Dont slam ‘PK’ without even seeing it: Hindu leader

[Hindustani78]

PK was a mushy over sweat shitfest but how exactly ur sentiments were hurt by the chase scene! do u somehow belive that that the person enacting Lord Shiva on stage and subsequently chased by PK was Lord Himself!!

I don't think that Muslims or Christians or Sikhs or even Buddhists will like to see that their religious figures are shown like that in any movie and the same is being done by the Hindu groups in protest.

Already there is so much uproar in our country regarding many issues which is being raised by the Hindu groups and now at this moment again the same is going on.

why will central govt get involved!!

Censor board guidelines are issued by central government only.

 

[punit]

I don't think that Muslims or Christians or Sikhs or even Buddhists will like to see that their religious figures are shown like that in any movie and the same is being done by the Hindu groups in protest.

Already there is so much uproar in our country regarding many issues which is being raised by the Hindu groups and now at this moment again the same is going on.




Censor board guidelines are issued by central government only.

final decision lies with censor board.

 

[Hindustani78]

so am i ...although not very liberal.

I am Liberal and believe in engaging on all the issues but in peaceful ways.

any right group ppl in the world "fake" cares about his/her religion and trashes the rest. their education and mindset are narrower than the narrow lanes where they live.
just because those retards come up with some "arguments" doesnt mean that we have to jump into the discussion , let alone support it. please let ur brain do some exercise and not let these wayward men influence ur thoughts.

There are political or religious reasons behind all these things but in all this why the ordinary people have to suffer ? If things turned into violence then the first people who will be suffering will be the ordinary people. Try to think more deeper .

final decision lies with censor board.

Yes and when censor board has allowed it , why the central or state governments haven't raised any objection ?

 

[punit]

I am Liberal and believe in engaging on all the issues but in peaceful ways.



There are political or religious reasons behind all these things but in all this why the ordinary people have to suffer ? If the turned into violence then the first people who will be suffering will be the ordinary people. Try to think more deeper .



Yes and when censor board has allowed it , why the central or state governments haven't raised any objection ?

because they can niot intervene. Only courts can overturn the direction of Censor board. Even if a film is banned by Govt it can be challenged in court.

 

[Hindustani78]

because they can niot intervene. Only courts can overturn the direction of Censor board. Even if a film is banned by Govt it can be challenged in court.

Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) is a Statutory body under Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, regulating the public exhibition of films under the provisions of the Cinematograph Act 1952.

Films can be publicly exhibited in India only after they have been certified by the Central Board of Film Certification.

 

[Slav Defence]

I have seen this movie as well.The basic idea wasn't bad.However, the way of delivering it might have been considered as inappropriate. It would be much better if they have only targetted those pundits, maulvis and missionaries which are looting us in the name of religion and maligning it's images rather than religion itself.
This problem is common in both indo-pak, so relax!
Regards

 

[Juggernautjatt]

This film is not against Hindus IMO. It is just against superstitions & bad mouthing religious leaders.

 

[Hindustani78]

This film is not against Hindus IMO. It is just against superstitions & bad mouthing religious leaders.
View attachment 181447

We all know that this debate will never end. Some will say every child born as Muslim and other will say born again Christians and others will say if you born in India, you are hindu.

Claims and counter claims are going on everywhere.

 

[baajey]

There are political or religious reasons behind all these things but in all this why the ordinary people have to suffer ? If things turned into violence then the first people who will be suffering will be the ordinary people. Try to think more deeper

so we should stifle free speech in order to appease the goons ??? where is the understanding when "ghar wapsi" etc are brazenly encouraged. i m sure u are a sane person (ur recent posts are the proof), but I doubt there was anything in the movie which hurt hindu sentiments (i m talking general hindu sentiments shared by u, ur family or the next door neighbours, and not the political hindu sentiments , which are supposed to be protected by the right wing idiots.).
Also , when OMG released, there werent any such exploding sentiments (although OMG was far more critical of the hindu rituals). but i do believe that if OMG would be re released tomorrow, it wud face same accusation as PK has faced. u and i can only guess whats the difference between then and now.
the last time such appeasement happened, Europe paid the price.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

All are human beings feel offended be it Hindu, Muslims, christian, Sikh etc and being Indians all should work out to respect each other and stop offending each other.

Killing any people is wrong overall its the loss of Indians. GoI should pass bill like United states that hurting and killing any Indian aboard will not be tolerated.

Intellectual freedom should be guarded until the act is caused deliberately to insult - in which case the person ceases to be an intellectual and gets reduced to a hatemonger.

I don't have any problem with pk being shown, but I have the right to express my opinions about it. Protesting against it or supporting it - both are within my rights. I just hope the next time Taslima Nasrin or Salman Rusdie comes to India, there will not be a great hue and cry. Because that would expose the selective bias that we are accustomed to.

just because those retards come up with some "arguments" doesnt mean that we have to jump into the discussion

Exactly. Those who are hurt are wrong. You are right.

 

[Pride]

I watched movie with my family including parents and though my mom is religious she wasn't offended. The point is simple there are so many ill practices are coming in religion and religious activities and it is spread across all religions. The only reason, it is primarily on Hindus, because RajKumar Hirani himself is Hindu. I have seen any religious place in India you visit irrespective of religions, it is sheer business and that is why I started avoiding them. I am from Allahabad and I know how "Panda" make fool of others. Also, you go to Ajmer Sharif and people demand money inside shrine as well.

 

[Dem!god]

i want to see a movie on muhammads true life..
if only bollywood has guts to make this.. i bet.

 

[Hindustani78]

This film is not against Hindus IMO. It is just against superstitions & bad mouthing religious leaders.
View attachment 181447

But any ways all talks are about the land of India. Be it in the name of Bani Adam or all were Hindus by Praveen Togadia. Hope Indians should understand the real message.

 

[waz]

Hindus should not have the right to feel offended. If they are they are insensitive, bigoted, have no jobs etc.


Umm, no. Religious sentiments, like any other sentiments SHOULD ALSO BE hurt.

But those who get offended need to be respected - as long as they don't kill people and burn theaters down.

Oh of course dear chap, people should be free to comment and hurt sentiments all they want. The issue is the civil unrest that occurs in the aftermath. Yes it's wrong, but it's also reality. I'm afraid the sub-continent hasn't quite experienced the renaissance that Europe did, hence my comment.

why.. I think its govt's job to protect ordinary public(and their property) from sentimental people.

Of course, but not every sentimental person wants to tear apart the place apart. But anyway, I already stated why I wrote my earlier post.

 

[Hindustani78]

so we should stifle free speech in order to appease the goons ??? where is the understanding when "ghar wapsi" etc are brazenly encouraged. i m sure u are a sane person (ur recent posts are the proof), but I doubt there was anything in the movie which hurt hindu sentiments (i m talking general hindu sentiments shared by u, ur family or the next door neighbours, and not the political hindu sentiments , which are supposed to be protected by the right wing idiots.).
Also , when OMG released, there werent any such exploding sentiments (although OMG was far more critical of the hindu rituals). but i do believe that if OMG would be re released tomorrow, it wud face same accusation as PK has faced. u and i can only guess whats the difference between then and now.
the last time such appeasement happened, Europe paid the price.

When Hindu groups are raising this issue even when the movie was allowed by Censor board which is under the Ministry of information and Broadcasting then its needed to be think what this whole issue is about. I do agree with you that OMG movie was even critic but the role played by Akshay kumar as Lord Krishna done the balance.