Why China will never enter Afghanistan is due to Pakistan and Turkey

[nahtanbob]

China is not interested in colonial expansion or war but only in trade. They are the communist party not the war mongering neocon party.

Look at history - all trading powers especially the size of China become military powers to secure economic interests
it is a matter of time

 

[jaybird]

It's really irrelevant talking about China entering Afghanistan when there is no chance of that happening. The only thing China will bring to Afghanistan is investment and mining cooperation with the local government (whoever it might be) when the environment is safe and stable enough to do business.

Military intervention in another country is not China's thing. PRC only did it twice in her whole history of existence. Once in the Korean war, another is Vietnam war. Both time was because ally country of China was under imminent threat of collapse. I don't see Afghanistan can ever threaten the existence of Pakistan. As Pakistan is far more advanced and stronger than Afghanistan right now. So, there is no chance of Chinese military entering Afghanistan.

 

[Titanium100]

Any part of this you do not comprehend

As far as Europe, Russia and Middle East goes you have the ocean

The world has moved on from land based trade to maritime trade after Turks captured Constantinople.
That train has left the station.

What does Turks capturing constantinople has anything to do with martime because Martime was always present..

I know the ocean is valid for them and that is how they trade or the air

 

[nahtanbob]

What does Turks capturing constantinople has anything to do with martime because Martime was always present..

I know the ocean is valid for them and that is how they trade or the air

Do you study history ? Did the Romans or Greeks sail to India around Cape of Good Hope ?

 

[Raj-Hindustani]

They have just had enough and it involves their economy and plus they are much stronger today

NO, the Pakistani economy was much better stage than now. Thanks... I m out now.. not worthy to discuss.

 

[Titanium100]

Do you study history ? Did the Romans or Greeks sail to India around Cape of Good Hope ?

They didn't have the know how but the Rashidun, umayyad, Abbasid use to.. Just because they didn't doesn't mean martime was not active.. Martime was active and flourish 8 centuries before Constinintople was taken

 

[nahtanbob]

They didn't have the know how but the Rashidun, umayyad, Abbasid use to.. Just because they didn't doesn't mean martime was not active.. Martime was active and flourish 8 centuries before Constinintople was taken

A cargo shipment from Indonesia to Greece would go by sea only part of the way
you were dependent on some land route for portion of the way

 

[Titanium100]

A cargo shipment from Indonesia to Greece would go by sea only part of the way
you were dependent on some land route for portion of the way

You should read more history on how flourish martime was in the Sahaba period which is around 6th century AD.. The Romans and greeks lacked the know how because they were from an older generations than the Sahaba period

 

[nahtanbob]

You should read more history on how flourish martime was in the Sahaba period which is around 6th century AD.. Tje Romans and greeks lacked the know how because they were from an older generations than the Sahaba period

can I avoid the land ?

 

[Paul2]

Just from the stragetic point of view..

China has good relations with Pakistan and won't risk losing it over irrelevant Afghanistan because if China was to lose Pakistan India will be let out of the pakistani choke-hold and China sees Pakistan as useful element to contain India which has been successful and cut of India from the mainland Asia. Losing this would give China to many fronts and weaken their stragetic positioning and long term planning.

China won't risk clashing with Turkey and Pakistan in Afghanistan this could be a major war and costly without stragetic value for them and the only course is to avoid it. Turkey and Pakistan are already in Afghanistan and won't allow foreign elements in the country but only them to gain their interests hence why China backs Pakistan stance on Afghanistan in that way China gets the BRI without difficulty and all her interests but Pakistan's position is Afghanistan to reach politiical settlement is strong and won't tolerate any form of foreign entity in it's backyard anymore because it destablizes also Pakistan having a war waging in your neighbour and Pakistan has learned to not repeat this again which is their new red-lines and nobody will be able to cross that red-line. Turkey's main role here is to assist Pakistan and advance her economical interests and the same with China to advance their economical interests Pakistan will allow it

China will never enter Afghanistan, because it's not that crazy.

Beijing official stance is to pay Talibunnies a king's ransom for them to leave China alone.

 

[Song Hong]

At 2017 China side had a unpaved road leading to Wakhan. Afghan side did not even has anything. The capacity of the road is very small, and direct flow of human and goods must be minimum.

 

[Daniel808]

Enter Afghanistan? And brings suffery and sadness to their civilian?

https://twitter.com/x/status/1394467077549793282

Sorry, Chinese is a Civilized Society. Please, don't drag us down to that barbaric cowboy level

 

[Leishangthem]

It is definitely not because Pakistan, turkey Or Iran.

China is having a good relationship with Pakistan almost after 2005.....

Depends on their national interest, and it suits for China then they will take a risk to enter in AF.

China was having a good relationship with Africa & Pakistan for many, many decades, China is involved in Pakistan's every core aspect ,be it in military or economic development,from nuclear programme to checking the coalition that want to label Pakistan as a nefarious state on the lvl of Libya,Iraq,Syria.
Y'all just say anything imagining from clouds.

 

[Raj-Hindustani]

China was having a good relationship with Africa & Pakistan for many, many decades, China is involved in Pakistan's every core aspect ,be it in military or economic development,from nuclear programme to checking the coalition that want to label Pakistan as a nefarious state on the lvl of Libya,Iraq,Syria.
Y'all just say anything imagining from clouds.

Pakistan - US was having a far much better relationship than PAK -China before the early 1990s.

 

[Leishangthem]

Pakistan - US was having a far much better relationship than PAK -China before the early 1990s.

Who helped Pakistan nukes programme & provided missile tech that assured Pakistan's nuclear deterrence? Pakistan still has a relationship with US just like back then,only difference is US didn't cared about Pakistan's relationship with china back then, unlike now.
The Karakoram Highway, also known as the Friendship Highway in China, was built by the governments of pk and China. It was started back in 1959 and was completed and opened to the public in 1979. Though ,the leaders of both countries were deeply collaborating since decades ago,y'all don't realize how close China and Pakistan's ruling elites are linked,you're trying to rewrite history.