Bangladesh bans Maududi's books in mosques

[TopCat]

If you really want to enrich Bangladesh with good literature then you are to read Allama Iqbal, Maulana Rumi and poet like Hafiz. Tagore has no chance against these guys.

I will welcome their work. That will only enrich our already huge literature.
No comparisn with Tagore.. Tagore is a completely different type of modern poet...

 

[Bas_tum_Pak]

i am Big fan of Maududi , I have read lot of his books.
any one can prove any thing wrong about Him?

Read his Tafseer of Quran 'Tafheem Ul Quran', Then you will see how good he was.

 

[Al-zakir]

No i cant but if i can stop islamic foundation to stop patronizing Moududi books then i could save a whole of youngs..

You know Maulana Nizami, Mujahid and Allama Syeddi were arrested due to the ground of hurting religious sentiment. In this case Islam. Another word blasphemy law comes in mind.

Now Imagine if BNP-Jamat come back to power in future. What will happen to Secularist and so called free minded Awami intellectual??

oh man. I am already loving to think about they day of our day.

Now can you really blame us if you guys show us the way.

 

[M_Saint]

Shibir cadres, JMB, HUJI who are caught by police found with translation of Moududi books.

First off, get this in your head that you are arguing with a Non-RAWAMY-Commie that doesn't even accept JMB exists beyond Bharati-dalal's operational paradigm like AQ doesn't above Likud-Link's one. So, creating a Boggy first in hush-hush method and then handing him some books of a writer of Bharati's disliking just to defame anti-Bharati Jamaat is nothing but fishing in troubled water. Do you agree or not?

And 2ndly, whats wrong Shibir cadre carrying Moududi's book? Does any JI/Shibiries object BJP/VHP walas carrying Bhagabat Gita of Bharati-Nationalistic school?

 

[TopCat]

First off, get this in your head that you are arguing with a Non-RAWAMY-Commie that doesn't even accept JMB exists beyond Bharati-dalal's operational paradigm like AQ doesn't above Likud-Link's one. So, creating a Boggy first in hush-hush method and then handing him some books of a writer of Bharati's disliking just to defame anti-Bharati Jamaat is nothing but fishing in troubled water. Do you agree or not?

No I do not agree..

 

[EjazR]

Maududiat does not represent Islam. His ideology was affected mainly communist revolutions and Qutbism and Maudidiat are the foundation fo politcal Islam which has become the biggest problem for muslims today. This interpretation is completely against traditional Islam and many traditional Islamic scholars have refuted his ideology and concepts.
However,there are other works he has written about Islam in general or against communism which are fine. It is his using of Islam as a politcal tool that many traditional scholars disagree with.

Rather than banning outright, his ideas should be debated and debunked. Traditional Islamic scholars in the light of Quran and Sunnah should show the wrong interpretations and emphasize the problems that ithas caused for muslims today. However, if its just a withdrawal from govertnment mosques that is a different story.

Pertinent to note that Maududi was never a graduate from any Dar-ul-ullom orIslamic school. Also interesting to note was just a few months back. Jammat Islami Hind in India stated that even though Maududi had founded their organisation, theyno longer follow his philosophy and ideas but rathr the Quran and Sunnah.

 

[TopCat]

And 2ndly, whats wrong Shibir cadre carrying Moududi's book? Does any JI/Shibiries object BJP/VHP walas carrying Bhagabat Gita of Bharati-Nationalistic school?

I thought BJP/VHP belongs to India and there is nothing JI could do about it.. pointless.

 

[M_Saint]

Now Imagine if BNP-Jamat come back to power in future. What will happen to Secularist and so called free minded Awami intellectual??

Nothing would happen as they would cross the border to reach at their Mashto- Pishato Boons in WB. They did it before and got away with murders and oppression in the past many times and they knew that they could do it again and again since West Pakistani soldiers weren't in BD anymore to guard Islam and Muslims. That was why I commented like with the departure of West Pakistani soldiers from our land, Islam was drawn in to Bay of Bengal. Perhaps Indira Ghandi analyzed it before anyone to make similar comments too.

 

[Patriot]

JI is a political party which uses Islam (the greatest religion) as it's tool.I think JI should be banned in Pakistan too.

 

[M_Saint]

I thought BJP/VHP belongs to India and there is nothing JI could do about it.. pointless.

I thought a Dada of WB was posing as BD national for all along.

 

[TopCat]

I thought a Dada of WB was posing as BD national for all along.

You are always in bad dream saint.. please wake up....

 

[M_Saint]

JI is a political party which uses Islam (the greatest religion) as it's tool.I think JI should be banned in Pakistan too.

Repub in US is a political party that uses Christiniaty as tool, BJP is a political party in IND that uses Hindutavya as the same. Can you ask for its abandonment?

 

[TopCat]

Repub in US is a political party that uses Christiniaty as tool, BJP is a political party in IND that uses Hindutavya as the same. Can you ask for its abandonment?

They do not pose a threat to the basic democracy but JI does. As soon as JI get a chance they will impose Talibanism over the whole nation.

 

[Al-zakir]

Maududiat does not represent Islam. His ideology was affected mainly communist revolutions and Qutbism and Maudidiat are the foundation fo politcal Islam which has become the biggest problem for muslims today.

Biggest problem of Muslims today is ignorance and division. Maudidi is not problem. If Madudi's philosophy goes against Qur'an and Sunnah then it's automatically discredited.

Now there are some Maulana become traditional and accepted by secularist because they are anti Jamatis. Not necessarily true Islamic scholars.

 

[humanfirst]

Guys is it true that ji support terrorists in pakistan?Do they consider dead ttp terrorists martyrs etc,,?Can some pakistani member give some info about how was the contribution of jamate islami to pakistani society,