Why is South India paying for North India

[TheGreatMaratha]

At the time of partition Karachi population was 85% Hindu 10% Parsi 3% British and Just 2% Muslims.

Didn't know that.

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

Punjabis don't speak farsi

Yes, in old days some did. Especially in the powerful Rajput clans. Remember that the official state tongue of the Moghuls was Dari, not Urdu.

 

[Andhadhun]

Didn't know that.

All of them replaced by Mohajirs from India. Which is why the city has gone to the dogs.

 

[padamchen]

Hoshiarpur and Gurdaspur, which were Muslim majority regions (2 of the 7) given by British in India. It is on the border of Punjab and Kashmir.



Islamic countries made Parsis Ahlul Kitab, that is the religious justification.

Are koshur speaking dardic people Iranic or they come from the north?

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

*Jammu

Maqbooza Jammu and Kashmir.

 

[padamchen]

At the time of partition Karachi population was 85% Hindu 10% Parsi 3% British and Just 2% Muslims.

Don't be so eager to claim Parsi's built it. It was a Hindu trading city LONG before the parsis arrived.

The name Karachi/Kolachi is the Sindhi name of the Hindu Goddess who is known as " Hingula Devi" in India dedicated to whom there is a major Shaktipeeth in Hinglaj, Balochistan.

Dude I'm not getting into this with you again.

Obviously more Hindus will live anywhere. Look at your numbers.

By your reasoning, Bombay was also Hindu fishing villages long before the Parsis built it into a city.

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

Are koshur speaking dardic people Iranic or they come from the north?

Well, all Pakistanis have degree of Iranic blood due to Sakas, Kushans, Hepthalites.

Kashmir in particular was known to Persians as a pleasant place, hence it was a vacation destination. Many Persians settled in Kashmir due to the climate and hospitality of the people. This happened throughout the Islamic period.

However Kashmiris also have ancient Indo-Aryan blood also, like Kalash and Nuristanis. This is why they have a unique phenotype.

 

[padamchen]

Hoshiarpur and Gurdaspur, which were Muslim majority regions (2 of the 7) given by British in India. It is on the border of Punjab and Kashmir.



Islamic countries made Parsis Ahlul Kitab, that is the religious justification.

So middle East countries where Zoroastrians continue to be butchered are not Islamic countries?

Turkey is not Islamic?

Trust me, once the Maratha broke the back of foreign Mislim rule in India, our oppression in India ceased.

Even by local Muslims.

It must be the DNA and not the protective presence of the Hindus because Parsis of Pakistan even on being probed never say anything negative about your country and people.

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

In hoshiarpur your ancestors used to speak eastern Punjabi which sounds like mix of Urdu and Punjabi

Firstly, where are you from?

Secondly, that is false, our bozorg speak theeth Punjabi, actually similar to what is spoken in Faisalabad today.

Anyway, I am not getting into regionalism with you.

My bozorg spoke multiple languages, Punjabi and Dari were just the major ones.

So middle East countries where Zoroastrians continue to be butchered are not Islamic countries?

Turkey is not Islamic?

Trust me, once the Maratha broke the back of foreign Mislim rule in India, our oppression in India ceased.

Even by local Muslims.

It must be the DNA and not the protective presence of the Hindus because Parsis of Pakistan even on being probed never say anything negative about your country and people.

How did Kisra treat the messenger of Rasulullah saws? Persians were not kind to Arab emissaries, therefore caused war on themselves.

The same thing repeated years later when Xorozm Shah killed the Mongol emissary, and earned the wrath of Chingiz Khan.

 

[padamchen]

Firstly, where are you from?

Secondly, that is false, our bozorg speak theeth Punjabi, actually similar to what is spoken in Faisalabad today.

Anyway, I am not getting into regionalism with you.

My bozorg spoke multiple languages, Punjabi and Dari were just the major ones.



How did Kisra treat the messenger of Rasulullah saws? Persians were not kind to Arab emissaries, therefore caused war on themselves.

The same thing repeated years later when Xorozm Shah killed the Mongol emissary, and earned the wrath of Chingiz Khan.

The reason the ISIS genocided the Yazidis is purely religious. Not racioethnic.

That is also the core of the Turks going after the Kurds. And Alevis.

Their own blood too.

At its core Syria and Assad are also religious.

It's a Muslim and Christian and Jewish game to make the middle east out to be Muslim on Muslim genocides.

While the truth is that these are old fights, not dead, and arising once more.

For a final showdown.

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

The reason the ISIS genocided the Yazidis is purely religious. Not racioethnic.

Daesh is not Muslim, they are Khawarij. They previously killed Hazrat Ali bin Abi Talib. Khawarij means those who left (Islam.) Later Muslims had to fight them and defeat them. They were one of the religious ideologies which emerged after the death of Prophet Muhammad saws, along with Musaylimah al kazzab and other apostates, they directly challenged Madinah.

They did the same and worse to Muslims that were done to Yazidi Kurds, but Western media only reported on Yazidis and Christians.

Daesh has links outside Muslim world and their source of funding also.

That is also the core of the Turks going after the Kurds. And Alevis.

Nice fairy tale.

 

[Andhadhun]

Dude I'm not getting into this with you again.

Obviously more Hindus will live anywhere. Look at your numbers.

By your reasoning, Bombay was also Hindu fishing villages long before the Parsis built it into a city.

Karachi was a trading city, mumbai was a village that the British built into a city. Same as Chennai.

 

[padamchen]

Daesh is not Muslim, they are Khawarij. They previously killed Hazrat Ali bin Abi Talib. Khawarij means those who left (Islam.) Later Muslims had to fight them and defeat them. They were one of the religious ideologies which emerged after the death of Prophet Muhammad saws, along with Musaylimah al kazzab and other apostates, they directly challenged Madinah.

They did the same and worse to Muslims that were done to Yazidi Kurds, but Western media only reported on Yazidis and Christians.

Daesh has links outside Muslim world and their source of funding also.



Nice fairy tale.

Threads and threads if wars with Turks here.

Them ganging up in Turkish (they actually started a separate thread for me) and me gatecrashing their party with Google translate.

Choicest of abuse about my faith and ancestry.

Your countrywoman @Dubious cuddling them and banning me.

Many of those are still not deleted and still around.

Methinks @jamahir remembers.

There was a Chinese guy too.

And another with some funny flag.

Do a keyword search for Kurd, alevi, Erdogan, Zoroastrian ....

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

Threads and threads if wars with Turks here.

Them ganging up in Turkish (they actually started a separate thread for me) and me gatecrashing their party with Google translate.

Choicest of abuse about my faith and ancestry.

Your countrywoman @Dubious cuddling them and banning me.

Many of those are still not deleted and still around.

What is your panga with Turks? They had no part to play in your exodus from your holy land.

 

[padamchen]

What is your panga with Turks? They had no part to play in your exodus from your holy land.

Exactly!

They weren't even friggin there in our part of the world yet.

Yet they abuse us as if it's their blood fight.

We were building empires while they were still Mongol pastoralist horsemen.

One word ....

Islam.