Are Sikhs Hindus or Muslims?

[Stephen Cohen]

After desecration of their temple and murder of sikhs across india makes this even more pathetic

In Punjab ; During the TEN years of Terrorist attacks
EIGHTY percent victims were HINDUS -- ie more than Eight Thousand Hindus

The Sikh terrorists wanted to DRIVE out Hindus from Punjab but FAILED

Because ordinary SIKHS turned AGAINST the Terrorists

It was Punjab Police and KPS Gill who KILLED all TERRORISTS

 

[Indus Pakistan]

So would you say Gorkha are not Hindu?

I did not say that. What I said is Sikhs have history and tradition that is unique to them, sufficent to be considered as separate religion and not some appendage of something else. Nothing you say is going to change that fact.

Punjab was not the only state annexed by Britishers.

I know. Thanks for reminding. The British "Make India". They used force and their own blood in "Make India". It would be nice if people remember this when this think of 1947. A British entity built by British blood united by killing the locals broke up becasuse locals did not want to be shackled to the British product.

 

[Stephen Cohen]

No because sikhs had lost their balls, kashmiris still fight refusing to accept occupation

The sikhs just gave up except for a few brave hearts who still want india destroyed

You are JEALOUS because Sikhs are with INDIA and Sikhs love India

 

[Centurion2016]

THE KASHMIRIS are NOT fighting THEY LOVE india being indian

ITS THE TERROR outfights from Pakistan causing the issue.

LIKE WISE INDIA IS CAUSING MAYHEM IN BALUCHISTAN lets see who wins

but today over siachen the Kashmir valley the water supply ITS ALL INDIAN CONTROL AND FLAG

 

[Great Sachin]

Neither Hindus Nor Muslims. Sikhism is an Independent religion Period.

Guru Nanak was born Hindu....period

 

[Parul]

Guru Nanak was born Hindu....period

Did anyone say that he wasn't born to Hindu Parents?

 

[Kathin_Singh]

"If this religious thread was about ISLAM, then in no time it was closed with some pink members.

But since the real objective of this thread is to drive a wedge between Hindus and Sikhs members,it would be kept alive"

~Ghanta Baba ji

 

[hussain0216]

You are JEALOUS because Sikhs are with INDIA and Sikhs love India

Couldn't care less about sikhs
They chose their path and rather than having a independent sikh punjab on the Indian side, they chose servitude.

They were repaid by the desecration of their most holy temple and slaughter of their people

If they still want to gargle hindu balls after that then they are beyond hope

 

[Parul]

What did he do ?

I had a debate on this subject with a Multiple ID's Hindutva Troll on this Subject - I'd dig up the thread and you can go through it. Allow me some time.

 

[hussain0216]

THE KASHMIRIS are NOT fighting THEY LOVE india being indian

ITS THE TERROR outfights from Pakistan causing the issue.

LIKE WISE INDIA IS CAUSING MAYHEM IN BALUCHISTAN lets see who wins

but today over siachen the Kashmir valley the water supply ITS ALL INDIAN CONTROL AND FLAG

They are Muslim, they hate india, hindus like the rest if us

Balochistan is fine, growing and on track

Our water supply is fine

 

[monitor]

Not Muslim but they like to hang out with Muslim.

No I heard they are more against Muslim then him dude. Their man were 'churi' with a vow to eliminated Muslim then remove the churi

 

[Centurion2016]

Hussain

Not has fine as the WATER supply running through indian dams in Himlayers and Kashmirs OR THE saichen glaciers

 

[911]

So far the thread has served its purpose.

 

[Kathin_Singh]

Guru Nanak was born Hindu....period

Did anyone say that he wasn't born to Hindu Parents?

Jesus was born also JEW. So should it mean there are no Christian as such? NO

 

[takeiteasy]

Sikhism seems to be striving to-be-monotheistic religion with good influence from Islam and culturally closer to Hinduism. Many Muslims also left Islam for Sikhism in pre-partition Punjab. Sikhs absolutely hate to be called as Hindus contrary to RSS Ugravaadi opinion. However, there's no doubt Sikhism is a front-line martial group formed to protect the people in the Punjab and their faith (Hinduism).

Sikh's Guru Nanak is said to have turned Mohammadan icon of Ka'aba in Mecca.
Guru Nanak's account of the occurrence of Mecca
http://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php/Guru_Nanak_in_Mecca

When I went to the Kabbah at Mecca Sharrif I was resting. From there a Kaddam (Moluvi/priest) came to me running and with raging anger and said " O Fakir move your feet away from the Kabbah and sit properly". I said with patience, humbly "Why talk in so much anger (rudely) to tell me for what I have done". After saying this I started to move my feet, whereever I moved my feet the Kabbah sharrif's door moved. That kaddam/qaddam (priest) after seeing such a miracle was suprised and asked for forgiveness. In such the priest's knowledge was enlightened and he kissed my (Guru Nanak's) hands and for his rudeness and asked for forgiveness. Everything that occured was due to Allah's great given utmost mercy and grace.