Zakir Naik: Pakistan should not have been created

[salarsikander]

His views are personal and there's no reason to insult him for that. The guys is a gem and politics is certainly not his cup of tea

 

[MAS9]

His views are personal and there's no reason to insult him for that. The guys is a gem and politics is certainly not his cup of tea

I respect your views. But a person with large no. of followers should know what to say. Otherwise he should remain quite.

 

[salarsikander]

I respect your views. But a person with large no. of followers should know what to say. Otherwise he should remain quite.

Its OK. Its not like denying the very existence of Pakistan makes one non Muslim.
Perhaps he said in the context of sacrifices that were made. The loss of live in both sides.
Honestly speaking nheres not a single person in whole of Pakistan qualified enough like him.

He's indeed a gem of Indian Muslim crown

 

[MAS9]

We in India are glad the partition took place. It would have been better for all of those involved if the partition was taken to completion in 1947: pakistan for muslims and India for non-muslims.

What about the akhand bharat hotheads?

 

[Basel]

but still we would have been powerful enough to make them suffer too. together with dalits and moaist we could have ruled on india for another thousand years.

It's only a delusion, because Muslims will be scattered minority with low life quality.

We in India are glad the partition took place. It would have been better for all of those involved if the partition was taken to completion in 1947: pakistan for muslims and India for non-muslims.

If you are so glad then why you won't let go Muslim majority Kashmir??

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Na ghar ka na ghat ka

THANK Bhagwaan and Mr. Jinnah for IR Pakistan.

If we would have been with india then we could have easily forced them to do whatever we wanted.

True, Dharmic peoples would have been wiped out by now. Or reduced to small pockets of strength. Like in the 17th century (before the backlash).

may be but i think those who opposed Pakistan and those who supported Pakistan all were sincere to muslims but were thinking differently.

True.

 

[Basel]

We, the majority of India, don't want anymore muslims in our country. Why would we want to purposely annex 500 million more of them?



If we could give away Kashmir with the stipulation you have to accept all our muslims we would gladly sign on the dotted line.

Give back what you have occupied since 1947 along with Kashmir and we can take all Muslims in Pakistan and send all non Muslims to India.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

His views are personal and there's no reason to insult him for that. The guys is a gem and politics is certainly not his cup of tea

Well, my view is Zakir's dad should have practiced 'safe sex' - that way he would not have been created. Now that is my very personal view.

Give back what you have occupied since 1947 along with Kashmir and we can take all Muslims in Pakistan and send all non Muslims to India.

Why? You want to turn all of Pakistan into a huge ethnic battlefield like Karachi? The best revenge India could give Pakistan is export another 30 million Muslims to Pakistan and watch how Pak would implode into a ethnic war and chaos. Send 100 million and Pak would suffer a catastrophic break up within months. That is a fact.

Ps. Find which province would agree to take in 100 million migrants from India or take share of that burden? Sindh? K-P? Punjab? Balochistan?

 

[SarthakGanguly]

we can take all Muslims in Pakistan and send all non Muslims to India.

Still no Kashmir for you.

give away Kashmir with the stipulation you have to accept all our muslims we would gladly sign on the dotted line.

You are free to give away your birthplace. My homeland is not for barter.

 

[Basel]

Well, my view is Zakir's dad should have practiced 'safe sex' - that way he would not have been created. Now that is my very personal view.

Why? You want to turn all of Pakistan into a huge ethnic battlefield like Karachi? The best revenge India could give Pakistan is export another 30 million Muslims to Pakistan and watch how Pak would implode into a ethnic war and chaos. Send 100 million and Pak would suffer a catastrophic break up within months. That is a fact.

Before opening your mouth put ethnic mind set behind and put Pakistan first, and Google the map of occupied areas India have since 1947 which went with Pakistan, KPK is very small in size compared to those areas.

 

[abhishekgoel80]

S

And now same hindu baniya from Pakistan control India economy. They got much bigger market for themselves only.

So today I got the root cause of problem. It is hatred Pak has for Hindu Bania. (They are currently running the worlds economy to counter them they are importing chinese)
in past I was of opinion that PAK army is the cancerous problem.

 

[Khanate]

Still no Kashmir for you.

Except Azad Kashmir, of course.

 

[Kabira]

We in India are glad the partition took place. It would have been better for all of those involved if the partition was taken to completion in 1947: pakistan for muslims and India for non-muslims.

Nehru played double game. Facade of secularism helped Hindu India retain many areas with majority non-hindus. British officials at that time were at bed with cunning Nehru/Hindus.

Ideally there should have been 7 Pakistans out of Hindustan.

even more drastic version of this map was needed. Nothing is lost yet, 180 million Indian muslims can make another Pakistan in coming decades or even 100 years from now.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Stop being so selfish and think of the greater good.

NOPE. Not one step more.

 

[Basel]

Stop being so selfish and think of the greater good.



You can have Kashmir, we will talk Haseena into reuniting bangladesh, we will accept all non-muslims.

Not Talking about BD you can keep it, I m talking about Hyderabad, Junagarh states and other areas.