What's new

Chinese Aero Engine information thread

still they bought more than 900 engines just in 2002 they bought 300

Speaking to AIN at the Aviation Expo 2011 in Beijing, Salut general director Vladislav Masalov said that negotiations continue on a second batch of nearly 140 AL-31FNs and that a follow-on contract is expected to be signed in October.

Masalov further said that the grand total of Salut-made AL-31 series engines in China “is nearing one thousand units.” To serve them, Salut has established partnerships with Limin Corp. and Tyan Li company in Chengdu on deliveries and manufacturing of spare parts for both the AL-31F and the AL-31FN. Russia has also agreed to provide all necessary maintenance and repair documentation to the Chinese partner


https://www.ainonline.com/aviation-...big-new-chinese-order-russian-fighter-engines

so bad quality they have bought 1000
The AL-31 engines were solely responsible for quite a few J-10 crashes. So the quality of Russian products is definitely in question ...

It's not like there was much of a choice back then. Now there is.
Either a bad engine or no engine
 
still they bought more than 900 engines just in 2002 they bought 300

Speaking to AIN at the Aviation Expo 2011 in Beijing, Salut general director Vladislav Masalov said that negotiations continue on a second batch of nearly 140 AL-31FNs and that a follow-on contract is expected to be signed in October.

Masalov further said that the grand total of Salut-made AL-31 series engines in China “is nearing one thousand units.” To serve them, Salut has established partnerships with Limin Corp. and Tyan Li company in Chengdu on deliveries and manufacturing of spare parts for both the AL-31F and the AL-31FN. Russia has also agreed to provide all necessary maintenance and repair documentation to the Chinese partner


https://www.ainonline.com/aviation-...big-new-chinese-order-russian-fighter-engines

so bad quality they have bought 1000

It is not bad quality in question. The point they raised was manufacturing practice by certain workers, and lack of quality control. These were findings after investigation of crash due to engine malfunction. Thus instead of re-design the engine for better quality, it is a matter of improving workers proficiency in Russian factory.
 
The AL-31 engines were solely responsible for quite a few J-10 crashes. So the quality of Russian products is definitely in question ...


Either a bad engine or no engine
when you understand why J-10 continued using Al-31s when J-11 used WS-10s you will understand Al-31 was far more reliable than the Chinese engine

when you understand why J-10 continued using Al-31s when J-11 used WS-10s you will understand Al-31 was far more reliable than the Chinese engine
nonsense, single engine aircraft tend to have higher accident rates than twin engines, F-16s are prone to have more accidents than F-18s or F-15s
 
Many of the so called AL-31 you seen serve in PLAAF is in fact overhaul by Chinese themselves since the quality is so bad originally from Russia.
Yup. There was a IHS Janes report in 2010 which stated that the Chinese doubled the AL-31's MTBO through in-house upgrades. Even those upgrades weren't enough to prevent a couple J-10 engine accidents...
 
Yup. There was a IHS Janes report in 2010 which stated that the Chinese doubled the AL-31's MTBO through in-house upgrades. Even those upgrades weren't enough to prevent a couple J-10 engine accidents...
Cost effective of Russian engine is not good.
 
As if Chinese now still buy Russian engine...
they do they bought 48 spare 117 for Su-35s and they bought 1000 Al31s of course lick your wounds, Russia is already flying T-30s on one Su-57, if China has something better why do you buy Su-35? of course in the land Alice in wonder land was charity, specially as an old IL-76 can be re-engined with PS-90 but China is stuck with obsolete engines for Y-20 and still buys engines to Ukraine, but live in wonder land Al-31s that China got are designs from 1980 upgraded in the 1990s, Su-30MS are going to be upgraded soon with 117s and Il-76 with PS-90 have better performance than Y-20
 
Last edited:
they do they bought 48 spare 117 for Su-35s and they bought 1000 Al31s of course is lick your wounds, Russia is already flying T-30s on one Su-57, if China has something better why do you buy Su-35? of course in the land alice in wonder land was charity, specially as an old IL-76 can be re-engined with PD-90 but China is stuck with obsolete engines for Y-20 and still buys engines to Ukraine, but live in wonder land Al-31s that China got are designs from 1980 upgraded in the 1990s, Su-30MS are going to be upgraded soon with 117s and Il-76 with PD-90 have better performance than Y-20
There is no point beating the old news. China WS-10 are no CMF-56 equivalent from the 80s. They are much improve and upthrusted. Same as the engine currently used on Y-20. Your IL-76 fitted with new PD-90 still has an inferior smaller cargo bay and lower payload compare to Y-20 with current engine.

Kawasaki C-2 fitted with 2 powerful engine that has more thrust than 4 D-30kp2 but just manage to get a payload of 40tons only. More or less speak of the the bad engineering. Same as your new IL-476.
 
There is no point beating the old news. China WS-10 are no CMF-56 equivalent from the 80s. They are much improve and upthrusted. Same as the engine currently used on Y-20. Your IL-76 fitted with new PD-90 still has an inferior smaller cargo bay and lower payload compare to Y-20 with current engine.

Kawasaki C-2 fitted with 2 powerful engine that has more thrust than 4 D-30kp2 but just manage to get a payload of 40tons only. More or less speak of the the bad engineering. Same as your new IL-476.
fantasy of Chinese forum, WS-10 is used mostly on J-11 for a simple reason a less reliable engine needs a mate if it fails on a single engine you need a more reliable engine because if it fails your aircraft drops, if China has better J-11 with Ws-10 why buy Su-35? in fantasy land for charity, but in real land J-11 has not better performance than Su-35,otherwise you will never buy Su-35 specially now China has TVC nozzles, and remember ARJ-21 and 919 use western engines none fly on Chinese engines but there are Tu-214 flying with Ps-90s.

J-10s fly on al-31 for a reason, a more reliable engine..

Y-20 has engines that burn fuel in higher amounts, the payload is how large in the cargo compartment, but how much fuel you burn on your engines means your performance is lower, Il-476 has new wings and better engines, it will burn less fuel regardless your Alice in wonderland story
 
Last edited:
fantasy of Chinese forum, WS-10 is used mostly on J-11 for a simple reason a less reliable engine needs a mate if it fails on a single engine you need a more reliable engine because if it fails your aircraft drops, if China has better J-11 with Ws-10 why buy Su-35? in fantasy land for charity, but in real land J-11 has not better performance than Su-35,otherwise you will never buy Su-35 specially now China has TVC nozzles, and remember ARJ-21 and 919 use western engines none fly on Chinese engines but there are Tu-214 flying with Ps-90s.

J-10s fly on al-31 for a reason, a more reliable engine..

Y-20 has engines that burn fuel in higher amounts, the payload is how large in the cargo compartment, but how much fuel you burn on your engines means your performance is lower, Il-476 has new wings and better engines, it will burn less fuel regardless your Alice in wonderland story
I guess some is in denial mode.

What engine is that?

If the engine is so unreliable, I guess China will never dare to put a single engine especially with TVC on display for hundred thousands of people....

Failure is not an option like this...

Su-35 is bought to balance the blank sheet since Russia complain so much about Chinese buying Russia raw material only. If Su-35 is so good. Let me ask you why only the minimum require of 24 is bought?

As for Civilian engine. China is more ambition with more practical and powerful engine in the pipeline.

ARJ-21 is just a pioneer for more important C919 ambitions. Having more western parts to ensure it going global is more appealing.
 
I guess some is in denial mode.



Su-35 is bought to balance the blank sheet since Russia complain so much about Chinese buying Russia raw material only. If Su-35 is so good. Let me ask you why only the minimum require of 24 is bought?



ARJ-21 is just a pioneer for more important C919 ambitions. Having more western parts to ensure it going global is more appealing.
minimum requirement was 24 at 2 billion Dollars 48 Su-35s equal 4 billion, why do not you make math instead of putting idiotic theories, China does not sell engines for fighters to Russia nor to the West, so far a more realistic person says China could not buy more because they are darn expensive and 100 would have been close to more than 8 billion, but of course stupidity can not accept reality, the whole Su-27SK/J-11 clone costed 2.5 billion dollars, 38 Su-30MKK were even cheaper, China has made advances and eventually they will catch up in some areas, but deny weaknesses are only for stupids, China is still behind the west, and Russia in aircraft engines, Russia too is behind the west in engines but they are much more capable than China at this moment, in fact J-31 has nothing near 135 engine used on F-35, they use two old RD-95 and in order to speed up the development they were realistic a 135 is decades away so they opted for two RD-93 and if lucky in the future they might have something domestic but one single 135 equals two RD-93 do you get it no one now has an engine as powerful to power a single engine aircraft, nor Russia even does, T-30 engine perhaps has surpassed 119 engine but still in tests and PD-14 is just nearly 1 year to be fit to MS-21, and if lucky by 2023 they might start making it with PD-14.


And about C919 few in the west will buy it until it is not proven safe, so they use western equipment first because ARJ-21 is a disaster no one flies it in the west nor even Latin america or Africa only China and by government order, they lack the equipment, the safety prestige and the cost efficiency plus you are dreaming the West will not allow it to fly it in the western world, even Superjet 100 has problems for sales, so stop putting excuses C919 has no proven record and its rivals will not let it fly beyond China
 
Last edited:

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom