What's new

10 Privileges that PTM Enjoys but Not TLP

PTM is created or let it be to counter PTI in KPK on the basis of MQM which was let free to counter PPP.

Sad state of affairs....

PTI wins two third majority from KPK and FATA

PTM wins two seats only from North and South Waziristan

Pakistani Liberals: PTI is selected and PTM is the real representative of Pakistani Pashtuns

Call Manzoor ,Mohsin, Ali Wazir whatever you want..but not the ordinary followers..

Those who support Mohin, Ali Wazir or Manzoor Gashteen despite knowing their agenda are indeed traitors and I would call them that

Yeah their gullible followers might not deserve such title
 
.
PTM: we would hang army officers. We would kill them. F*ck Pakistani constitution. We won't teach our kids jinnah and iqbal. We would create a new country for pashtuns

Jungibaaz: may be their speeches are anti state. May be.....

:lol:

Don’t misquote me intentionally. That’s dishonest.

I said some of them are anti-state, and said that citing their speeches shouldn’t be used to discredit legitimate grievances of theirs.
 
.
Don’t misquote me intentionally. That’s dishonest.

I said some of them are anti-state, and said that citing their speeches shouldn’t be used to discredit legitimate grievances of theirs.

They are anti state. Not some of them. Ali Wazir, Mohsin Dawar and Manzoor Gashteen. All of them

That is the whole PTM for you. Call them anti state without any ifs and buts. That is what I want from you

As for legitimate grievances. All have legitimate grievances. BLA, MQM even TTP

That doesn't mean we stop ourselves from saying the obvious and let gullible people towards these organizations. We need to counter these organizations with facts instead of hiding the filth that they are
 
.
They are anti state. Not some of them. Ali Wazir, Mohsin Dawar and Manzoor Gashteen. All of them

That is the whole PTM for you. Call them anti state without any ifs and buts. That is what I want from you

As for legitimate grievances. All have legitimate grievances. BLA, MQM even TTP

That doesn't mean we stop ourselves from saying the obvious and let gullible people towards these organizations. We need to counter these organizations with facts instead of hiding the filth that they are

You are reacting to this in a very emotionally charged way. First you need to calm down and assess what is actually being told to you.

I have heard directly from tribals, not just in Waziristan but elsewhere in FATA, their grievances. They were first oppressed by militants and drone strikes, we all believe army was right to conduct operations in FATA and it helped free us from the scourge of TTP and terrorism, but you have to be aware of the cost of military operations. That cost includes militarisation of civilian areas and collateral damage. I won’t say much more here, but I ask you, next time you speak to anyone from affected areas, ask them about what we’re discussing here. If you are lucky, they will be far more open about these issues and speak more freely than I have chosen to speak here.

Pashteen and his movement draw massive crowds among tribals. Many share his sentiment. Will you dismiss them all as anti-state, or lock them up for sedition? I agree that they should not say inflammatory things as they have. But there is no comparison as yet between them and the likes of TTP which you are comparing them to.

You compare them to TTP. Before operations in this area, TTP killed several family members of Pashteen himself, including his elder brother. Their demands now are very simple, they do not like army presence in their lives, you know tribal culture, they dislike checkpoints and indignity subjected on them and on their women, they also want land mines removed. And our agencies, as it has been shown in multiple cases, are fond of “picking up” those they deem trouble makers. They want an end to this and they want all cases investigated. It is not the fault of an ordinary soldier that his presence is causing problems, he is doing his job. Removing some checkpoints is probably a bad idea and will have a cost of its own in terms of making the region vulnerable to militants again.

But these are all things policy makers and the army needs to consider.

And again, as I said before. I used to think exactly like you. There was a member on this very forum a few years back who said what I’m saying now. I thought he was a liar, apologist for militants, or probably some sort of anti-Pakistan Afghan. I’ll repeat what he told me back then before I found out for myself; go and speak to tribals, they’ll tell you thus.
 
.
Fact: I am not a TLP supporter. Never was.

But I can't ignore blatant freedom to abuse Pakistani state, its institutions and its people given to PTM but not given to TLP

Privilege 1: Open Calls to Kill Military officers of Pakistan


Privilege 2: Calls for Mutiny in Pakistan army


Privilege 3: Abusing constitution of Pakistan openly


Privilege 4: Mocking Jinnah and Iqbal openly


Privilege 5: Open calls to hang Pakistani military officers by barb wires at Afghan border


Privilege 6: Calling Punjabis ugly and illegitimate children of the British Army.


View attachment 603282

Privilege 7: Accusing Pak army of killing its own soldiers


Privilege 8: Giving money to children to speak against Pakistani state

https://twitter.com/PaasoonOfficial/status/1183047794959011841

https://twitter.com/Gulalai_Ismail/status/1182925195574677504

Privilege 9: Connecting rape of a 10 year old in Islamabad with Pak army

https://twitter.com/AsharJawad/status/1132597492481167360

Privilege 10: Banning flag of Pakistan from their Jalsas

https://twitter.com/umar8528/status/1222071377089482752

Justice Athar minallah and Pakistani liberals won't have any issues with these privileges

Laikin TLP ya kisi aur darhi walai ko yeh privliege nahi dena

Also me as a Pakistani I don't have privilege to call these guys traitors despite such open proof saying so

This is seminal work.

You and some of the people you've tagged are doing more than the entire national security apparatus combined in terms of narratives.

Please keep it up!
 
.
Summary. The protesters are not Anti Pakistan but Anti Punjabi influence....The guy at 11:04 deosnt even know what the acronym PTM stands for. There's no need to call them Ghaddar and worsen the situation..Most are local Waziris some with Afghan refugee background.
The best way is to start developing ex-FATA to a level that its comparable to Peshawar.And people there are not ready yet for Western corporatocracy so for now we need to manage it locally through national enterprise.Start the health card thing there..Build schools...Rest of Kpk can sacrifice part of its education budget for a year to give this place a boost in building structure .needs to be done while respecting their culture..Also we need more people to people contact between Punjabis and Waziris..It has to start from somewhere, if govt, is not doing anything we can do it an individual level , maybe brainstorm more on this here at pdf.In the longer run South Punjab province needs to be created that creates an equilibrium among all provinces and would be instrumental in venting out the nationalist feelings not just in kpk but sindh and Baluchistan..
I'm absolutely in favor of development because it will address the concerns of the vast majority, and those concerns are absolutely legitemate, but the PTM itself and the mindset of its leadership, core members & even non-Pashtun supporters will never be satisfied with 'development'.

Even if the Tribal areas were developed to the level of Dubai, the PTM would be abusing Pakistan, Fauj & Punjabis claiming that 'these Kalia are taking advantage of us extremely developed, wealthy, beautiful, fair skinned Afghans'.

You just can't win a rational argument with a racist ideology.

The PTM's non-Pashtun supporters are people like Gul Bukhari, Hussain Haqqani etc who even now would support a foreign military attack on Pakistan as well as sanctions - they don't care if the country gets broken up because that would mean the Fauj gets weakened and they can maybe become Hindustani like Adnan Dangar Khan. For them it's not about development, it's about weakening the Fauj and oneness with Hindustan, and that is where they have common cause with the PTM, who's focus is not development as much as it is about racism and a superiority complex over 'daal khors' and 'oneness with Afghanistan'.

But while you can't win an argument with a racist ideology, you can limit the amount of support it gets and that is where the government needs to focus on the development and uplift of the former FATA areas from where the PTM draws most of its support.
 
Last edited:
.
You are reacting to this in a very emotionally charged way. First you need to calm down and assess what is actually being told to you.

I am talking facts. The facts that prove PTM is a fraud

They were first oppressed by militants and drone strikes, we all believe army was right to conduct operations in FATA and it helped free us from the scourge of TTP and terrorism, but you have to be aware of the cost of military operations

You are not only one. Mohsin Dawar used to justify civilian deaths in drone attacks and military operations but is now champion of Pashtun rights today

PTM is full of such flip flops. You are another one of these confused supporters of PTM

You compare them to TTP

They are political wing of TTP. Another proxy of Kabul government

Before operations in this area, TTP killed several family members of Pashteen himself, including his elder brother.

Are you sure?

Because as per a tribal elder Yasir Mehsud Manzoor Gashteen is himself TTP


Not to forget TTP open support for PTM


Also going by logic if TTP killed Manzoor Gashteen elder brother and also kills Pakistan army soldiers then it is joint enemy of both PTM and Pak army but then why PTM tries to white wash crimes of TTP and pin them on Pak army instead

PTM claiming dead militants of TTP as innocents


PTM saying Pak army officers killed at hands of TTP were actually killed by Pak army


PTM accusing Pak army of orchestrating APS attack


If PTM is actually against TTP and manzoor was personally hit by TTP then why PTM is hell bent on pinning crimes of TTP on Pak army?

Any logical reasoning that you can share with me??

you know tribal culture, they dislike checkpoints and indignity subjected on them and on their women

Yeah because those check posts stop them from running their terrorism economy where suicide bombers where available on rent

Anyways checkposts have been reduced anyways

they also want land mines removed

Yeah the landmines planted by TTP but here again PTM accuses army of planting those land mines and not TTP

Yet another example of PTM pinning TTP crime on Pak army. May be PTM hates TTP that is why it pins its crimes on Pak army

Strange "hate" they have for TTP :lol:

But these are all things policy makers and the army needs to consider.

The thing policy makers need to understand that for how long they would allow propaganda against the state on the name of freedom of express. For how long people would get away with running campaigns against the state and that too on tax payers money (example Mohsin and Ali wazir)

I used to think exactly like you.

I don't know and I don't care either

I can't call cr@p as gold like you. That is I am sure about

go and speak to tribals, they’ll tell you thus.

I have

Those who didn't use to benefit from "terrorism economy" of Waziristan have told me a lot about PTM and its leadership. All of them agree that it is a piece of sh!t.

No wonder PTM doesn't win outside Waziristan despite all the support and funding from Afghanistan and our librals like Gul Bukhari

This is seminal work.

You and some of the people you've tagged are doing more than the entire national security apparatus combined in terms of narratives.

Please keep it up!

Just doing my part as a Pakistani even if the state is sleeping

Can't allow a whole ethnic group of my country being fooled to support a secessionist movement on the name of communal rights

Can't see people presenting pile of sh!t as gold and get away with it
 
.
I am talking facts. The facts that prove PTM is a fraud



You are not only one. Mohsin Dawar used to justify civilian deaths in drone attacks and military operations but is now champion of Pashtun rights today

PTM is full of such flip flops. You are another one of these confused supporters of PTM



They are political wing of TTP. Another proxy of Kabul government



Are you sure?

Because as per a tribal elder Yasir Mehsud Manzoor Gashteen is himself TTP


Not to forget TTP open support for PTM


Also going by logic if TTP killed Manzoor Gashteen elder brother and also kills Pakistan army soldiers then it is joint enemy of both PTM and Pak army but then why PTM tries to white wash crimes of TTP and pin them on Pak army instead

PTM claiming dead militants of TTP as innocents


PTM saying Pak army officers killed at hands of TTP were actually killed by Pak army


PTM accusing Pak army of orchestrating APS attack


If PTM is actually against TTP and manzoor was personally hit by TTP then why PTM is hell bent on pinning crimes of TTP on Pak army?

Any logical reasoning that you can share with me??



Yeah because those check posts stop them from running their terrorism economy where suicide bombers where available on rent

Anyways checkposts have been reduced anyways



Yeah the landmines planted by TTP but here again PTM accuses army of planting those land mines and not TTP

Yet another example of PTM pinning TTP crime on Pak army. May be PTM hates TTP that is why it pins its crimes on Pak army

Strange "hate" they have for TTP :lol:



The thing policy makers need to understand that for how long they would allow propaganda against the state on the name of freedom of express. For how long people would get away with running campaigns against the state and that too on tax payers money (example Mohsin and Ali wazir)



I don't know and I don't care either

I can't call cr@p as gold like you. That is I am sure about



I have

Those who didn't use to benefit from "terrorism economy" of Waziristan have told me a lot about PTM and its leadership. All of them agree that it is a piece of sh!t.

No wonder PTM doesn't win outside Waziristan despite all the support and funding from Afghanistan and our librals like Gul Bukhari



Just doing my part as a Pakistani even if the state is sleeping

Can't allow a whole ethnic group of my country being fooled to support a secessionist movement on the name of communal rights

Can't see people presenting pile of sh!t as gold and get away with it

Very well said!
 
.
Racist ideals can’t hide forever behind whatever justification provided. Be it some MQM terrorist generalizations or calling all migrants Gangus. It only reflects on their family values and adds to the narrative of Pakistan being a failed state.
By inferring to descendants of migrants who aren’t from Punjab as second class , they essentially help the enemies of Pakistan.

This culture you talk about is deep rooted in our society and Military establishment unfortunately, thing is we created the monsters like Manzoor and Altaf, and once they start doing what they were created for they become traitors and liabilities to the state and needs to be disposed , You can see a systematic racism against migrants against the so called Sons of Soil here on PDF which is been promoted by some Moderators .
 
. .
You are reacting to this in a very emotionally charged way. First you need to calm down and assess what is actually being told to you.

I have heard directly from tribals, not just in Waziristan but elsewhere in FATA, their grievances. They were first oppressed by militants and drone strikes, we all believe army was right to conduct operations in FATA and it helped free us from the scourge of TTP and terrorism, but you have to be aware of the cost of military operations. That cost includes militarisation of civilian areas and collateral damage. I won’t say much more here, but I ask you, next time you speak to anyone from affected areas, ask them about what we’re discussing here. If you are lucky, they will be far more open about these issues and speak more freely than I have chosen to speak here.

Pashteen and his movement draw massive crowds among tribals. Many share his sentiment. Will you dismiss them all as anti-state, or lock them up for sedition? I agree that they should not say inflammatory things as they have. But there is no comparison as yet between them and the likes of TTP which you are comparing them to.

You compare them to TTP. Before operations in this area, TTP killed several family members of Pashteen himself, including his elder brother. Their demands now are very simple, they do not like army presence in their lives, you know tribal culture, they dislike checkpoints and indignity subjected on them and on their women, they also want land mines removed. And our agencies, as it has been shown in multiple cases, are fond of “picking up” those they deem trouble makers. They want an end to this and they want all cases investigated. It is not the fault of an ordinary soldier that his presence is causing problems, he is doing his job. Removing some checkpoints is probably a bad idea and will have a cost of its own in terms of making the region vulnerable to militants again.

But these are all things policy makers and the army needs to consider.

And again, as I said before. I used to think exactly like you. There was a member on this very forum a few years back who said what I’m saying now. I thought he was a liar, apologist for militants, or probably some sort of anti-Pakistan Afghan. I’ll repeat what he told me back then before I found out for myself; go and speak to tribals, they’ll tell you thus.

Lmao ... What a shit *** argument.

An overwhelming majority of terrorist and suicide attacks were done by a single ethnicity and that too belonging from a specific areas. Using the same logic, how about we level the areas of tribes that were involved in killing 70K+ pakistani ?

As far as the grievances are concerned , well, it is a war zone and until and unless resistance and insurgency is not over , army should not pull out. We don't want these thugs and goons to reach Islamabad. I still remember how these thugs belonging to one particular ethnicity had captured Swat and were marching towards Islamabad.

Also , tribal people need to come out of the abstract and subjective definitions of dignity ... Check points and land mines are part and parcel of violence. Had these tribal not killed Pakistanis , none of that would have happened.

Isn't it funny that after killing 30k+ of these terrorist ( majority of them Pashtuns) , there was 89% reduction in terrorist attacks all over Pakistan....

FATA has been a source of Problem for a very long time. People are still stuck in 19th century with their darconian customs and foolish sense of pride and dignity. Bringing them to 21st century is necessary for us to proper as a nation.

Also , a lot of jews were killed in holocaust. Look what they are doing to Palestinians.....Just like Jews , Fata people have displaced their anger from taliban to Pakistan.
 
.
FATA has been a source of Problem for a very long time.

FATA in general isn't a problem. It is Waziristan that is problematic

Just like in the case of TTP, fitna of PTM also has started from Waziristan

That is why I am opposing PTM so strongly.

Because our liberals are hell bent on making PTM representative of every Pakistani pashtun which it clearly isn't
 
.
FATA in general isn't a problem. It is Waziristan that is problematic

Just like in the case of TTP, fitna of PTM also has started from Waziristan

That is why I am opposing PTM so strongly.

Because our liberals are hell bent on making PTM representative of every Pakistani pashtun which it clearly isn't

Not just Waziristan but whole of FATA... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tehrik-i-Taliban_Pakistan

Also , Manzoor Pashteen aka Manzoor Mehsud belongs to the same tribe from which all taliban leadership came from. The current leader of TTP is a mehsud.

We need to be clear in defining the enemy. It is the FATA people in the form of TTP who are source of 95% of all terrorism in Pakistan. I am not going to be politically correct here.
 
.
why ? Because MQM is mostly consist of Urdu speaking people and PTM is Mostly Pashtoon ? oh yes Sons of Soils vs Indian Immigrants ..



Irony of this land, one ethnicity get away with treason , murder , terrorism , anti state while the other is branded Muhajir and prove your loyalties for less ..
U need to look at what u are saying, MQM has been given there due share of lenience, maybe too much in the past, they had our economical hub by the balls and had to be handled when they grew out of propotion, as i said dont make this about ethinicity, pashtoon areas were bombed and dealt with an iron hand in zarb e azab or have u forgotten that? i am niether a pashtoon nor an urdu speaker so i have no alliegence to either of these so called ethinic groups, TTP was a predominately pashtoon group which was dealt with just as MQM was dealth with, PTM is a different story, it is a cancer that seeks to survive on a narrative of wrongs done to pashtoons, they seek to feed of the destruction caused in the wake of the WOT in tribal areas hence we need to deal with them more smartly.

FATA in general isn't a problem. It is Waziristan that is problematic

Just like in the case of TTP, fitna of PTM also has started from Waziristan

That is why I am opposing PTM so strongly.

Because our liberals are hell bent on making PTM representative of every Pakistani pashtun which it clearly isn't
It is the fault of our politicians for letting FATA remain no mans land since partition, we should have brought them to the mainstream and merged them with KPK decades ago and this problem wouldnt even exist, we have been dealing with these guys with colonial era draconion laws since 1947 for heavens sake, for them the British never left, atleast now we have smartend up, i guess "der aye durust aye". Dealing with internal threats is much more complicated that fighting an enemy overseas. It takes a delicate touch because the consequences of acts done in haste and as a result of natural instinct can haunt us for decades to come.
 
Last edited:
.
Isn't it funny that after killing 30k+ of these terrorist ( majority of them Pashtuns) , there was 89% reduction in terrorist attacks all over Pakistan....
You have to be careful not to conflate all Pashtun or even all Tribal Pashtun with the minority that joined the TTP. And the blame for so many joining the TTP also lies across the board, not just with the people of the Tribal areas. In my view, the power structure in the Tribal areas was ready for a strong, brutal entity like the TTP to step in and overthrow. The Tribal leaders were targeted one by one and the TTP, in contrast to the fractured tribes, was able to put up enough unified force in specific areas to overrun any local opposition. Even the pro-government Lashkar's were not always able to ward off the TTP long term without Army assistance.

That said, I don't agree with giving the PTM an ounce of sympathy or understanding - they are, as I mentioned in my earlier post, an ideologically racist and separatist movement that see themselves as closer to Afghanistan than Pakistan, and no amount of development and uplift in FATA is going to change racism - that is who they are and who they will always be. The focus should be on making sure that the number of Pashtun the PTM can exploit in support of its cause is minimized as much as possible, and with those ordinary Pashtun, it IS development, reconstruction and uplift that will make the difference.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom