'Aamir Khan, A Muslim, In Mahabharata': Javed Akhtar Responds To Trolls

[Shahzaz ud din]

Can you read ? THIS IS the Bani Hashmi tribe.

Krishna was born into the Yadava Clan, and its pretty well known in India.

Also none of his children made it beyond the kali yuga as per his wish.

where it is written that these guys are from bani Hashem !!!

 

[Advaitagrata]

THIS is what this tribe look like TODAY. Now its much easier to trace their origin , isn't it ?

where it is written that these guys are from bani Hashem !!!

Bani Rahsheed were offshoots of the Bani Hashem tribe.

 

[Shahzaz ud din]

THIS is what this tribe look like TODAY. Now its much easier to trace their origin , isn't it ?

Bani Rahsheed were offshoots of the Bani Hashem tribe.

WTF offshoot
Currently Bani Hashim does not exist in KSA. With the invasion of house of Saud they all migrated to Syria,Yemen,Iraq and Jordan

The Hashemites (Arabic: الهاشميون‎, Al-Hāshimīyūn; also House of Hashem) is the ruling royal family of Jordan. The House was also the royal family of Syria (1920), Hejaz (1916–1925) and Iraq (1921–1958). The family belongs to the Dhawu Awn, one of the branches of the Hasanid Sharifs of Mecca – also referred to as Hashemites – who ruled Mecca continuously from the 10th century until its conquest by the House of Saud in 1924. Their eponymous ancestor is Hashim ibn Abd Manaf, great-grandfather of the Islamic prophet, Muhammad.

The current dynasty was founded by Sharif Hussein ibn Ali, who was appointed as Sharif and Emir of Mecca by Sultan Abdul Hamid II in 1908, then in 1916 was proclaimed King of the Arab Lands (but only recognized as King of the Hejaz) after initiating the Arab Revolt against the Ottoman Empire. His sons Abdullah and Faisal assumed the thrones of Jordan and Iraq in 1921. The dynasty is the oldest ruling dynasty in the Islamic World, and the second-oldest in the world.[1]

 

[fitpOsitive]

Amir khan is an Indian, and let Indians resolve this matter the way they like. None of our business. The muslims who choose to remain in India back in 1947 are themselves responsible for what is happening with them now.

 

[Advaitagrata]

WTF offshoot
Currently Bani Hashim does not exist in KSA. With the invasion of house of Saud they all migrated to Syria,Yemen,Iraq and Jordan

The Hashemites (Arabic: الهاشميون‎, Al-Hāshimīyūn; also House of Hashem) is the ruling royal family of Jordan. The House was also the royal family of Syria (1920), Hejaz (1916–1925) and Iraq (1921–1958). The family belongs to the Dhawu Awn, one of the branches of the Hasanid Sharifs of Mecca – also referred to as Hashemites – who ruled Mecca continuously from the 10th century until its conquest by the House of Saud in 1924. Their eponymous ancestor is Hashim ibn Abd Manaf, great-grandfather of the Islamic prophet, Muhammad.

The current dynasty was founded by Sharif Hussein ibn Ali, who was appointed as Sharif and Emir of Mecca by Sultan Abdul Hamid II in 1908, then in 1916 was proclaimed King of the Arab Lands (but only recognized as King of the Hejaz) after initiating the Arab Revolt against the Ottoman Empire. His sons Abdullah and Faisal assumed the thrones of Jordan and Iraq in 1921. The dynasty is the oldest ruling dynasty in the Islamic World, and the second-oldest in the world.[1]

So basically all the rulers in the M.E magically trace their lineage to the prophet Muhammed , while the original tribes who are the ruled, have no real claim on a member of their tribe.

Yup, sounds totally true.

Exactly like the rulers of burma, cambodia, Thailand, vietnam etc. who trace their lineage back to Sri Ram or Buddha.

 

[Shahzaz ud din]

LOL..... you seem positively offended that your prophet was a darkie.

What happened to islamic "brotherhood" ?

Arabs were barely civilized people living in a freaking desert, and they often married into the Africans. This is recorded history. That is why most of their kids looked the people in the pictures.

I don't you why you have difficulty in believing what is in front of you.

These pictures are from 1932.Do you think these people look like members of the royal family.Since 10th century this tribe ruled over Hijaz(KSA) ,syria,Iraq and Jordan

 

[Advaitagrata]

These pictures are from 1932.Do you think these people look like members of the royal family.Since 10th century this tribe ruled over Hijaz(KSA) ,syria,Iraq and Jordan

These pictures provide a realistic picture of what your prophet looked like.

Contrary to popular belief (among almost all muslims), Muhammad was neither a Hanifi nor was he different from the rest of his clan, Quraysh.

He was just a normal human like others, following the very complex faith that existed in Macca at that time. That is: the intermingled version of Zorostrianism, Christianity, and Judaism. Which essentially was a henotheistic religion. Although Quraysh believed in one High God: Allah (the creator god) but like all other high gods, they did not expect anyone to consult him directly. For that there were other gods: Given the status of Ka'bah as a sanctuary for all gods, Quraysh had to acknowledge or at least be open to the possibility of existence of other gods, hence the henothesim.

The evidence that Muhammad was not a hanifi comes from one of the little known traditions (among some other evidences) of the encounter of young Muhammad with Zayd ibn Amr, who was one of the founding members of Hanifism movement.

When Muahammad was coming back from Ta'if after taking part in one of the sacrificial rituals to gods of that time where he met Zayd and offered him some meat (of sacrificed animal). Zayd's response was that he wouldn't eat the meat that was slaughtered in the name of false gods since he believed in only one God: The god of Abraham.

Other than this encounter, It is an established fact that Muhammad used to go on devotional retreats (where he received his revelation as well) which was a common practice of pagal arabia, called Tahannuth. Moreover, he also used to perform the religious ritual of circumambulating the Ka‘ba (7 complete circles of the sanctuary). It was one of the very common rituals among Quraysh at that time. Muslims still follow this during their pilgrimage to Ka'bah.

The fact that Muhammad was deeply involved in all these rituals clearly shows that he followed the religion of Quraysh. The concept of Muhammad following the same religion as Quraysh, before Islam, is difficult to digest for Muslims.

 

[thesolar65]

These pictures provide a realistic picture of what your prophet looked like.

Contrary to popular belief (among almost all muslims), Muhammad was neither a Hanifi nor was he different from the rest of his clan, Quraysh.

He was just a normal human like others, following the very complex faith that existed in Macca at that time. That is: the intermingled version of Zorostrianism, Christianity, and Judaism. Which essentially was a henotheistic religion. Although Quraysh believed in one High God: Allah (the creator god) but like all other high gods, they did not expect anyone to consult him directly. For that there were other gods: Given the status of Ka'bah as a sanctuary for all gods, Quraysh had to acknowledge or at least be open to the possibility of existence of other gods, hence the henothesim.

The evidence that Muhammad was not a hanifi comes from one of the little known traditions (among some other evidences) of the encounter of young Muhammad with Zayd ibn Amr, who was one of the founding members of Hanifism movement.

When Muahammad was coming back from Ta'if after taking part in one of the sacrificial rituals to gods of that time where he met Zayd and offered him some meat (of sacrificed animal). Zayd's response was that he wouldn't eat the meat that was slaughtered in the name of false gods since he believed in only one God: The god of Abraham.

Other than this encounter, It is an established fact that Muhammad used to go on devotional retreats (where he received his revelation as well) which was a common practice of pagal arabia, called Tahannuth. Moreover, he also used to perform the religious ritual of circumambulating the Ka‘ba (7 complete circles of the sanctuary). It was one of the very common rituals among Quraysh at that time. Muslims still follow this during their pilgrimage to Ka'bah.

The fact that Muhammad was deeply involved in all these rituals clearly shows that he followed the religion of Quraysh. The concept of Muhammad following the same religion as Quraysh, before Islam, is difficult to digest for Muslims.

link please. want to know more.

 

[Advaitagrata]

link please. want to know more.

I think its mentioned in Malik Muwatta Hadith

 

[naveen mishra]

Amir should make movie about

• Jinnah "The Great Leader"
  
• Mohammad Bin Qasim
  
• Any Mogal Empirors
  
• Tipu Sultan
• Sir Syed , role of education in region
• Edhi
• Bhutto
• Free Kashmir for Pakistan
• Amir the UK boxer here is a nice project
• Salah Ud Din Ayubi , Liberator of Jerusalam . Release it also in Israel if you want

lot of projects

Just don't understand logic to portray a religious Indian thing specially with all the negative sentiment existing in that country , playing with tense fire

He is being disrespectful Amir should know better

Playing a wrestler vs Religious figure are two drastic extremes ...

nothing is going to happen , in past also many character play by Muslim in Mahabharata TV serial , in last two mega project Hindi serial Mahabharata Arjuna was played by Muslim actor

 

[Advaitagrata]

nothing is going to happen , in past also many character play by Muslim in Mahabharata TV serial , in last two mega project Hindi serial Mahabharata Arjuna was played by Muslim actor

Its not about the actors religion, but about his suitability for that role.

Amir Khan is NOT suitable for the role of Krishna. They should really consider Milind Soman for the role of Krishna. He will fit in perfectly.

 

[thesolar65]

These pictures are from 1932.Do you think these people look like members of the royal family.Since 10th century this tribe ruled over Hijaz(KSA) ,syria,Iraq and Jordan

Wish we could have time machine before we die. So that we can go back take a pic oh him and every body to see how he looks like. And we can solve many more mysteries.