CriticalThought
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Oct 10, 2016
- Messages
- 7,094
- Reaction score
- 13
- Country
- Location
You never have to according to quran we can even say kufr to save our life we can eat pork and drink wine with in the limits to save our life
and someone else's life what to say our own family quran says saving one human is like saving the whole of humanity and killing one human is like killing the whole of humanity we need to read quran holistically. It's totally wrong deduction that in some cases we have to secrefic our family physically for God. The story
Of hazrat Ibrahim was really the end of human sacrifice. On altar. The real lesson was stop sacrificing Humans on altar I God just want purity of your heart not human blood On altar
in another place the Qur'an says that God receives neither bloody nor meat but the purity of your hearts. I know what you are saying and it's right but it can be misconstrued.
Oh bhai why are you so fatalistic? I do not believe the original question was about saving the life of parents. It was more in the spirit of, what if you need to take some action that has negative impact on parents. But even in the most severe case, for example, if a non-Muslim father is facing his son in Jihad, the son will not hesitate in taking his life. This is evident from the example of Abu Bakr May Allah be Pleased with him. Or suppose your non-Muslim parents command you to revert. You will not follow their order even if this irks them. As I said earlier, these are edge cases that do not occur in the normal lives of most Muslims.
Second, why are we even having the discussion of human sacrifice? Provide a valid reference that says any Shariah revealed by Allah ordained people to perform human sacrifice. The only case we have is that of Abraham and Ismail Peace be upon them, and as we all know, the actual act of human sacrifice didn't take place, it was merely a test. Why are you bringing up human sacrifice?