Why Hong Kong should send back ‘asylum’ seekers from India

[grey boy 2]

I believed we need to reopen the "REFUGEES CAMPS" from the Vietnamese refugees era
Lock these criminals up, isolated them from our society
http://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/...camps-be-re-opened-hong-kong-lawmakers-hijack

 

[Nilgiri]

Another sh!t storm is approaching HK way faster than we thought
The number of stateless children born to refugees is growing in Hong Kong, where claims from asylum seekers have more than tripled in the last two years, alarming residents and lawmakers.
Hong Kong has approved just 52 of more than 8,000 claims since 2009. There are more than 11,000 asylum seekers in the Asian financial hub, some still uncertain about their fate after waiting for more than 15 years.
http://www.reuters.com/article/us-world-refugeeday-hongkong-idUSKCN0Z500Y

Any breakdown of where the applicants come from origin country-wise? Both current and future projection?

 

[Jlaw]

You do realise that censuses are not done yearly right? Do you even know the difference between a census and a survey? No a census is not toilet paper, if you know how they are done. Surveys maybe (it depends).

When a newer one becomes available, we can post it then.....especially if you are dumb enough to believe data regarding education qualifications can change so drastically over 5 years or so.

i guess i can't rely on what you post either

 

[terranMarine]

Yup just replying to the statements by Jlaw and others.

BTW I agree that HK must have a good strong legal immigration/visitor process.

I feel this way for EVERY country in the world....that people should only be admitted in on THEIR terms.

So please (like many Indians themselves have already said) deport these people and have a rigid strong system that everyone must follow. HK must change its laws as needed, yes you need not be blindly following the liberal leftist west in this regard.

But Chinese members should not turn this into an overall Indian bashing thing....that too in other countries as well.

I have just posted the education data for Indians and others in HK to illustrate why its wrong to stereotype a whole population on just a small selection. I would not do it for all chinese by just a small group either (and I could do this, but I personally know its invalid to do so).

Fair enough, that's the kind of mentality we like to see from our Indian friends. IF everybody keeps flooding in every nation will collapse

 

[Jlaw]

I believed we need to reopen the "REFUGEES CAMPS" from the Vietnamese refugees era
Lock these criminals up, isolated them from our society
http://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/...camps-be-re-opened-hong-kong-lawmakers-hijack

Abandon UK commonwealth law, go back to China basic law.. UNHR will not apply. Deport these people back. end of story. HK prosper again.

 

[Nilgiri]

View attachment 330872

i guess i can't rely on what you post either

OK you got me! But technically all censuses ARE surveys....they are just a special survey that does not rely on sampling but seek to ask every member of a population. Hope its all clear in your head now.

Most surveys however do the sampling method....since a Census is expensive and time consuming.

 

[grey boy 2]

They should go to Europe for a better life. More welfare in Europe. Plus indians and others already speak english. Easier transition.

Bro, thats not necessary true, in fact a lot of them are non English speaker(dalits), and we end up paying Indians with 40000hk dollars salary to be the human translators

 

[Roybot]

@Chinese-Dragon @grey boy 2

Is there any data on these 11000 refugees in HK and what countries they come from? I doubt Indians will be even in the top 10 source countries.

Never mind, found the stats, seems like Indians do make up 20% of all the asylum seeker. I say deport them back. These people are ruining it for the rest of the Indians, mostly traders and businessman, who have visa on arrival facility in HK.


According to numbers from the city’s International Social Service branch, there are 9,900 asylum-seekers in Hong Kong, a nearly 70% increase from the beginning of 2014. Of them, about 20% each come from Pakistan and India. A further 15% are from Vietnam, 13% from Bangladesh, and 11% from Indonesia. The remainder come from other countries in southeast Asia such as Sri Lanka, and some from as far afield as Somalia, Eritrea, and the Democratic Republic of Congo.

 

[Jlaw]

Bro, thats not necessary true, in fact a lot of them are non English speaker(dalits), and we end up paying Indians with 40000hk dollars salary to be the human translators

Worse than I thought. They can't even speak their official language. Shameful!
English is easier to learn for them than Cantonese. Going to EU or Australia is best

 

[ahojunk]

Please stay away from personal insults.

I am locking this thread.