Bhagavad Gita faces 'extremist' branding, ban in Russia

[Doctor09]

I doubt if any one can tell you about the authenticity. I as a Hindu have never even heard of the first book and not even 1% of the Hindus would have read Manu smriti.

Stop quoting from blogspots like "Hinduism Exposed". They are out of context verses. IF you are curious you should go find the books and read it yourself. There a millions other similar blogsites and websites on the lines of "Islam Exposed", which has some pretty strange verses. Should I start asking you about the authenticity of those verses?

why are you burning with hate ? i just asked a simple question and i got my answer . no need to troll ok

 

[Roybot]

I feel for sensitive little injuns.

Ah grow up.

I read the Quran when I was visiting Pakistan as part of my "Pakistan Orientation". Some of the stuffs written there shocked me. Allow me to quote

Verse 1: Inflammatory verse from the Quran taken out of context from Islam Exposed website.

Verse 2: Derogatory verse from the Quran taken out of context from Islam Watch website.

See its not that hard to be a bs artist?

---------- Post added at 11:49 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:47 PM ----------

why are you burning with hate ? i just asked a simple question and i got my answer . no need to troll ok

Burning with hate? Its just common sense, do you think I ll be able to understand the Quran by asking random questions to random unqualified people on the internet? Of course not.

 

[Doctor09]

haha you kinda answered your own question there. There is no such thing in Vedas! It's like saying Quran advocates pedophiles, adultery, terrorism and suggests that women should be used as a sex tool to give birth to Muslim babies. Which is as much of lies as what you've just quoted.

try to choose your words carefully , i just quoted few things from one of your books ( and Indian members told me they are not authentic) .
i can choose more disgusting words but i respect every religion and this is what my religion told me .

 

[joekrish]

In india - the Caste system is prevalent everywhere - it has always held them back, and is also the cause of the "reservation" business.

People not only miss interpret the quran or the bible it also happens with the Gita, Ramayan and the Mahabaratha I hope you would understand that better.

 

[Doctor09]

Ah grow up.

I read the Quran when I was visiting Pakistan as part of my "Pakistan Orientation". Some of the stuffs written there shocked me. Allow me to quote



See its not that hard to be a bs artist?

---------- Post added at 11:49 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:47 PM ----------



Burning with hate? Its just common sense, do you think I ll be able to understand the Quran by asking random questions to random unqualified people on the internet? Of course not.

Mr. that is why i asked Indian members about the authenticity of these .

 

[Rafi]

Ah grow up.

I read the Quran when I was visiting Pakistan as part of my "Pakistan Orientation". Some of the stuffs written there shocked me. Allow me to quote



See its not that hard to be a bs artist?

---------- Post added at 11:49 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:47 PM ----------



Burning with hate? Its just common sense, do you think I ll be able to understand the Quran by asking random questions to random unqualified people on the internet? Of course not.

Typical injun attitude - Russia is thinking of banning the Gita and not the Quran - your lot are so off topic - but one I have come to expect from inferiority ridden indians.

 

[Roybot]

Mr. that is why i asked Indian members about the authenticity of these .

I can almost guarantee you that none of the Indian/Hindu on this forum has ever come across those verse. They probably exist who knows, but shouldn't be read out of context? No one follows these books.

 

[Rafi]

Caste based politics in india are the reason that there is still a large amount of poverty.

 

[Roybot]

Typical injun attitude - Russia is thinking of banning the Gita and not the Quran - your lot are so off topic - but one I have come to expect from inferiority ridden indians.

Come up something new. Very unoriginal.

Knock yourself out.

Russia takes steps to ban Koran and deport Sharia supporters

 

[dearone4u_22]

Look at this extremist , armed heavy and telling everyone to convert to hinduism .....
How Dare they chant and play music which has been proven harmful to human in the past......pls stick to guns and bombs

 

[Sugarcane]

IMO - there is no point to discuss this topic on a defense forum and agree with JonAsad,

MOD please this tread

 

[Rafi]

O great hero! The duties of Brahmanas, Kshatriyas, Vaishyas and also of Shudras have been divided according to the qualities born of their own nature

This verse alludes to the fact that the Shudras being "born to the qualities - of their OWN nature" is justifying their treatment as the lowest of the low.

 

[Doctor09]

There is no traceability to the origin of this religion. There is no name to this religion. The word "Hinduism" is what is given by the westerneres due to proximity with Sindhu river. Heck there is not even mention of word "Hindu" or hinduism in ANY of our scriptures. Its not even a religion its a way of life.

So it is termed as Sanatan Dharma or eternal religion/ way of life.

Not like someone woke up in some midnight and declared to be founder of a new religion. Ours is Sanathan (eternal) Dharma. Referring to us as Hindus may be an offence if thought in proper perspective.

Here Prophets dont found our religion. Prophets are born in the existing Sanatan Dharma. Even they dont know the origin of it. They simply follow and whatever variant they propose gets assimilated in the very same foundation ie Sanatan Dharma.

your comments are targeting other religion . all other religion are the way of life for the followers . Hinduism is not unique in this sense .
you have concepts of Bhagwaan and otaars and we have concept of Prophets so lets not discuss this thing . i dont want to indulge in religious fight . for you is your religion and for me is my religion

 

[v9s]

haha you kinda answered your own question there. There is no such thing in Vedas! It's like saying Quran advocates pedophiles, adultery, terrorism and suggests that women should be used as a sex tool to give birth to Muslim babies. Which is as much of lies as what you've just quoted.

Ahh..so basically the Smritis are the Hindu equivalent of the hadith books, i.e. not authentic and full of conjecture.

 

[Altaf Bhai]

Caste based politics in india are the reason that there is still a large amount of poverty.

Its reducing tremendously. Caste based political players like Lalu prasad Yadav got only 4 seats in parliament as compared to 45 seats some years ago, Ramvilas paswan only 1 seat of himself from previous 27. These numbers are game chaning in Indian politics.

People are rejecting it overwhelmingly.

---------- Post added at 06:00 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:58 PM ----------

Ahh..so basically the Smritis are the Hindu equivalent of the hadith books, i.e. not authentic and full of conjecture.

ManuSmriti is Manu's Interpretation and his views on social code of conduct. Its not binding.

No religious text is binding in Sanatan Dharma. Like its OK to draw cartoon of your prophet even if it is forbidden by your book. This is the sort of liberty offered. The liberty to question to be critical, to introspect, to discard. Basically, its a way of life and not a religion as such.