Afghan-Pakistan Relations After Rabbani Assassination

[Ahmad]

According to the UNHCR and the local law enforcement agency, about 50,000 Afghan refugees live in Karachi.

Afghans in Pakistan - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Ok, thank you very much.

 

[darkinsky]

99% if afghans cant obtain iranian citizenship

, 935,600 of these are refugees[1] who cannot obtain Iranian citizenship or permanent residency, and live in Iran under time-limited condition of stay.[1]

 

[Ahmad]

99% if afghans cant obtain iranian citizenship

, 935,600 of these are refugees[1] who cannot obtain Iranian citizenship or permanent residency, and live in Iran under time-limited condition of stay.[1]

they have refugee status in paksitan too. and for god's sake leave people to have healthy debate here. if you have any issue with the iranians you can take your fight to them, why do you taunt me for it.

 

[53fd]

I see that you seem to be rather enjoying the misery of the Afghans and making clear your liking for the Taliban.

Tell me seriously, is Karachi safer? What are the respective tolls in the last 1 year?

The difference between you and me is that we were feeling sad when you Iraqis were killing each other by the hundreds of thousands. Not trying to score cheap points.

No one is trying to enjoy anything. The Taliban wouldn't be anywhere without the support of the Afghan people, they have more legitimacy than Karzai does, & none of this concerns Pakistan. If you are comparing Pakistani cities to Afghanistan, you've got to be out of your mind.

 

[Ahmad]

No one is trying to enjoy anything. The Taliban wouldn't be anywhere without the support of the Afghan people, they have more legitimacy than Karzai does, & none of this concerns Pakistan. If you are comparing Pakistani cities to Afghanistan, you've got to be out of your mind.

i doubt if they have any legitimacy. if they have legitimacy then your taliban also have legitimacy in KP and FATA.

 

[53fd]

i doubt if they have any legitimacy. if they have legitimacy then your taliban also have legitimacy in KP and FATA.

When the TTP start controlling 72% of Pakistan, or keep attacking Islamabad regularly like the Taliban have done with Kabul, we can start talking.

 

[Vinod2070]

No one is trying to enjoy anything. The Taliban wouldn't be anywhere without the support of the Afghan people, they have more legitimacy than Karzai does, & none of this concerns Pakistan. If you are comparing Pakistani cities to Afghanistan, you've got to be out of your mind.

Taliban have less legitimacy in Afghanistan than TTP (Pakistani Taliban) does in Pakistan as Ahmed just pointed out.

And surely less than the likes of MQM and ANP in Karachi who probably have killed more people than have died in Kabul.

You mentioned that Kabul is not safe! I just pointed out some facts.

 

[Ahmad]

When the TTP start controlling 72% of Pakistan, or keep attacking Islamabad regularly like the Taliban have done with Kabul, we can start talking.

i said in KP and FATA, not the whole pakistan. Secondly, ability to destroy is nto the same as legitimacy.

 

[53fd]

Taliban have less legitimacy in Afghanistan than TTP (Pakistani Taliban) does in Pakistan as Ahmed just pointed out.

And surely less than the likes of MQM and ANP in Karachi who probably have killed more people than have died in Kabul.

You mentioned that Kabul is not safe! I just pointed out some facts.

Karachi does not suffer from terrorism like Kabul does, Karachi suffers from ethnic violence. Big difference.

You've got to be kidding me if you think the TTP have more than 72% control of the Pakistani nation, please give me a source that claims more than 72% of the Pakistani nation is controlled by the TTP.

 

[darkinsky]

these ungrateful afghanis

Pakistan envoy to Iran 'attacked by Afghan' in Tehran

Pakistan's ambassador to Iran has been injured in an attack by an Afghan on his car in Tehran, officials say.
The suspect was arrested, an Iranian foreign ministry spokesman quoted by state-run al-Alam TV said.
Mohammad Bakhsh Abbasi was taken to hospital after the incident in the Iranian capital, although he was not reported to have been seriously hurt.
The envoy was travelling without bodyguards or a driver, the foreign ministry spokesman said.
An earlier report from Dubai-based al-Arabiya TV said two bodyguards had been killed.
"The Pakistan ambassador's car has been attacked by an Afghan," foreign ministry spokesman Ramin Mehmanparast was quoted as saying.
"The ambassador has been injured and he is in hospital. The Afghan has been arrested."
A Tehran police chief reportedly said the ambassador had got into a confrontation as he went to a leisure centre he frequents.

 

[Vinod2070]

Karachi does not suffer from terrorism like Kabul does, Karachi suffers from ethnic violence. Big difference.

The roots of terror in Afghanistan is the same ethnic violence.

You've got to be kidding me if you think the TTP have more than 72% support of the Pakistani nation, please give me a source that claims more than 72% of the Pakistani nation supports the TTP.

I never claimed 72% support. You did that.

keep attacking Islamabad regularly like the Taliban have done with Kabul

Like the Marriott hotel attack? There have been several attacks on Islamabad and all Pakistani cities by the Pakistani Taliban. Even on your GCHQ, Naval HQ etc. There have been thousands of civilians who have paid the price with their lives.

 

[53fd]

The roots of terror in Afghanistan is the same ethnic violence.

Not true.

Like the Marriott hotel attack? There have been several attacks on Islamabad and all Pakistani cities by the Pakistani Taliban. Even on your GCHQ, Naval HQ etc. There have been thousands of civilians who have paid the price with their lives.

Islamabad hasn't seen a bomb blast in over 2 years. That's better than Delhi & Mumbai's record. It's been about 8-9 months since the Naval HQ incident happened (which is a rare one in itself), & many years since the GHQ one. Do you want me to start posting to you all the incidents that have taken place in Afghanistan since the start of this year?

 

[darkinsky]

here goes bubble of ahmed bursted

http://www.fpcci.com.pk/trade-with-countries/Afghanistan.pdf

afghanistan import from pakistan is 25.5%

united states 11.5%
germany 9%

iran and india not a top importer

 

[Vinod2070]

Not true.

So you think Taliban are pure terrorists?

Then why are they also "rightful Afghan regime" as per you?

So you are a terrorist supporter?

Islamabad hasn't seen a bomb blast in over 2 years. That's better than Delhi & Mumbai's record. It's been about 8-9 months since the Naval HQ incident happened (which is a rare one in itself), & many years since the GHQ one. Do you want me to start posting to you all the incidents that have taken place in Afghanistan since the start of this year?

OK, tell me the respective toll in Karachi and Kabul.

 

[karan.1970]

Not true.



Islamabad hasn't seen a bomb blast in over 2 years.

We all know why I guess.. The architect of violence in the region was living for so many years next to Islamabad.. Guess no one wanted to bomb the residential area of world's biggest terrorist.. right?