After telecom, India halts Chinese power equipments suppliers

[xuxu1457]

I don't think Indian domestic company can product these Power Equipment:

 

[deepak75]

This is not the way of giving your Products a chance keep following this policy and your products will just be limited to your own domestic market consumer will suffer due to the monopoly of Indian local Producers as they will be able to set their own prices due to lack of Foreign Competition.

I can give you a case study.Just study the effects of banning of second hand imported cars in Pakistan.Who's is suffering?Consumer.

If you wanna develop industry on solid foundations you give something to compete with them.Otherwise your domestic entities will be nothing more than hollow bodies which will be washed away at the mere sighting of Foreign Products.

It is not your consumers that will suffer Sir. It is your manufacturing sector that will suffer because of import of used cars. That is why even African countries do not like it.

It is a huge burden on the foreign reserves and at the same time the jobs are being created in the economy from where you are importing the used cars because they get the money even for their trash. In fact they do not even have to spend money to recycle this trash as is required by their own governmetns.

You are doing yourself no favours by importing used cars or used anything. That is why several countries implement anti - dumping duties on this vehicles.

 

[deepak75]

Yar its crystal clear there is nothing called prefer the local industry thing .Its the kickback indian policy maker get from the local manufacturers .
Its always like this give money to policy makers and they will make policy in ur favour thts it.Nothing toward china or stuff.
And one more thing the much u can pay the better u gonna get .so dont say we dont compromise on quality .Want excellent quality pay more for it and u can have it.

And then on the Pakistan economy thread you guys are worried about the increasing deficit and the lack of revenue generation in your economy.

How much of your prosperity are you ready to give away to Bhai Mulk China?

 

[deepak75]

If your companies were really made to compete they wouldn't be bribing your policy makers into banning Chinese products.

Cheap can be competed with technology and high quality.Otherwise all the big corporation and Japanese Electronics and Car Industry would immediately vanish at the sight of Chinese goods.There is a reason due to which our people in Pakistan prefer to buy Japanese Cars over Chinese Ones.Even if it costs them almost double.

Again i am saying patriotism is one things but businessmen are not so very patriotic when it comes to earning money.Banning Chinese will only make your consumer suffer both in short and long term.

Every system has pros and cons and lack of government involvement in economy is one of them when it comes to capitalism although it depends upon your POV that you consider it as an Advantage or Disadvantage.

I think you got to read the article again. It is not that India cannot manufacture the equipment, it is that the equipment required is more that what current installed capacities can manufacture.

So in step the Chinese with the manipulated currency and their export subsidies and import barriers and they start throwing lower prices in the market. So what happens, the customers instead of adding manufacturing capacity locally start buying the additional requirement from China.

This is called wealth drain my friend. And that is why India will not allow any unfair practice from China to suceed.

 

[deepak75]

Ok lets say your business men haven't done anything ok.

You are actually affirming my point if India can make quality products why ban the Chinese????????

I cannot say that sensible people re ruling India or not because if they would be really sensible and would see the big picture they would had resolved their disputes with Pakistan long time ago.Imagine how much India would earn once it got hold into Pakistani markets.Your Businessmen would had to pay more tax increase revenue for government and generate more jobs making people happy.But Alas!.

If your Industries make better items and Indian People prefer to buy them why in the world does your government have to ban Chinese?

Have you noticed the shape of your economy recently? For example understood what is currently wrong with your yarn industry? Stop and think what have you lost with the dispute with India.

But, I am sure that India is your bigger enemy so I understand why you think what you think.

 

[Marxist]

I don't think Indian domestic company can product these Power Equipment:

BHEL is capable of producing these equipments,

 

[deepak75]

I loled at the people that said our power equipment was low quality.

if it was truly low quality, then the market would've wiped it out.

fact is, 90% of people here don't even know what is high quality and what is low quality in power machinery. if the professionals working with the machines decided to install them, who are nonprofessionals that don't even know the difference between a good and bad turbine to talk about anything?

cost being higher doesn't mean quality is higher, it means cost is higher, period.

Here, take a break from your "Great Leap" economic lecture and read this:

http://www.livemint.com/2009/03/19214938/Dongfang-turbine-fails-trial-r.html

 

[SpArK]

I don't think Indian domestic company can product these Power Equipment:

Nope. they cant ....they produce better products.

 

[Srinivas]

India has done correct thing, We don't need any Chinese cheap and low quality products, If Indian companies can produce quality goods why do India need Chinese goods??

 

[SpArK]

Most people dont understand how huge the companies like L&T and BHEL are...

They are global and listed in Fortune2000 companies of the world.

Cheap products massively produced and dumped into the world are a painful fator and sooner or later this trend will go down.

 

[xuxu1457]

India has done correct thing, We don't need any Chinese cheap and low quality products, If Indian companies can produce quality goods why do India need Chinese goods??

right,why the Customers choose the "lower quality" goods?Are they silly? Why the Indian company need the protect of gov?Like why did army make 1000 T90 but don't want any Ajun,even only accept hundreds at the press of gov~~

 

[SpArK]

right,why the Customers choose the "lower quality" goods?Are they silly?

Maybe...they are... but the governments are not.

Why the Indian company need the protect of gov?Like why did army make 1000 T90 but don't want any Ajun,even only accept hundreds at the press of gov~~

2 words quality and practicability.Price is and was never a factor in army purchases.

 

[xuxu1457]

Maybe...they are... but the governments are not.



2 words quality and practicability.Price is and was never a factor in army purchases.

Funny,I only heard "Customer is God" and "Government servant",the winner is the one who can fit the need of Customer but not let the Customer to fit your procuction~~You lost what you protected~~

 

[SpArK]

Funny,I only heard "Customer is God" and "Government servant",the winner is the one who can fit the need of Customer but not let the Customer to fit your procuction~~You lost what you protected~~

Yes you are right Customer is God that's why we want them access to quality products only.. hence the restrictions.

We didn't lost anything. World dont necessarily revolve around China and today's world gives us plenty of options to choose from.

Thank You.

 

[deepak75]

right,why the Customers choose the "lower quality" goods?Are they silly? Why the Indian company need the protect of gov?Like why did army make 1000 T90 but don't want any Ajun,even only accept hundreds at the press of gov~~

Read this and you will understand India's concerns better. I am sure that you will appreciate India's compulsions and apprhensions.

‘To counter dragon, allow power equipment cos to import freely’