Aren’t Rohingyas Bengalis, and Arakan integral to Bangladesh?

[UKBengali]

We run the show in your country, it was BD from where we launched our campaign to nab zakir naik.

Ok, if you say so.

 

[HariSinghNalwa]

Call it what you will India has built Sithwe port for connectivity with tripura and Mizoram and also want to implement trilateral highway till thailand as soon an 2019 ,Myanmar is lichpin to our act east policy also china also has many economic project in Myanmar ,so does japan ,so annexing a territory for bangladesh army might have some blowbacks which the bangladeshi member here don't understand no country would side with them in this hypothetical scenario as Myanmar is very strategic place as it connects china with bay of bengal and india with south east asia and some of north east states of india

 

[UKBengali]

Call it what you will India has built Sithwe port for connectivity with tripura and Mizoram and also want to implement trilateral highway till thailand as soon an 2019 ,Myanmar is lichpin to our act east policy also china also has many economic project in Myanmar ,so does japan ,so annexing a territory for bangladesh army might have some blowbacks which the bangladeshi member here don't understand no country would side with them in this hypothetical scenario as Myanmar is very strategic place as it connects china with bay of bengal and india with south east asia and some of north east states of india

Yeah whatever.

China will stay neutral in a BD/ Myanmar war.

India is irrelevant.

Only US/EU can try sanctions but by the time of any war(say around 2030) at least half of BD trade will be with other countries, and BD will use the excuse of defensive war to save Rohingya from genocide.

Yeah, BD needs to be very very scared of "consequences" lol

 

[HariSinghNalwa]

Only thing it indicates is india shitting in its pants.
If they can't accept anything related to bangla or bengali.We take their sea from them also cause its called "Bay of Bengal".


Only thing it indicates is india shitting in its pants.
If they can't accept anything related to bangla or bengali.We take their sea from them also cause its called "Bay of Bengal".

Bangladesh doesn't have a copyright of Bengal ,our president is a bengali and our province is poschim bongo and bangladesh navy doesn't have capabilities to take on bharatiye nowsena ,some noisy chinese subramanies won't win you your sovereignty which many in BNP chides is being taken by Bharat.

Yeah whatever.

China will stay neutral in a BD/ Myanmar war.

India is irrelevant.

Only US/EU can try sanctions but by the time of any war(say around 2030) at least half of BD trade will be with other countries, and BD will use the excuse of defensive war to save Rohingya from genocide.

Yeah, BD needs to be very very scared of "consequences" lol

Yeah India is irrelevant is much good strategy when going to war with a indian neighbour ,Myanmar army have been fighting rebel militia from decades ,it is a battle hardened army it is increasing its strategic assets and till 2030 it will have respecatable coastal defence as well as a good navy and air forces the ludicrous claims of yours of capturing rakhine state of Myanmar will be good wet dreams as if till 2030 bangladesh will get a conventional edge over Myanmar ,it is speculation of highest order

http://m.economictimes.com/news/def...an-sea-bay-of-bengal/articleshow/51044876.cms


India and Myanmar have signed an agreement on standard operating procedure for coordinated patrols in the strategically significant Andaman Sea and Bay of Bengal even.

As part of the ongoing India-Myanmar defence relations, the fourth edition of the India-Myanmar Coordinated Patrol (IMCOR) was successfully undertaken from February 13-16 along the International MaritimeBoundary Line (IMBL) in the Andaman Sea.

Indian Navy ships Saryu and Bitra, along with Myanmar ships Aung Zeya and FAC 563, participated in the 4th IMCOR.

During the closing ceremony of 4th IMCOR, the Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) for IMCOR was signed between Indian Navy and Myanmar Navy.

Myanmar is only the third country with which India has signed a formal agreement for maritime coordinated patrols and reflects growing naval interaction between India and Myanmar, a statement by the Navy said.

 

[UKBengali]

Yeah India is irrelevant is much good strategy when going to war with a indian neighbour ,Myanmar army have been fighting rebel militia from decades ,it is a battle hardened army it is increasing its strategic assets and till 2030 it will have respecatable coastal defence as well as a good navy and air forces the ludicrous claims of yours of capturing rakhine state of Myanmar will be good wet dreams as if till 2030 bangladesh will get a conventional edge over Myanmar ,it is speculation of highest order

http://m.economictimes.com/news/def...an-sea-bay-of-bengal/articleshow/51044876.cms


India and Myanmar have signed an agreement on standard operating procedure for coordinated patrols in the strategically significant Andaman Sea and Bay of Bengal even.

As part of the ongoing India-Myanmar defence relations, the fourth edition of the India-Myanmar Coordinated Patrol (IMCOR) was successfully undertaken from February 13-16 along the International MaritimeBoundary Line (IMBL) in the Andaman Sea.

Indian Navy ships Saryu and Bitra, along with Myanmar ships Aung Zeya and FAC 563, participated in the 4th IMCOR.

During the closing ceremony of 4th IMCOR, the Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) for IMCOR was signed between Indian Navy and Myanmar Navy.

Myanmar is only the third country with which India has signed a formal agreement for maritime coordinated patrols and reflects growing naval interaction between India and Myanmar, a statement by the Navy said.

Yeah, whatever.

BD has no fear of India as it is powerless to do anything. Go bully little states like Bhutan lol

As soon as BD economy and military is ready, BD will deal with the little upstart Myanmar once and for all.

 

[HariSinghNalwa]

Myanmar is a ancient country ,bangladesh an increasingly Islamist nation with radical wahabi populace can't be a economic power in true sense as many commentators have mentioned the closeness between india state and hasina wajid is scene as a traitorous value similarly cadres of JMB will be increasing and the instability of the political change of power which happens in bangladesh as the opposition never trust the incumbent and wants a care taker govt there are many reforms to be made to bangladesh be a economic and military power ,the discipline of its forces is also in question after BDR rebellion episode remain much tainted and no bangladeshi believe the BGB as they consider them incapable of giving response to BSF,so as i said this is speculation of highest order ,you should be in stock markets if you could predict wars like that

http://thediplomat.com/2017/03/india-to-supply-torpedoes-to-myanmar/


S Christopher, the head of India’s Defense Research and Development Organization (DRDO), confirmed in New Delhi that the export of the torpedoes, produced by PSU Bharat Dynamics and engineering company L&T, follows earlier supplies of military equipment including naval sonars, acoustic domes, and directing gear to Myanmar.

Few specifics were provided beyond this. IHS Jane’s quoted unnamed industry sources as saying that Christopher was referring to the DRDO-designed advanced lightweight torpedo Shyena, which is reportedly based on the Whitehead Alenia Sistemi Subacquei (WASS)/Leonardo A244/S lightweight torpedo previously provided to the Indian Navy (IN).

 

[Nilgiri]

@Nilgiri If BD and Myanmar gonna have a war, what your plan?

My plan personally?

Sit back and grab some popcorn.

It wont happen though. BD is not a fighting kind of country and both China and India will apply pressure on both sides to prevent it from happening. At most maybe some border clashes can happen.

 

[Nike]

country like BD with no or significant heavy industry, no decent infrastructure to carry out major attack, no defense industry , no aircraft manufacturer and all talk big, how can they win a war and end it fast? all they had is load of piss poor people with least income.

big bullshit symptoms indeed

@Nilgiri @Aung Zaya @LA se Karachi @Khan_21

 

[swnjo]

if Arakan is integral part of Bangladesh because the people are of Bengali decent, then what about East Bengal that is in India, or Tripura or Assam or Manipur, Meghalaya and Mizoram. They have links with Bengal as well.

No not with north eastern states.All the bengalli speakers came very late here, some with british and most after 1947. All these state were ruled by the local kings and chieftains until 1947.

 

[Imad.Khan]

No not with north eastern states.All the bengalli speakers came very late here, some with british and most after 1947. All these state were ruled by the local kings and chieftains until 1947.

Well that is the history of all of South Asia. Even if they were part of any large kingdoms they were always ruled by local chieftains or in the case of British as a gift for being loyal to them.

 

[Aung Zaya]

China better stay away with it. if BD and Myanmar want to fight, just do it. We will stay neutral. I'm not sure whether the minorities armed force in the North of Myanmar will stay neutral or not.

And most importantly, maybe some neighbour in the adjacent west will come in to fish in trouble water.

鱼蚌相争，渔翁得利。Chinese old saying: A third party will benefit from the tussle.

I don't want to offend anyone. no one is really care about Rohinyas, all they care is the land Arakan and regional influence. I think Myanmar shall give citizenship to those non- seperatists Rohinyas willing to stay and treat them like a ethnic minorities.

If Myanmar want to make ethnic cleaning policy against Rohinyas, you will breach the international law. Your neighbour will fear you, and stay away from you.

bro we're just neutral and u can see who want to fight and annex arakan showing its mights. even Rohingya problem may be part of annexing arakan project. personally i'm against to go war until they start. always support to invite more chinese investment in that region to balance western's.

the west data showed the population of bangali roghingya is doubling every year. and western also said again we're making mass killing. we have no word. they want to show a reason to gain influence in the region like MDW of Iraq.

Now we're doing and follwing the suggestion of Kofi Annan led team.i hope it will be ok. bro

 

[帅的一匹]

bro we're just neutral and u can see who want to fight and annex arakan showing its mights. even Rohingya problem may be part of annexing arakan project. personally i'm against to go war until they start. always support to invite more chinese investment in that region to balance western's.

the west data showed the population of bangali roghingya is doubling every year. and western also said again we're making mass killing. we have no word. they want to show a reason to gain influence in the region like MDW of Iraq.

Now we're doing and follwing the suggestion of Kofi Annan led team.i hope it will be ok. bro

Following the suggestion of Kofi Annan is a good way to lead out. We don't want to be dragged into the Arakan problem, we have lot other mess to deal with.

 

[帅的一匹]

hope BD and Myanmar can solve the Rohinyas problem by the international law, bring peace back along the border.

 

[TopCat]

country like BD with no or significant heavy industry, no decent infrastructure to carry out major attack, no defense industry , no aircraft manufacturer and all talk big, how can they win a war and end it fast? all they had is load of piss poor people with least income.

big bullshit symptoms indeed

@Nilgiri @Aung Zaya @LA se Karachi @Khan_21

Ask how Chinese screwed Americans in first korean war.
Get a google earth and look at the Rakhine geography and see if MM army has the capacity to hold the ground there. Its not BD but its MM which has to fight 3 front war in the tiny sandwiched piece of land.
And why are you inviting trolls to back you up when you are an expert in everything (as you claim)

hope BD and Myanmar can solve the Rohinyas problem by the international law, bring peace back along the border.

Its not between BD and MM. Its between Rohingya and MM. We even did not know that a country MM exist before they pushed 1/2 million of refugee within our border. They made us a party by calling those Rohingya as Bangladeshi.

 

[帅的一匹]

Ask how Chinese screwed Americans in first korean war.
Get a google earth and look at the Rakhine geography and see if MM army has the capacity to hold the ground there. Its not BD but its MM which has to fight 3 front war in the tiny sandwiched piece of land.
And why are you inviting trolls to back you up when you are an expert in everything (as you claim)



Its not between BD and MM. Its between Rohingya and MM. We even did know that a country MM exist before they pushed 1/2 million of refugee within our border. They made us a party by calling those Rohingya as Bangladeshi.

Aung Zaya said Myanmar is gonna give Roginyas willing to stay in Arakan the citizenship. Hope it's true. Rohingya is definitely not Bangladeshi.