A political solution for Kashmir and lasting peace for India and Pakistan

[Joe Shearer]

Inter-caste marriage occurs in India but this is still a taboo. Less then 5% of marriages in India are Inter-caste.

What is wrong with 5%? You started by denying the possibility, and now it has come to this most unsatisfactory state of affairs.

I will ensure that the GOI Secretary responsible for promoting inter-caste marriages has his services terminated forthwith.

Inter-caste marriage occurs in India but this is still a taboo. Less then 5% of marriages in India are Inter-caste. Most likely in individuals that are secular and not too devote.

Two of my own uncles, father's brothers, married outside our caste. There is a large number of cousins who have done this.

 

[925boy]

We've had 73 years. The religiosity and animosity has spiked. It's an unnatural union. Muslims and Hindus can't exist together.

Um....yea. I wonder if its also down to /mainly /considerably about polytheism vs monotheism...hmm...

That is why the Kashmiris must be convinced of a progressive system

...ok.....

that originated in a Muslim-majority land.

...hmmm.....isnt this indirectly implying Sharia law? I dont see how Kashmiris will live in a Western style "democratic" or "progressive" govt locally. what do you even really mean by "progressive"? these terms have to be clarified so we all know do the best degree possible what you mean by those words in this situation. cheers.

 

[niaz]

Sir,

A nice solution, But did you take the FATA into account ? The Birth of TTP ?

Kulbashan, RSS, Hindutva Hate prospering country wide ?

Your solution is a very good and easy one but not practical now, Time has passed, India’s hate for Pakistan isn’t just Kashmir, Kashmir is the least of the India’s hate triggers.

I do not deny that your argument has a sound basis but just think about the alternatives.

India would b quite happy if we accept the LOC as the international border; which it is in all but name since 1948, whichever way you look at it. This is definitely not acceptable to the majority of Pakistanis or the Kashmiris.

Agreed that Musharraf's proposal (suggested in my post) would be difficult at this point in time, but tell me honestly, is there any other " Practicable solution?

In the absence of the above, either we live with India in an uneasy truce as we have done for the last 72 years or engage in a war of annihilation with India. If my countrymen are happy with the second option, so be it. However any future war with India would either be inconclusive like the previous conflicts, which would not give us IOK or it could involve the use of nuclear weapons destroying both the countries, making the victory of either party meaningless.

 

[Joe Shearer]

Inter-caste marriage occurs in India but this is still a taboo. Less then 5% of marriages in India are Inter-caste. Most likely in individuals that are secular and not too devote.

Should there be a measure? Should this be monitored and tracked? Or should it just happen or not happen, according to the wishes of the individuals?

 

[925boy]

Please understand what is Iranian genetic composition in 2020 has had liberal epochal infusions of alien blood, Arab, African, Indic, Turkic on 4 broad time period planes.

These are not the same as two genetic pulses detected on Parsis and Irani Zoroastrians.

The older one male and Cypriot, coinciding with Alexander's invasion.

And the more recent one about 44 generations old, female and Indic.

Bottomline, modern day Iranians are mongrelized Persians.

@drmeson your fellow brother in Iranian genetics? enjoy. cheers.

 

[JohnWick]

Uyghurs say the same.

@Beast

 

[padamchen]

@drmeson your fellow brother in Iranian genetics? enjoy. cheers.

Im just a regular physician. With amateur interest.

@Salahuddin Ayyubi is the expert.

 

[925boy]

Im just a regular physician. With amateur interest.

@Salahuddin Ayyubi is the expert.

I know. this guy i tagged really told them who they are. lol.

 

[Beast]

@Beast

Please don't compare. Xinjiang is still autonomous region while Modi has revoked Kashmir right as an autonomous region, imposed curfew and basically make the whole region a prison plus open riot against Muslim encourage by Modi hindu. Did u see that in China?

 

[StormBreaker]

I do not deny that your argument has a sound basis but just think about the alternatives.

India would b quite happy if we accept the LOC as the international border; which it is in all but name since 1948, whichever way you look at it. This is definitely not acceptable to the majority of Pakistanis or the Kashmiris.

Agreed that Musharraf's proposal (suggested in my post) would be difficult at this point in time, but tell me honestly, is there any other " Practicable solution?

In the absence of the above, either we live with India in an uneasy truce as we have done for the last 72 years or engage in a war of annihilation with India. If my countrymen are happy with the second option, so be it. However any future war with India would either be inconclusive like the previous conflicts, which would not give us IOK or it could involve the use of nuclear weapons destroying both the countries, making the victory of either party meaningless.

Sir,

Until the rise of Modi, This solution was (bitter for me to say), but the Only Peaceful solution.

However, Now that it is not about Pak India but Muslims vs Hindutva Fascism, War is inevitable, It will happen sooner or later, To full scale.

 

[CrazyZ]

Sir,

Until the rise of Modi, This solution was (bitter for me to say), but the Only Peaceful solution.

However, Now that it is not about Pak India but Muslims vs Hindutva Fascism, War is inevitable, It will happen sooner or later, To full scale.

Spot on. While I hope for a peaceful settlement the reality is the Kashmir issue will only be settled with blood and iron. Pakistan must attain a certain level of self sustainable development in industry and weaponry then embrace a WW2 style national mobilization where 20%+ of the GDP is devoted to security. Only than can peace in Kashmir be attained. Until we reach that point status quo should remain.

 

[StormBreaker]

Spot on. While I hope for a peaceful settlement the reality is the Kashmir issue will only be settled with blood and iron. Pakistan must attain a certain level of self sustainable development in industry and weaponry then embrace a WW2 style national mobilization where 20%+ of the GDP is devoted to security. Only than can peace in Kashmir be attained. Until we reach that point status quo should remain.

Even a full fledged war isn’t an effective solution, You never know who wins, Who loses or what if Nukes get involved, No one survives...

But a war Will Happen (Don’t think of me as some Ghazwa Hind fanboy, No, The current situation and the rising tensions and the wound left on 27 Feb will not heal up so easily)

What is wrong with 5%? You started by denying the possibility, and now it has come to this most unsatisfactory state of affairs.

I will ensure that the GOI Secretary responsible for promoting inter-caste marriages has his services terminated forthwith.



Two of my own uncles, father's brothers, married outside our caste. There is a large number of cousins who have done this.

People who remain limited to own caste or race are kinda stupid TBH.

I say, Lets explore More,

 

[CrazyZ]

Even a full fledged war isn’t an effective solution, You never know who wins, Who loses or what if Nukes get involved, No one survives...

But a war Will Happen (Don’t think of me as some Ghazwa Hind fanboy, No, The current situation and the rising tensions and the wound left on 27 Feb will not heal up so easily)


People who remain limited to own caste or race are kinda stupid TBH.

I say, Lets explore More,

No guts. No glory. Pakistan military never embraced large scale coordinated warfare in previous conflicts. Our offensives were limited in size, scope, and coordination. 27 Feb was probably the biggest single coordinated attack in PAF's history and look how well that went. If things go bad... there is a plan B.

 

[Joe Shearer]

Even a full fledged war isn’t an effective solution, You never know who wins, Who loses or what if Nukes get involved, No one survives...

But a war Will Happen (Don’t think of me as some Ghazwa Hind fanboy, No, The current situation and the rising tensions and the wound left on 27 Feb will not heal up so easily)


People who remain limited to own caste or race are kinda stupid TBH.

I say, Lets explore More,

Well, all I can say is, been there, done that.

They are. Undoubtedly. And those who aren't stupid have already moved on. Standing and staring at the stupid remainder is unlikely either to make them less stupid, or make the one staring less stupid.

No guts. No glory. Pakistan military never embrace d large scale coordinated warfare in previous conflicts. Our offensives were limited in size, scope, and coordination. 27 Feb was probably the biggest single coordinated attack in PAF's history and look how well that went. If things go bad... there is a plan B.

Ignorance doesn't get washed away by braggadocio.

Look up what Nur Khan did in 1965.

 

[StormBreaker]

No guts. No glory. Pakistan military never embraced large scale coordinated warfare in previous conflicts. Our offensives were limited in size, scope, and coordination. 27 Feb was probably the biggest single coordinated attack in PAF's history and look how well that went. If things go bad... there is a plan B.

PAF has excelled throughout the history, Since it isn’t the primary deciding force, It’s potential is undermined by PA and the Decision Makers.

Trust me, If in a conflicting situation, PAF is given free hand to Conduct independent operations, PAF wouldn't leave any stone unturned to Achieve Air superiority as well as Control over surrounding enemy Air spaces and create a buffer zone.

It is just that land forces business is much more complex and time consuming as well as sensitive to plan that the overall advancement is restricted in a war.