doublemaster
FULL MEMBER
- Joined
- Jul 31, 2012
- Messages
- 1,077
- Reaction score
- 1
- Country
- Location
NEW DELHI: Calling the hanging of Parliament attack convict Afzal Guru a setback to the process of reconciliation and normalcy in Kashmir, former chief of Research & Analysis Wing (RAW) and an expert on the valley AS Dulat has said that had AB Vajpayee been the Prime Minister he would have never let Guru hang.
"Even though BJP had been demanding Guru's hanging, Atal Bihari Vajpayee would have not done it had he been heading the government," Dulat told TOI. Dulat headed RAW in 1999-2000 and was subsequently appointed as advisor to the PM (Vajpayee) on Kashmir. He was instrumental in shaping BJP's Kashmir strategy and an important player in Track II diplomacy.
Neither Congress nor BJP, which has both demanded and gloated over Guru's hanging, are likely to find the comment palatable. However, Dulat is firm in his opinion that the hanging has come at a wrong time when the valley was moving towards normalcy. "It has the potential to take the valley several years back. I was not expecting this to happen," he said.
Sentiments over Guru have been strong in the valley and as has been evident from the protests following the hanging three civilians are reported dead in the clashes between protestors and security forces despite the latter having been told to exercise utmost restraint things always have the potential to spiral out of control in Kashmir.
Even as the establishment has been banking on the anticipation of a good tourist season, strict but cautious policing and a youth geared more towards reaping benefits of a rising economy than causing long-drawn stir, observers say Kashmir can be unpredictable.
"Kashmiris are smart people. They can reap economic benefits and still vent their anger. They are also politically very conscious. Already the security clampdown is being called Gaza-isation of the valley. Also, while the youth is economically inclined, it is also very impatient," said an expert.
Sources also said as much of a political decision it may have been for the Congress, the party may not benefit from it in the upcoming elections. The leapfrogging to hang Guru over Beant Singh and Rajiv Gandhi killers will only hurt its secular image. In fact, it's the BJP that will be able to consolidate its support base as it has been demanding the hanging for several years, sources said.
However, according to Dulat, the biggest loser in this entire episode is J&K CM Omar Abdullah. "He has completely lost his credibility in the valley," says Dulat. Not surprisingly, Abdullah has been constantly distancing himself from the decision and has castigated Centre over it.
Dulat says the government must now devise a strategy to find a way out of the situation. "And the solution should attempt to go beyond law and order mechanisms. Militancy is not the thing to fear in the valley, but public anger is," he added.
Had Vajpayee been PM, Afzal's execution wouldn’t have happened: Ex-RAW chief - The Times of India
Look what they are saying now....When afzal was not hanged, they tried to portray it as `minority appeasement`. These BJP RSS workers intruded every where and flooded facebook and emails with tons of post saying afzal is not being hanged just because of this. Congress was clearly loosing vote because this. Despite this they considered national interest, sake of kashmir they avoided this. But now, look what they are doing..they fell on BJP trap.
Look like i say always, BJP is the least patriotic party of our country.
"Even though BJP had been demanding Guru's hanging, Atal Bihari Vajpayee would have not done it had he been heading the government," Dulat told TOI. Dulat headed RAW in 1999-2000 and was subsequently appointed as advisor to the PM (Vajpayee) on Kashmir. He was instrumental in shaping BJP's Kashmir strategy and an important player in Track II diplomacy.
Neither Congress nor BJP, which has both demanded and gloated over Guru's hanging, are likely to find the comment palatable. However, Dulat is firm in his opinion that the hanging has come at a wrong time when the valley was moving towards normalcy. "It has the potential to take the valley several years back. I was not expecting this to happen," he said.
Sentiments over Guru have been strong in the valley and as has been evident from the protests following the hanging three civilians are reported dead in the clashes between protestors and security forces despite the latter having been told to exercise utmost restraint things always have the potential to spiral out of control in Kashmir.
Even as the establishment has been banking on the anticipation of a good tourist season, strict but cautious policing and a youth geared more towards reaping benefits of a rising economy than causing long-drawn stir, observers say Kashmir can be unpredictable.
"Kashmiris are smart people. They can reap economic benefits and still vent their anger. They are also politically very conscious. Already the security clampdown is being called Gaza-isation of the valley. Also, while the youth is economically inclined, it is also very impatient," said an expert.
Sources also said as much of a political decision it may have been for the Congress, the party may not benefit from it in the upcoming elections. The leapfrogging to hang Guru over Beant Singh and Rajiv Gandhi killers will only hurt its secular image. In fact, it's the BJP that will be able to consolidate its support base as it has been demanding the hanging for several years, sources said.
However, according to Dulat, the biggest loser in this entire episode is J&K CM Omar Abdullah. "He has completely lost his credibility in the valley," says Dulat. Not surprisingly, Abdullah has been constantly distancing himself from the decision and has castigated Centre over it.
Dulat says the government must now devise a strategy to find a way out of the situation. "And the solution should attempt to go beyond law and order mechanisms. Militancy is not the thing to fear in the valley, but public anger is," he added.
Had Vajpayee been PM, Afzal's execution wouldn’t have happened: Ex-RAW chief - The Times of India
Look what they are saying now....When afzal was not hanged, they tried to portray it as `minority appeasement`. These BJP RSS workers intruded every where and flooded facebook and emails with tons of post saying afzal is not being hanged just because of this. Congress was clearly loosing vote because this. Despite this they considered national interest, sake of kashmir they avoided this. But now, look what they are doing..they fell on BJP trap.
Look like i say always, BJP is the least patriotic party of our country.
