Why India's military buildup in the Sino-Indian border?: China's MOD

[Roybot]

take a look in your india map...you will understand if we divert water Indus water directly to Pakistan..India will have no leverage against Pakistance but India side of Jammu will be a dead land.

Indus doesn't pass through Jammu. It passes through Ladhakh. They don't teach you goegraphy in china?


Ladakh is a cold desert as it is, doubt diverting Indus would affect anything. Residents of Ladakh will still have Shyok And Nubra rivers(fed by Sichen glacier) to live off.

You divert Indus directly to Pakistan, we divert Chenab and Ravi river. Problem solved. Not to forget that diverting the natural course/flow of the river, will devastate the already flood prone plains of Indus. Also less silt in the water, as a result the soil in food basket region of Pakistan will be not as rich anymore, which means lower agricultural output.


So yeah,

0/10 for Geography

0/10 for Strategic Logic

0/10 for Geology

10/10 for wet dreams.

 

[harshad]

We will do whenever we feel that's the right time and that we can rip a great benefit for us...we have total control of our land and water...India can't do anything about it but just sit idlely and watch if we decide to do it... you can call this as fan boy stuff if that make you feel better.

always waiting for the right time

 

[Kiss_of_the_Dragon]

Considering your map is to scale you will have to dig a 700-800Km long underground tunnel ..
Do you know what is the length longest underground man made tunnel and how much it costed??
Can you estimate the cost of this adventure?

Not only is it technologically and economically unfeasible...but so dangerous an idea to contemplate that ..its repercussion can destroy majority of Tibet region.

eg An earthquake or landslide(pretty common in Himalayan regions) causes a even tiny section of the tunnel to or even mountains to collapse ..what happens??...You end up flooding Tibet ..killing thousands of your own people.
Tiniest repair on such a tunnel will take years and cost billions.

Same as westerner said about Tibet railway, it not feasible because of earthquake but we did it with zero death.

Clearly all your talk is just hot air and has no substance in it in the real world ..I asked for something as simple as feasibility study(which is a bed rock of any project) of something you are so sure, can be done!!
Considering there is no such report ..means saner section Chinese population are not even contemplating such foolishness!!

I’m pretty sure that Chinese government has made a feasibility study about this strategic issue otherwise why invest 47 billions on Tibet water project , if an Idiot such me can imagine the diversion of Indus river to Pakistan…certainly there is more foolish than me in China with other idea on how to use water to contain India.

i think kiss of dragon has a rotten habbit,,, as soon as he sees an indian thread he imediately posts a flaming reply...with irrelevant chest bashing stuffs.. u know the saying ,, "If ignorant both of your enemy and yourself, you are certain to be in periL" -sun tzu

Water as weapon is not irrelevant, In ancient time when army siege a city first thing to do is to cut water supply to force the city to surrender. We certainly don’t want to ignore India as enemy that why a plan “B” such water as weapon is attractive option

Indus doesn't pass through Jammu. It passes through Ladhakh. They don't teach you goegraphy in china?
Ladakh is a cold desert as it is, doubt diverting Indus would affect anything. Residents of Ladakh will still have Shyok And Nubra rivers(fed by Sichen glacier) to live off.
You divert Indus directly to Pakistan, we divert Chenab and Ravi river. Problem solved. Not to forget that diverting the natural course/flow of the river, will devastate the already flood prone plains of Indus. Also less silt in the water, as a result the soil in food basket region of Pakistan will be not as rich anymore, which means lower agricultural output.
So yeah,
0/10 for Geography
0/10 for Strategic Logic
0/10 for Geology
10/10 for wet dreams.

I give you 10/10 for what you said since I don’t know much about Jammu but just don’t cry river if China effectively cut water supply to that region

 

[QDNDVN]

You think you gonna make me look bad? You pray that water is never be use as weapon…or 89 millions Vietnamese will be perform cannibalism and drink blood of each other instead and your beautiful Vietnam is nothing else but an Arab desert land.



Achieve victory with minimum lost and less effort has been in the mind of great strategist in ancient time, water is essence of life…control it will make your enemy as fast loser, any war is a sin war…don’t flatter yourself by bringing moral as way to compensate your weakness, talking about guilty and bad image: when American use nuke against Japanese or use chemical orange against north Vietnamese..did they care about Guilty and bad image…they just want to achieve victory quick and efficient.

I can not make you look bad and yet I am not capable of it, excepting you and just you made yourself looking bad due to the way your acted and the way your respond post to the other.

Ever since, during a war for two contries, no one dare to divert war or even think to polute water. It's was came from your foolish idea. Read the bold parts, those are make you realy look bad and you also made your China mother looking realy bad too.

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

I can not make you look bad and yet I am not capable of it, excepting you and just you made yourself looking bad due to the way your acted and the way your respond post to the other.

Ever since, during a war for two contries, no one dare to divert war or even think to polute water. It's was came from your foolish idea. Read the bold parts, those are make you realy look bad and you also made your China mother looking realy bad too.

Kiss_of_the_Dragon makes a lot of sense to me.

The Tibetan plateau is the source of water for most of Asia's major rivers.

 

[Roybot]

I give you 10/10 for what you said since I don’t know much about Jammu but just don’t cry river if China effectively cut water supply to that region

We won't cry we ll simply divert water(whatever water we loose) from Chenab and Ravi river.

Both the rivers originate in India, and all of the water from these two rivers is used by Pakistan as per Indus Water treaty. So you divert Indus for Pakistan, Indus the water of which is already allocated for Pakistan, we divert water from these two river. We loose nothing, Pakistan's ecology, soil composition, agriculture. China indulges in this pointless expensive exercise of diverting water, creating tunnels and canals through the Karakorum.

So, 0/10 for Planning.

0/10 for not knowing anything about Indus Water Treaty

Your report card isn't looking good mate.

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

We won't cry we ll simply divert water(whatever water we loose) from Chenab and Ravi river.

Both the rivers originate in India, and all of the water from these two rivers is used by Pakistan as per Indus Water treaty. So you divert Indus for Pakistan, Indus the water of which is already allocated for Pakistan, we divert water from these two river. We loose nothing. China indulges in this pointless expensive exercise of diverting water, creating tunnels and canals through the Karakorum.

So, 0/10 for Planning.

0/10 for not knowing anything about Indus Water Treaty

Your report card isn't looking good mate.

When you cut off water to Pakistan then they will nuke you, no question about it.

We both know that they will blame you and not us, like has always happened.

 

[Paan Singh]

When you cut off water to Pakistan then they will nuke you, no question about it.

We both know that they will blame you and not us, like has always happened.

they cant even think to do so..forget about arm chair generals here..and if it happens then china will be nuked too

 

[QDNDVN]

Kiss_of_the_Dragon makes a lot of sense to me.

The Tibetan plateau is the source of water for most of Asia's major rivers.

For you, Yes, it was perfect idea because you, KOD are similar ideas. That's why! What a shame for Han's self-complacent?

 

[Roybot]

When logic fails, they ll use nukes is the best argument

Besides i said diverting( not blocking) whatever amount of water Ladakh would loose, due to diversion of the Indus River by the chinis.

 

[QDNDVN]

When you cut off water to Pakistan then they will nuke you, no question about it.

We both know that they will blame you and not us, like has always happened.

See? you shot yourself on foot instead of shooting in a target .

Once you think you can polute and divert water, that day China got nuke too so big mess for China.

 

[patna_ke_presley]

When you cut off water to Pakistan then they will nuke you, no question about it.

We both know that they will blame you and not us, like has always happened.

Why not we nuke China when they will do the same with us.

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

they cant even think to do so..forget about arm chair generals here..and if it happens then china will be nuked too

LOL by who? India's nuke arsenal is 1 megaton vs China's nuke arsenal which is 294 megatons.

You get nuked by Pakistan, then who nukes us? India won't have any reason or the balls to do so when our counter-attack will wipe out their civilization, and after nuking Pakistan they will have to save what little arsenal they have left, to prevent a defenceless India from being invaded.

The Economist - India and Pakistan: The world's most dangerous border

 

[QDNDVN]

LOL by who? India's nuke arsenal is 1 megaton vs China's nuke arsenal which is 294 megatons.

You get nuked by Pakistan, then who nukes us? India won't have any reason or the balls to do so when our counter-attack will wipe out their civilization, and after nuking Pakistan they will have to save what little arsenal they have left, to prevent a land invasion.

The Economist - India and Pakistan: The world's most dangerous border

No India does not need to nuke China but every contries whose has nukes capable they will. Polute water and divert water that actions equal for genocide. Not war anymore kiddo.

Pakistan is smarter than you for sure, why the heck they nuke India then they got nuke back, and let China smile at them laugh like the way evil laugh?

 

[Paan Singh]

LOL by who? India's nuke arsenal is 1 megaton vs China's nuke arsenal which is 294 megatons.

You get nuked by Pakistan, then who nukes us? India won't have any reason or the balls to do so when our counter-attack will wipe out their civilization, and after nuking Pakistan they will have to save what little arsenal they have left, to prevent a defenceless India from being invaded.

The Economist - India and Pakistan: The world's most dangerous border

you are blindly supporting due to hate against india..i dont intent to write further to you...ask paksitanis better..
and u r in my ignore list now..you dont have any thing better to add other than repeating same post and write post full of delusions.