Why Kerala has no beef with beef.

[rockstarIN]

A visit to you tube would be enlightening to those who think this is going to rest on the doorstep of the courts.

Take a look at what happens to those who transport cows for slaughter ..... makes for interesting viewing. And yes, there are no state borders for these posses.

What youtube is to do with a legal matter?

 

[doppelganger]

So what if the Muslims apply this logic and start forcing everyone not to drink alcohol or pork. Or the Jain's start forcing people to umm keep their clothes off.

No harm in trying. Would give credibility to the pushback.

But I want the cow.

You are in Pakistan. Eat a camel for all we care man.

Pork at least is more readiably available than beef. The big restaurants like Pizza Hut and Mcdonalds generally do not sell beef but sell pork. I am Lucknowi so I know. Also as I discussed finding halal is also difficult for us.

As I said, this is not an equal equal game here.

So majority of Indians meaning Hindus. So how is it a secular nation then?

Secular does not eqal to people dancing on other's balls. The more balls you dance on, the more you force the state to enact laws to prevent the same. Right now, too many balls are involved. Sadly for you, you do not have as many. Balls.

 

[45'22']

Nation wide ban is not going to happen too..

Some just got overexcited after BJP came into power and wants everything medieval..

Different parts of India have different cultures and food habits....

I dont understand why my countrymen are so sentimental on food habits of others...

Oh see poor animal, holy animal, mum like, you eat i get senti... ban it ..damn it.

After cow, we will ban fish as it was an avatar and considered to be incarnation, a god himself and then goat as it is the chariot of pushan, then we will ban chicken as its on flag of murukan/ subramanian/karthik...

We will thrash people on cow issue even if they are only transporting.., because for us cows are more important than bloody humans...

We can still eat Prawns

People are sentimental on religious issues not food issues
Why a cow slaughter is so important???

If it's banned then what difference will it make
I don't think banning is gonna create problems

Barring Kerala......most of the states will have no problem in banning the slaughter

 

[doppelganger]

What youtube is to do with a legal matter?

Everything that happens in India does not happen with due process and the sanction of law.

The impact and effect though is very real.

 

[SpArK]

We can still eat Prawns

People are sentimental on religious issues not food issues
Why a cow slaughter is so important???

If it's banned then what difference will it make
I don't think banning is gonna create problems

Barring Kerala......most of the states will have no problem in banning the slaughter

Yes.... so sad on what others do.

Cow is a pillar, the motivation, to sustain our faith... and gladly we have 500 million on them.. everywhere...

Another thought provoking fact.

The punishment for marital rape: Nil (It's legal)

The punishment for drunken driving (that causes loss of lives): 2 years

The punishment for manslaughter (which obviously costs lives): 2 years

The punishment for theft: 3 years

And the punishment for eating beef: 5 years.

Eating beef is a crime that is worse than killing someone, drunken driving, and theft.

 

[rockstarIN]

No. But some people are going to get badly hurt. Pretty soon.

Dude understand the accept the differences and move on. India is unity in diversity. Even we follow the same Hinduism, we are different...we do not celebrate Deevali or holi, but Onam and Vishu. Our style is different, culture is different.

Everything that happens in India does not happen with due process and the sanction of law.

The impact and effect though is very real.

Come on, now you speak the same way some across the border dudes. It does not happen that way.

 

[doppelganger]

Dude understand the accept the differences and move on. India is unity in diversity. Even we follow the same Hinduism, we are different...we do not celebrate Deevali or holi, but Onam and Vishu. Our style is different, culture is different.

As long as we are living on the same land, we will not allow what deeply offends us. Why don't you adjust instead? Want a national vote on the subject?

 

[45'22']

Yes.... so sad on what others do.

Cow is a pillar, the motivation, to sustain our faith... and gladly we have 500 million on them.. everywhere...

Another thought provoking fact.

The punishment for marital rape: Nil (It's legal)

The punishment for drunken driving (that causes loss of lives): 2 years

The punishment for manslaughter (which obviously costs lives): 2 years

The punishment for theft: 3 years

And the punishment for eating beef: 5 years.

Eating beef is a crime that is worse than killing someone, drunken driving, and theft.

Why eating beef is so important???
You are saying we shouldn't not on react what others do
Just for the sake of argument say I abuse Prophet.....is it okay for me to do so????
I mean it's my life and I can do whatever I feel like doing,others shouldn't have problems right???


And yes killing an animal intentionally is a crime that is worse than drunken driving or stealing money

 

[magudi]

Yes.... so sad on what others do.

Cow is a pillar, the motivation, to sustain our faith... and gladly we have 500 million on them.. everywhere...

Another thought provoking fact.

The punishment for marital rape: Nil (It's legal)

The punishment for drunken driving (that causes loss of lives): 2 years

The punishment for manslaughter (which obviously costs lives): 2 years

The punishment for theft: 3 years

And the punishment for eating beef: 5 years.

Eating beef is a crime that is worse than killing someone, drunken driving, and theft.

Why bother?

Am hearing SS had beef ban in their manifesto so the people of maha knew this when they went to polls (here's the hoping people actually read manifestos)

Isn't this a non issue for keralites

 

[doppelganger]

Why bother?

Am hearing SS had beef ban in their manifesto so the people of maha knew this when they went to polls (here's the hoping people actually read manifestos)

Isn't this a non issue for keralites

The BJP rules Maharashtra. Not the Shiv Sena.

 

[rockstarIN]

As long as we are living on the same land, we will not allow what deeply offends us. Why don't you adjust instead? Want a national vote on the subject?

How can a state or law dictate what to eat or not to? If you can adjust with akori naga babas and their life style, can't you understand others as well? And so far it is a state subject as 20 states passed the law.

But it is available everywhere where it is banned. (been to Delhi and blore, it is easily available)

 

[About.to.be.banned]

The BJP rules Maharashtra. Not the Shiv Sena.

Even then it was implicit as BJP+SS government had passed that bill in 1996. That ban was not abrogated, but de-facto suspended by Congress by not asking for Presidential assent.

 

[doppelganger]

How can a state or law dictate what to eat or not to? If you can adjust with akori naga babas and their life style, can't you understand others as well? And so far it is a state subject as 20 states passed the law.

The state is not telling you what to eat. Its telling you what you have no business eating. Perfectly legitimate. Would India or Hinduism be the first to do so?

But it is available everywhere where it is banned. (been to Delhi and blore, it is easily available)

That is a reflection of the execution and corruption. Not the validity of the law.

 

[haviZsultan]

HIndus do not eat pork too.

And BTW stop worrying about Indian and Indians. You are not Indian.

I never said I count myself as Indian.

First you tried to get accepted by Pashtoons but after they pissed on you, you have started to emphasize your ancestral Lucknawi roots.

This is an attack.

Stop trying to act like you have a stake in India and embrace your identity of Pakistani mohajir.

This is a personal attack. It is my choice which ethnic group I choose when in Pakistan. And I was born in Islamabad though both my parents are from Lucknow. I don't consider muhajir as identity. Anyway who cares. I have some limited pashtun links so I would prefer pashtun over muhajir any day. Moving from one place to another also does not make one muhajir.

No harm in trying. Would give credibility to the pushback

Well I will tell one of my cousins to try on my behalf until I can test the theory myself.

What is the pushback against btw. Oh sorry that was for evil muslims eating beef as all that is lawful to them is to be consumed in abundance by them in the Quran.

You are in Pakistan. Eat a camel for all we care man.

No you didn't get what I meant. I want beef on my plate when I come to Lucknow.

As I said, this is not an equal equal game here.

So where should the muslims be? Bottom?

Secular does not eqal to people dancing on other's balls. The more balls you dance on, the more you force the state to enact laws to prevent the same. Right now, too many balls are involved. Sadly for you, you do not have as many. Balls.

Secular equals equal rights for all, an equal, egalitarian society... perhaps many Indians do not understand the meaning of proper secularism.

 

[doppelganger]

Even then it was implicit as BJP+SS government has passed that bill in 1996. That ban was not abrogated, but de-facto suspended by Congress by not asking for Presidential assent.

My point is, do not blame a hard right party for the wishes of the people.