]

India-China War Again? More Tension At Sikkim Border, Beijing Warns Indian Army To Withdraw From Doka La

The warning comes from the Chinese government mouthpiece Xinhua News Agency, which asserts that there could be serious implications if India interferes with China’s activities at the border. The official news agency asked New Delhi to respect the Sikkim section of the Indo-China border, as “demarcated by the 1890 Sino-British treaty.”

China earlier claimed that it was India that had ignored international law and interfered with Beijing’s construction activities in the Chinese territory. Xinhua News Agency claimed that there was enough evidence to prove that the Indian army had violated the written agreement between the two countries. India apparently acknowledged, even in writing, that it did not have any objection to the direction of the Sikkim section

China has strong words for the Indian army. It’ll be interesting to see how New Delhi responds

http://www.inquisitr.com/4341816/in...g-warns-indian-army-to-withdraw-from-doka-la/

 

[T-Rex]

India-China War Again? More Tension At Sikkim Border, Beijing Warns Indian Army To Withdraw From Doka La





China has strong words for the Indian army. It’ll be interesting to see how New Delhi responds

http://www.inquisitr.com/4341816/in...g-warns-indian-army-to-withdraw-from-doka-la/

These indians will most probably mock at this warning as another of those Chinese warnings.

 

[salimpheku]

China has an overwhelming superiority on all fronts, and has a defence industry that produces everything they need. There is no contest.

If that was the case US should have won all wars of the last 50 years.

To topic, It depends on who the attacker is and what the "objectives" are.

India is in no position to attack China and win the war.

China conversely will loose any war with India where it is the attacker.
Now, if the objective of China is to attack & not hold any ground, then there are a lot of hypotheticals that will determine whether they will be able to meet their objectives.

If at all China want's to attack India and capture portion of our land, they will be walking into nasty surprise.

a 2 front war will spell India's ultimate demise and disintegration.

Pakistan engage with India to take over S Kashmir while China can retake S Tibet.

Divided into several countries, India will not be in a position to confront China and peace will prevail in S Asia

While that is happening, India will be sitting quietly twiddling our thumbs.
Oh, the fantastic fantasies of India haters. Do you guys get off thinking about breaking india?

The other option is to send in the IAF but that's risky with Chinese air defence and of course the PLAF will also be there.

What about all the Chinese oil passing through waters near to India?
Wonder how India will play this out when China starts attacking us?

 

[itaskol]

we are outnumbered near china indian board. for a small conflict ，hard to win.

first priority is infractractur， we need finish lot of roads and airfield。so the main troops from everywhere in china can get there and easy to supplier.
fact is infracture in tibet area is too hard even for us， need a long time.

or deploy troops in pakistan and attack from pakistan.better way

 

[salimpheku]

In conventional war, China will simply walk over India

Don't share this with any serious defence analyst.

How will China attack India in a conventional war?
Over Himalayas? Get all their Navy into Arabian Sea or Bay of Bengal? Or may be get their Air force parked on Mt Everest to attack India

China will get it's bottom licked if it's tries to attack India in a conventional way.

Forget winning, China will loose in less than a week.

One simple & single reason all the "experts" here are forgetting. OIL. All Chinese Oil flows through Indian ocean. Not one drop of our oil flows through a drop of water controlled by China.
Any one want's to guess how many days it would take for CHina to come begging to India for truce?

Does anyone have any idea why China is so desperate for Naval bases near India?

was that why your Chinese soldiers were getting manhandled like toddlers 2 days ago

May be that is Chinese govt sending SOS through pdf, to the real "men" to help them out with India.

If you are from Chennai, then I am with you brother and I really do feel your pain.

My Best Regards

You are from Pakistan and you are feeling sorry for some one else!

 

[Canuck786]

You are from Pakistan and you are feeling sorry for some one else!

YES!

 

[ghauri05]

how to turn .5 to 5? can you explain

by supporting nexals and other separatist movements in india...i wonder why china has not done it till now?? this is a cheap way to keep india in check...n the resources china can provide..it can easily become 0.5 to 5.0

 

[manlion]

Had Tamil Eelam materialized , it would have been a 3 front attack and the Tigers would have devoured the cows

The irony has stretched to tragic dimensions. Despite its vastly superior numbers (India Today sources put it at as much as 30,000 apart from the paramilitary contingent), unlimited fire-power and acknowledged professionalism, the IPKF has suffered unexpectedly heavy losses in the fortnight of fierce fighting. Officially, at the end of the 16-day siege of Jaffna, the IPKF admits to 214 dead, including 15 officers, two of them colonels.

Another 36 soldiers are missing, captured and presumably killed by the Liberation Tigers, while over 700 IPKF personnel have been wounded in the action. Unofficially, however, army sources admit that the death toll in the first Indian Army operation that has taken place on foreign soil since 1975, could be closer to 400.

 

[Han Patriot]

Neither do you champ...You probably are mentioning Sunny Leone


Why did you not include sri lanka in this gang, They must be feeling left out!
On the other hand please keep a check on the BS that you post...

Yup, I mentioned that a few post back, ITO corrected me. Sunny Leone is the one I was watching in the ****.

 

[salimpheku]

So many posts, yet, no one explained to me the one elephant in the room.

most of China's imports & exports, including it's oil, pass near by Andaman & Nicobar Islands. Just what do you think India would do to all these ships passing through it's waters in case of war?

India has China by it's b@lls. Hence the desperation from China to have it's bases with it's string of pearls, which India has just destroyed.

CHina won't last a week in war with India and they know it. That's the reason why they have never escalated the border issue.

 

[terranMarine]

So many posts, yet, no one explained to me the one elephant in the room.

most of China's imports & exports, including it's oil, pass near by Andaman & Nicobar Islands. Just what do you think India would do to all these ships passing through it's waters in case of war?

India has China by it's b@lls. Hence the desperation from China to have it's bases with it's string of pearls, which India has just destroyed.

CHina won't last a week in war with India and they know it. That's the reason why they have never escalated the border issue.

Well then if India has China by the balls why hasn't India launched another Forward Policy after 1962?

 

[salimpheku]

Well then if India has China by the balls why hasn't India launched another Forward Policy after 1962?

Because we can't win.

We are not stupid. Neither is China, hence the reason why they have not attacked either.

 

[Kiss_of_the_Dragon]

So many posts, yet, no one explained to me the one elephant in the room.

most of China's imports & exports, including it's oil, pass near by Andaman & Nicobar Islands. Just what do you think India would do to all these ships passing through it's waters in case of war?

India has China by it's b@lls. Hence the desperation from China to have it's bases with it's string of pearls, which India has just destroyed.

CHina won't last a week in war with India and they know it. That's the reason why they have never escalated the border issue.

How India has China by the ball when India will be Navy-less, we can sink all Indian warships, cargo and merchant ship via Tibet with DF-21D, and I'm not sure if Indian Navy can handle Chinese navy even in Indian Ocean...make a miscalculation will bring India misfortune.