How Karachi has been discriminated

[Zarvan]

I have a simple suggestion to you. Why don't you just do what you are good at?

You have a a very narrow understanding of your own country politically and culturally. You have borderline extremist issues and it is frightening your knowledge about guns and ammo.

Why don't you take a soul searching holiday? It may help you with your itch.

I have very good understanding of my country and both politically and culturally far better than many here thanks to ALLAH. I take holidays when I need them and my views are based on my research of Quran and Sunnah and and every other topic. Now Karachi was destroyed when people decided to stand with MQM and if you want to tell the me the story that people are afraid of getting killed well than do a election now and still some sort of MQM will win majority of seats. So basically people of Karachi want to stand with goons than there choice. No other party would come from Punjab or KPK to do development here when there guys are not elected from here. You want to make excuses of ethnicity and other than you do but these only stop development. PML N is one big thug but far better than MQM terrorists.

 

[El Sidd]

You can keep complaining about PPP all you want. Most sindhis no longer support them. In the past decade theres been a wave of urbanization among Sindhis which has also lead to decline of Punjab inspired feudal culture.
In the next decade Sindh will decide its fate by itself. We are very much tired of the Karachi/Punjab centric status quo and the Sindhis have are very aware on the ground realities of Pakistan. Soon a new wave of nationalism will spring up in Sindh.

And @Hamzay

There is no place for nationalism based on race or ethnicity in Pakistan.

Be it the migrated folks or the dwellers of this country. Both are equal citizens and if poor governance has frustrated you than you can start the change yourself by losing this victimisation tactics.

@waz keep a close eye on this potentially racist thread. I thought we have risen above this primitive modus operandi

 

[S.Y.A]

Sindhis during the partition we're looking forward to this rosy cooperation utopia trash that you mentioned, but the deception that they were rewarded with instead is a crime against humanity.

What deception? please explain? What exactly was stopping Sindhis from setting up schools, colleges in their cities? DJ and Adamjee college in Khi were private endeavors. What stopped Sindhis from setting up industry in other cities as well as Khi? Sindhi socialists are quite well read and intelligent people, and I do believe that they will be better than the waderas running the PPP. But I do hope that you let go of this baseless hatred and propaganda.

 

[gangsta_rap]

and if poor governance has frustrated you than you can start the change yourself by losing this victimisation tactics.

If poor governance has resulted in failure repeatedly then one needs to go back the drawing board. Slowly yet steadily things will lead to that event soon enough

 

[El Sidd]

I have very good understanding of my country and both politically and culturally far better than many here thanks to ALLAH. I take holidays when I need them and my views are based on my research of Quran and Sunnah and and every other topic. Now Karachi was destroyed when people decided to stand with MQM and if you want to tell the me the story that people are afraid of getting killed well than do a election now and still some sort of MQM will win majority of seats. So basically people of Karachi want to stand with goons than there choice. No other party would come from Punjab or KPK to do development here when there guys are not elected from here. You want to make excuses of ethnicity and other than you do but these only stop development. PML N is one big thug but far better than MQM terrorists.

I am not here to discuss politics. Your twisted views on Islam coupled with potentially racist behaviour are a recipe for disaster in the making.

You should ideally be under surveillance and i think you are.

I just wanted to be the first to let you know that and think twice before you write here

If poor governance has resulted in failure repeatedly then one needs to go back the drawing board. Slowly yet steadily things will lead to that event soon enough

Yes they will and they are.

Whats not helping is the discord sowing behaviour and the fact that it is politically motivated.

Rise above petty politics and own your country's problems rather than going Gaga over it

 

[gangsta_rap]

What deception? please explain? What exactly was stopping Sindhis from setting up schools, colleges in their cities? DJ and Adamjee college in Khi were private endeavors. What stopped Sindhis from setting up industry in other cities as well as Khi? Sindhi socialists are quite well read and intelligent people, and I do believe that they will be better than the waderas running the PPP. But I do hope that you let go of this baseless hatred and propaganda.

The partition did. Pakistan's existence stopped it all. This is very much apparent and you can see this in Balochistan as well.
The division of power in the aftermath of the partition was terribly executed and has shown how intense of a failure the entire scheme turned into, with power being invested into specific ethnicities at the expense of others.

Some Pakistanis recognize the faults that had been done in the past and are still being done. You cannot deny that the Baloch and Sindhi people were treated in a very unfair manner, and when they protested they were met with bullets either from the army or from upstart political militants.
The Baloch struggle is given a greater limelight because the Baloch people have always believed in armed struggle in the face of a threat. Sindhis unfortunately never mobilized in a similar manner but who knows when the powder keg will light up.

 

[Zarvan]

I am not here to discuss politics. Your twisted views on Islam coupled with potentially racist behaviour are a recipe for disaster in the making.

You should ideally be under surveillance and i think you are.

I just wanted to be the first to let you know that and think twice before you write here



Yes they will and they are.

Whats not helping is the discord sowing behaviour and the fact that it is politically motivated.

Rise above petty politics and own your country's problems rather than going Gaga over it

I am no racist I love entire Pakistan and Muslims. Also I have no twisted view on Islam people here want to here which suits there nafs not what ALLAH and his RASOOL SAW have told I just tell what ALLAH and his RASOOL SAW told. Racism you sound funny to me not I am not funny. MQM terrorist activities are known to every one and if now people of Karachi want to vote for a terrorist party even after when Armed Forces have weakened than they should not expect development because thugs only loot not do development and that is what MQM and PPP have been doing. Until people stop voting for these parties it's hard to see any development happening in Karachi or Sindh.

 

[Areesh]

LOL now i understand this Hamzay guys 'plight'
typical ex-altafist mqm thug who wants everything torn down once it hits the fan for them. LOL this behaviour has existed in altafists for a long time...how did i not even see this coming?

An altafist is far better than f*ckers like you who support terrorists and separatists like Jiye Sindh monkeys.

 

[Ahmet Pasha]

The question I would like to ask is why do you call themselves mohajirs when we are all mohajirs in pakistan we all left our homes in india to come here. My dads family left amritsar to come here and my moms family left Kashmir to come here.

Why do u call urselfes urdu speak. When we all speak urdu our national language is urdu.

Why do u follow people who wave colorful flags but hate and preach hate for our beloved green and white flag?

An example of this useless craziness is I went to work in an office of a so called urdu speak Karachiite and he insulted me in worst possible way. He called me a stupid punjabi and said we urdu speak and punjabis dont get along. I was astoniched because my intention was to be nice to him because he was a muslim brother and also a pakistani brother. I was absolutely horrified.

So the most important question is why soooo much HATE?? When we are one people, one blood under one flag? Why do u want to isolate urselves by becoming victims of powers who seek to break u up?

 

[salarsikander]

He did it in a manner which was appropriate for political leaders.

If you tacit support it. Then fk you ! Because you're anti national !
Simple , you're justifying his breaking of Pakistan. For such people and their ethicnity i piss on it.

Shame on uiu. You have no going right to say anything. So the fact that pigs like him demand the breaking of Pakistan is acceptable? Regardless of peace or violent. Try doing that and in will personally make sure you or anyone with motive is shown his grave.
Bloody traitors. No ethinicity is above Pakistan. I piss on idea of ethincity
E

 

[Ahmet Pasha]

As far as horrible conditions are concerned my brothers whole country is burning. Hell the whole muslim nation is suffering and up in flames.

Please Unite instead of dividing, our enemies love the most when we are divided

 

[El Sidd]

The partition did. Pakistan's existence stopped it all. This is very much apparent and you can see this in Balochistan as well.
The division of power in the aftermath of the partition was terribly executed and has shown how intense of a failure the entire scheme turned into, with power being invested into specific ethnicities at the expense of others.

Some Pakistanis recognize the faults that had been done in the past and are still being done. You cannot deny that the Baloch and Sindhi people were treated in a very unfair manner, and when they protested they were met with bullets either from the army or from upstart political militants.
The Baloch struggle is given a greater limelight because the Baloch people have always believed in armed struggle in the face of a threat. Sindhis unfortunately never mobilized in a similar manner but who knows when the powder keg will light up.

You just crossed the red line with your anti Pakistan post. I regret to inform you but Pakistan is here to stay and you should ideally make peace with it if that is still possible.

 

[salarsikander]

I just wanted to be the first to let you know that and think twice before you write here

Its is particularly too hard for him

An altafist is far better than f*ckers like you who support terrorists and separatists like Jiye Sindh monkeys.

Pig is actually justifying GM sheds action

 

[The Accountant]

It is absolutely insulting when 'mohajirs' act as if Sindhis should be grateful of them. Its the other way around, we did what we an to accommodate your forefathers during the partition out of good faith.I try not to judge 'Mohajirs' in this way but their altafist tendancies always pop up one way or another.

The reason why Larkana/Khairpur/e.t.c are in the state in which they are is very obvious. The Pakistan of today was meant to serve very specific ethnic and tribal groups/families. The political and military establishment makes sure that the ones who suffer remain in that state, and that's why rural Baloch and rural Sindhis are left in in this vicious system.

Disgusting how an urdu-speaker shows up and prides himself in occupying a land that belonged to its 5000 year old inhabitants. I can trace my lineage to Noor Muhammad Kalhoro, the Sindhi king who made the first modern Sindhi state. Very disturbing how the sacrifices of the Sindhi forefathers were nullified in 1947.

@S.Y.A has provided you a perfect answere ...

There was no land grabbing as Karachi and hyderbad were not more than a small unknown cities before arrival of urdu speakings ...

Secondly we did not grab any of the land from you .. we setelled on barren deserts and barren land and conveted it to most advance city of Pakistan ...

I am sure sindhi speaking have their co tribution too but kindly be realistic ... current state of affairs of sindhi people is rather than working on developing other cities they are condemning the people who are developing themselves ... again i would like to request you that rather than demanding respect from muhaijir statt working on education of development of your people ...

Regarding giving lands can you show me ks a single piece of your personal land or any other sindhi's personal was given to mohajir ...

We were allocated barren lands and agree it or not alot of educated and wealthy mohajir came to sindh which changed the land scape in its entirety ...

Now come to the real issue ... real issue is not mohajir not sindhi its the shity old system and those land lords and political leaders ... rather than selecting based on ethinicity we should select our leaders based on merits ... its time to kick out both mqm and ppp ...

Lets try PTI for a change and if you dont believe in PTI then try someone else but not PPP ... they are the sole reason of differnces between mahajir and sindhi ... we can work togather for combine development but PPP and MQM will not let us ...

 

[El Sidd]

I am no racist I love entire Pakistan and Muslims. Also I have no twisted view on Islam people here want to here which suits there nafs not what ALLAH and his RASOOL SAW have told I just tell what ALLAH and his RASOOL SAW told. Racism you sound funny to me not I am not funny. MQM terrorist activities are known to every one and if now people of Karachi want to vote for a terrorist party even after when Armed Forces have weakened than they should not expect development because thugs only loot not do development and that is what MQM and PPP have been doing. Until people stop voting for these parties it's hard to see any development happening in Karachi or Sindh.

Your understanding of how elections are held in Pakistan is a testament to your naive narrow minded understanding on how the world works.

My suggestion still remains the same as posted above. Pakistan has recently opened a rehabilitation center and you can check yourself in that anonymously. You will not regret it.

Thanks.