A serious question to pakistanis

[Zibago]

The media,s projection of Pakistan is not reflective of the ground realities of Pakistan

 

[SleepingLion]

Voilent protests over the stupid youtube video & chalie hebdo's cartoons in Pakistan & getting productive tool(Youtube) banned for 3 years straight. Destroying & burning state's properties . What was that for if the culprits didn't live & breath in Pakistan?

The youtube ban was from PTCL to save their bandwidth as internet prices are too low in Pakistan and giving away unlimited packages for like $10 was not profitable for them.

 

[thrilainmanila]

pakistanis are probably the most hospitable, but lets be honest, not many foreigners visit the country if you compare it to other countries, but those that do are valued and treated like part of the family, there is a great love for islam, because it is an underdeveloped country, ppl struggle daily and need religion in there life as a source of inspiration and to try and move forward, the issue is when they feel like this has been threatened they'll become over emotional and go to extreme lengths killing, murdering, raping and destroying, even though islam clearly forbids any of the stated, ppl feel there Love for Allah And the Prophet (SAW) is enough to carry out such actions.

 

[Skies]

I have this same question!

Whenever I observe Pakistani rites and cultures in songs, TV and Dramas, I find them very modern, smart, stylish, educated and liberal. But in newspaper, they often look as if they live in stone age!

 

[Imran Khan]

I have this same question!

Whenever I observe Pakistani rites and cultures in song, TV and Dramas, I find them very modern, smart, stylish, educated and liberal. But in newspaper they often look as if they live in stone age.

very simple news need attention and there is no short of crimes and stories in 190mn public . can you line up and educate 190mn people ? every society have issues so pakistan does .

 

[jupiter2007]

I heard (OK read) many times on this forum from pakistanis that pakistan is much liberal country than portrayed on media. To be honest there might be some truth to it..otherwise you don't celebrate Sufis and songs of bulle shah(which sometimes criticises mullahs and extremists)..I also noticed that burkha culture is much less in pakistan when compared to india(my observation after watching common women on number of pakistani news channels).
However, the killing of Punjab governor and veneration of that killer, judges scared to even give out judgements give a completely different picture of pakistan. When did this degeneration in pakistan start? Or was there this extremism always present in pakistan but was out in open only recently?

I remember reading exactly mumtaz qadri like incident a while back . Arya samajis published a book called rangeela rasool in 1927. The publisher was killed by a young man named ilmuddin..British government sent him to gallows..some lakhs of people attended his funeral in Lahore(including Iqbal)..This incident shows there was extremism in pakistan even before independence (after this incident British govt formulated blasphemy law)

What is true?Has pakistan always been a society run by extremism and it's advocates or is it only a recent phenomena?

Pakistan is very liberal country and you can see this from our tv shows and in-fact it's a true reflection of what people practice.

Islam as a religious is only practice by handful of people and majority of people are confused about what is real Islam. They are confused about the real message of peace and love in the teaching of Prophet Muhammad (saw). They argue and fight each other on minutest differences.

Among those who practice Islam, we have two sides, one side is extremely conservative in their approach to Islam and take everything literally, other are those who practice a form of mysticism, and these are Sufis (not same as Barelvis, Sufi can be Shafi, Maliki, Hanafi and Hanbali fiqh, example: Abdul-Qadir Gilani (r.a) followed Hanbali fiqh), Shia (Ithna'Ashariyah, Agakhani, Mustaali Bohra and Sulaimani Bohra) and Barelvis (follow Sunni Hanafi fiqh but some practices might be questionable).

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

pakistanis are probably the most hospitable, but lets be honest, not many foreigners visit the country if you compare it to other countries, but those that do are valued and treated like part of the family, there is a great love for islam, because it is an underdeveloped country, ppl struggle daily and need religion in there life as a source of inspiration and to try and move forward, the issue is when they feel like this has been threatened they'll become over emotional and go to extreme lengths killing, murdering, raping and destroying, even though islam clearly forbids any of the stated, ppl feel there Love for Allah And the Prophet (SAW) is enough to carry out such actions.

Underdeveloped??????????........it's not us that has around during 40% of the ENTIRE Earth's severely malnourished and extreme poor:

http://m.firstpost.com/india/shocke...t-of-worlds-malnourished-children-916359.html

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-india-28735449

The above is what you call severe underdevelopment. Until the above is resolved, indians are not in a position to comment about Pakistan or any other country for that the matter.

 

[I S I]

The youtube ban was from PTCL to save their bandwidth as internet prices are too low in Pakistan and giving away unlimited packages for like $10 was not profitable for them.

 

[Khan_patriot]

Mind your own damned business, we don't have to explain ourselves to anyone, go build yourselves some toilets and stop molesting every woman you see.
Condescending yahoo

 

[Verve]

I heard (OK read) many times on this forum from pakistanis that pakistan is much liberal country than portrayed on media. To be honest there might be some truth to it..otherwise you don't celebrate Sufis and songs of bulle shah(which sometimes criticises mullahs and extremists)..I also noticed that burkha culture is much less in pakistan when compared to india(my observation after watching common women on number of pakistani news channels).
However, the killing of Punjab governor and veneration of that killer, judges scared to even give out judgements give a completely different picture of pakistan. When did this degeneration in pakistan start? Or was there this extremism always present in pakistan but was out in open only recently?

I remember reading exactly mumtaz qadri like incident a while back . Arya samajis published a book called rangeela rasool in 1927. The publisher was killed by a young man named ilmuddin..British government sent him to gallows..some lakhs of people attended his funeral in Lahore(including Iqbal)..This incident shows there was extremism in pakistan even before independence (after this incident British govt formulated blasphemy law)

What is true?Has pakistan always been a society run by extremism and it's advocates or is it only a recent phenomena?

Gandhi was killed by those elements who are now ruling India. I think the questions you've posed will have better answers if applied to India.

Indra Gandhi killed by Sikhs, Rajeev Gandhi killed by Tamils. Modi sarkar killing and raping thousands Muslims. List is longer.

 

[GURU DUTT]

Gandhi was killed by those elements who are now ruling India. I think the questions you've posed will have better answers if applied to India.

Indra Gandhi killed by Sikhs, Rajeev Gandhi killed by Tamils. Modi sarkar killing and raping thousands Muslims. List is longer.

that shows how much you know about india ghandi was killed by nathu rame godse WHO WAS FROM HINDU MAHA SABHA

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akhil_Bharatiya_Hindu_Mahasabha

(as he was angry with ghandi policy to give pakistan a proposed passage/corridoor 40 miles wide from east to west pakistan after all the blood shed and a war that happenned after ghandi sat on hunger strike and gave pakistani its share of seppration money )

while NaMo is from RSS

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rashtriya_Swayamsevak_Sangh

rest keep blaberring

 

[B+ Dracula]

I have this same question!

Whenever I observe Pakistani rites and cultures in songs, TV and Dramas, I find them very modern, smart, stylish, educated and liberal. But in newspaper, they often look as if they live in stone age!

Ghussa dekhaoo gay to Khoon Sir pa lay lay ga.....Pyar say manoo gay tu Jan bhi de de ga

 

[Verve]

that shows how much you know about india ghandi was killed by nathu rame godse WHO WAS FROM HINDU MAHA SABHA

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akhil_Bharatiya_Hindu_Mahasabha

(as he was angry with ghandi policy to give pakistan a proposed passage/corridoor 40 miles wide from east to west pakistan after all the blood shed and a war that happenned after ghandi sat on hunger strike and gave pakistani its share of seppration money )

while NaMo is from RSS

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rashtriya_Swayamsevak_Sangh

rest keep blaberring

Either way, my point was that Indians killing prominent Indians is recorded in history. Countrymen kill each other for all sorts of reasons. Before raising the question on Pakistan, Indiana should 'learn' to pose the same question about themselves.

 

[GURU DUTT]

Either way, my point was that Indians killing prominent Indians is recorded in history. Countrymen kill each other for all sorts of reasons. Before raising the question on Pakistan, Indiana should 'learn' to pose the same question about themselves.

no you are confused and ignorent about history first get to know the right historical facts then give your opinion ... GOT IT ?

 

[Verve]

no you are confused and ignorent about history first get to know the right historical facts then give your opinion ... GOT IT ?

All three Gandhis were killed by Indian citizens (& non-muslims), got that?