Zakir Naik: Pakistan should not have been created

[SrNair]

Only few thousand hindus have gone to India. We on the other hand have received millions of illegal Indian muslims migrants till 90's.

Not few thousand .But millions of them.

Do you have any proof to validate your claim?

 

[saurav jha]

Land was solution before and it will be solution in future. People in north west british raj got their freedom along with in east bengal. But there should have been Israel like solution for 200 million Indian muslims. Give them huge piece of land somewhere along coast and ask them to migrate there while hindus leave and occupy muslim areas.

This is how I see it in 100 years down the road. For people religion comes first so conflict will continue because of hindutvas ruling Delhi.

As I told you earlier any more land is out of question. We have already lost our land. We will not loose an inch more at any cost. We will find another solution. Right now we control military, police etc. So we are in better position if Indian muslims revolt which they will do eventually.

 

[Jackdaws]

Only few thousand hindus have gone to India. We on the other hand have received millions of illegal Indian muslims migrants till 90's.

Source?

 

[Kabira]

As I told you earlier any more land is out of question. We have already lost our land. We will not loose an inch more at any cost. We will find another solution. Right now we control military, police etc. So we are in better position if Indian muslims revolt which they will do eventually.

You didn't loss any land. It was our land all along. Similarly Indian muslims are living in their own land and Israel like solution is needed to give them huge piece of continues land as per their population number at that time when it happens. You can't control few Kashmiris now imagine 500 millions in 100 years from now.

RSS are pushing Indian muslims to the wall, revolt should be expected sooner or later.

 

[saurav jha]

You didn't loss any land. It was our land all along. Similarly Indian muslims are living in their own land and Israel like solution is needed to give them huge piece of continues land as per their population number at that time when it happens. You can't control few Kashmiris now imagine 500 millions in 100 years from now.

RSS are pushing Indian muslims to the wall, revolt should be expected sooner or later.

Agree with red part. For other part of your post I have already explained in my previous post.

 

[Khanate]

On topic:
Pakistan is the best thing happened in sub continent .We will protect our minorities .
And will always made us proud.

All the evidence suggests, you're going to use Indian minorities as human shields or force them out of India like Zakir Naik. Indeed, Pakistan is the best thing to have happened to South Asia.

Yup.
Do you know how many of them took refuge in India?How many of them applied for our citizenship?.
How many from our minorities applied for refuge or citizenship in Pakistan?
Do you have any statistics?

20,000 from Kashmir alone. @Zibago

He is right, You see Pakistan is created for some stupid religious thing, and when atheism takes over in Pakistan, like it will all around the world, Pakistan will be the biggest loser of all time, Because they are making enemies with all of their neighbors for some religious reasons for sake of a country 2500 Kms away from them.

You must be a hormonal teenager if you think atheism can ever put a dent in tribalism — an inescapable fact of human neurology.

 

[SrNair]

All the evidence suggests, you're going to use Indian minorities as human shields or force them out of India like Zakir Naik. Indeed, Pakistan is the best thing to have happened to South Asia.

20,000 from Kashmir alone. @Zibago





You must be a hormonal teenager if you think atheism can ever put a dent in tribalism — an inescapable fact of human neurology.

So your are saying that the Major Gogoi should have given an order to kill all those natives?

20000 from Kashmir majority of them return as terrorists and bit the dust.

 

[kasper95]

Poor zakir naik can't come back so he is saying this to win over hindu hardliners from india.

Last thing any Indian will want is uniting Pakistan with india .these statements will only make the hardliners even mad.

Pakistan thumay Mubarak

You didn't loss any land. It was our land all along. Similarly Indian muslims are living in their own land and Israel like solution is needed to give them huge piece of continues land as per their population number at that time when it happens. You can't control few Kashmiris now imagine 500 millions in 100 years from now.

RSS are pushing Indian muslims to the wall, revolt should be expected sooner or later.

Don't post what you wish for ,there are still some Muslims there who can still live peacefully with others.

 

[ziaulislam]

he is right. muslims in india were left. Pakistan was broken and muslims were further divided.
If we would have been with india then we could have easily forced them to do whatever we wanted. we could have easily won elections in many indian provinces and then through their assemblies founded a new state called Pakistan with much bigger area and more provinces.
But Pakistan is what Allah wanted and it may have been for a reason.

1.wrong, clearly you need education in politics and demographics, do you think Jinnah was stupid, he was a genious

2.you couldn't get independence later, the thing what you mention was the 1946 cabinet mission that PML accepted but congress rejected (single dominion, with state having the right for independence after 10yrs).
do you think kashmir can win independence ?

3. if single india would have happened, within a few years they would abolished provinces and changed the demography(like joining sindh and rajistan ) and would have banned beef. agriculutre would have suffered in muslim parts and florished in hindu areas, demographics would have further deteriorated with high mortality rates in muslim area and extreme poverty in muslim areas

4. per 1940 resolutions the plan was to create multiple muslim states in majority of provinces that would ensure 70-80% of population being self ruled, what went wrong was the last minute vice roy having wife having an affair with nehru, otherwise whole punjab and assam, bengal(and thus kashmir by default) would have been part of pakistan thus leaving less than 10 % of population in india, unfortunately red cliff happened and PML with protest accepted the plan because jinnah knew the alternative was worse

5. Bangladesh becoming independent doesnt harm Muslims or the ideology of Pakistan. infact the original 1940 accord called for multiple states(2 infact) this was changed only in 1946 dehli accord

 

[kasper95]

All the evidence suggests, you're going to use Indian minorities as human shields or force them out of India like Zakir Naik. Indeed, Pakistan is the best thing to have happened to South Asia.

20,000 from Kashmir alone. @Zibago





You must be a hormonal teenager if you think atheism can ever put a dent in tribalism — an inescapable fact of human neurology.

I am not sure about south Asia .but for Indians it was the best thing ,trust me

 

[Zibago]

20,000 from Kashmir alone. @Zibago

That is only the post 90,s figure

 

[Khanate]

I am not sure about south Asia .but for Indians it was the best thing ,trust me

You don't even need to trust me. Just look at Zakir Naik, an Indian citizen, now marooned in Saudi Arabia despite his anti-Pakistan statements to appease Hindu hardliners of India, as @Mugwop pointed out. Pakistan is indeed the best thing to have happened.

So your are saying that the Major Gogoi should have given an order to kill all those natives?

There it is @SrNair approves of ethnic cleansing of Muslims in Kashmir.

20000 from Kashmir majority of them return as terrorists and bit the dust.

So much love for Indian minorities.

 

[SrNair]

No need to trust me, or anyone. Just look at Zakir Naik, an Indian citizen, now marooned in Saudi Arabia despite his anti-Pakistan statements to appease Hindu hardliners of India, as @Mugwop pointed out. Pakistan is indeed a blessing.





There it is @SrNair approves of ethnic cleansing of Muslims in Kashmir.




So much love for Indian minorities.

Not me ,but you .
Maj Gogoi did that to protect the local natives .He is the officer and he was in there for a mission to protect innocent people and officials .
So he can do anything to protect his people.Yet he protected both officials and local natives (he also sees them as Indian).

But you are saying they should have to shoot those people because of your own vested interests .

You don't even need to trust me. Just look at Zakir Naik, an Indian citizen, now marooned in Saudi Arabia despite his anti-Pakistan statements to appease Hindu hardliners of India, as @Mugwop pointed out. Pakistan is indeed the best thing to have happened.





There it is @SrNair approves of ethnic cleansing of Muslims in Kashmir.




So much love for Indian minorities.

Noone told them to cross border for terrorist training.

 

[kasper95]

You don't even need to trust me. Just look at Zakir Naik, an Indian citizen, now marooned in Saudi Arabia despite his anti-Pakistan statements to appease Hindu hardliners of India, as @Mugwop pointed out. Pakistan is indeed the best thing to have happened.

Again as I pointed out to @moqwop. The last thing any Indian wants is Pakistan reuniting with India.
You don't know how much respect we have for Jinnah for that.

 

[Levina]

what condition of Muslims is in India today only worse

hellooooo...theres nothign wrong with Indian muslims.
Remember APJ Abdul Kalam was our president and the man heading our intelligence bureau is also a muslim. Two key positions that will never be given to a hindu in your country. or prove me wrong.