If a dog is stoned, don't blame the Centre, says Union Minister VK Singh on killing of two Dalit chi

[Mamsalaphala]

Mob action or Family feud.....
Which country you belong too ? in India (IPC) murder is a murder only difference is in rarest of the rare cases where capital punishment is granted.

Rubbish. The circumstances of the case matter as much as the crime itself.

An accidental murder by a jealous husband who is temporarily insane is VERY different from the planned murder by a Terrorist.

A instigated Mob action which resulted in death is VERY different from a deliberate planned murder by a family.


Not only do they NOT attract the same punishment, but also the charges are different.

 

[jamahir]

v.k. singh doesn't know how to operate in the real world, he should have stuck to making nationalist threats against china and pakistan, and chanting everyday that "india, usa and israel are natural allies".

so what does he think a central government is for?? for becoming a tout for western weapons manufacturers or for declaring that india 5000 years ago had inter-planetary vehicles??

also, his party colleague, maneka gandhi, would be thinking "to hell with dalits, how can someone stone a dog !!"

v.k. singh should be jailed for the anti-human statement he made.

bjp government must go, it is a embarrassment for india and the world.

 

[nair]

Welcome Back!!!!

If he would have EQUATED with Cow there is a problem..........

If he would have EQUATED with Pig there is a BIGGER problem............

Actually he chosed the best animal so that it could never be seen as any DISCRIMINATION as Dogs are men's best friend & all men are dog...............

USME bhi tum iss bhale insaan ko mat choro...............Hai ZALIM duniya!!!

 

[IndoCarib]

v.k. singh doesn't know how to operate in the real world, he should have stuck to making nationalist threats against china and pakistan, and chanting everyday that "india, usa and israel are natural allies".

so what does he think a central government is for?? for becoming a tout for western weapons manufacturers or for declaring that india 5000 years ago had inter-planetary vehicles??

also, his party colleague, maneka gandhi, would be thinking "to hell with dalits, how can someone stone a dog !!"

v.k. singh should be jailed for the anti-human statement he made.

bjp government must go, it is a embarrassment for india and the world.

How many times before you have blamed the central govt for Dalit killings ? Now dont tell me Dalits were never killed before

 

[jamahir]

How many times before you have blamed the central govt for Dalit killings ? Now dont tell me Dalits were never killed before

you are correct that dalits have been killed before, but they were killed by those who hold the same thinking as bjp and its larger movement.

 

[Hindustani78]

Rubbish. The circumstances of the case matter as much as the crime itself.

An accidental murder by a jealous husband who is temporarily insane is VERY different from the planned murder by a Terrorist.

A instigated Mob action which resulted in death is VERY different from a deliberate planned murder by a family.


Not only do they NOT attract the same punishment, but also the charges are different.

Jealous husband case comes in domestic crime where as the terrorist one comes under national security.

How many times before you have blamed the central govt for Dalit killings ? Now dont tell me Dalits were never killed before

There are some geniune cases in which people are targetted for being oppressed but dont know how to term when its a family feud?

 

[jamahir]

If he would have EQUATED with Cow there is a problem..........

If he would have EQUATED with Pig there is a BIGGER problem............

Actually he chosed the best animal so that it could never be seen as any DISCRIMINATION as Dogs are men's best friend & all men are dog...............

USME bhi tum iss bhale insaan ko mat choro...............Hai ZALIM duniya!!!

sure, man's "best friend"...

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/07/world/asia/india-stray-dogs-are-a-menace.html?_r=0

(( Dog attacks a baby in india 2015 - YouTube ))

Female foetuses in Beed fed to dogs to hide evidence | Daily Mail Online

 

[IndoCarib]

you are correct that dalits have been killed before, but they were killed by those who hold the same thinking as bjp and its larger movement.

How do you know that ? Dalits are always attacked ny upper caste Hindus. Why make BJP connection now? Coz it is convenient and fits the secualr media narrative ?

 

[Mamsalaphala]

How do you know that ? Dalits are always attacked ny upper caste Hindus. Why make BJP connection now? Coz it is convenient and fits the secualr media narrative ?

Actually BJP brings the Dalits and the upper caste together. If anything, the attacks will reduce due to BJP.

Its the creamy layer "lower caste" like the Yadav and Bhumiyar, Patels and Jaats who are against BJP.

 

[JOEY TRIBIANI]

incredible india

 

[jamahir]

How do you know that ? Dalits are always attacked ny upper caste Hindus. Why make BJP connection now? Coz it is convenient and fits the secualr media narrative ?

1. is bjp a anti-sectarian anti-reactionary socialist movement?? if not, what is its ideology and parent body??

2. what is "secular media"?? are progressive people not part of this special type of media not talking against sectarianism ( including oppression of dalits )??

3. why should you have enmity with secular media?? don't you want india as a whole to enter civilized humanity??

incredible india

is pakistan any better...

Landlord sets dogs on minor in Muzaffargarh | PAKISTAN - geo.tv

Feudal lords sets dogs loose on worker | PAKISTAN - geo.tv

 

[Hindustani78]

How do you know that ? Dalits are always attacked ny upper caste Hindus. Why make BJP connection now? Coz it is convenient and fits the secualr media narrative ?

There have been cases which are family feuds which are being turned into caste issues and cases are being filed under SC protection acts which in reality are not correct.

Actually BJP brings the Dalits and the upper caste together. If anything, the attacks will reduce due to BJP.

Its the creamy layer "lower caste" like the Yadav and Bhumiyar, Patels and Jaats who are against BJP.

Its like regional parties Vs National party.

incredible india

Its internal politics.

While mr Singh is indeed a motor mouth, Indian media is just pure scum.

Media is doing what Media always do .

Infact Indian Media is quite open but Media should be a bit cautious when its about National security.

Commissioner of Police, Subhash Yadav said,"Seven persons out of total eleven accused named by the family have been arrested so far. We are hopeful to nab other culprits soon."

The three accused were held last night. He said the situation in the village was peaceful now.

Haryana's Director General of Police Y P Singal has said that as per investigations so far, an old enmity appeared to be the trigger behind the gruesome incident.

Eight police officials including Inspector Anil Kumar, Officer-In-charge of Sadar Ballagbarh Police Station have been suspended.

 

[Spring Onion]

If he would have EQUATED with Cow there is a problem..........

If he would have EQUATED with Pig there is a BIGGER problem............

Actually he chosed the best animal so that it could never be seen as any DISCRIMINATION as Dogs are men's best friend & all men are dog...............

USME bhi tum iss bhale insaan ko mat choro...............Hai ZALIM duniya!!!

why helpless minorities be equated with animals by Indian ruling and powerful class, always?

 

[I M Sikander]

why helpless minorities be equated with animals by Indian ruling and powerful class, always?

What else u expect from darinda modi and his government.

 

[OTTOMAN]

VK Singh also collected some classified baggage from Yemen.